Attack on Titan
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Vindicater said: Why does the Rod Reiss titan keep his face in the ground? Just so confusing. Rod's titan body mass is too much for the limbs to support. Plus the head is pretty heavy for a body part, so he can only drag it along the ground. |
| I like to think that Rod's titan form is so fucked up because he first turned when he was older than the other shifters we've seen. Uh, ignore Eren's dad. |
 |
| Gggreat episode. Didn't even realise 20 minutes passed |
| The reason why they use the serum is to not create cgi abuminations like this one that we all saw |
Julle said: If you want to read the manga you need to start this arc from the beginning. The manga and the anime are different in story and characters even though they have the same plot points...Wow, the overall animation quality is just getting worse by every season. Everything feels so lifeless now compared to season 1. And the CGI is just horrendous. No, I'm not just talking about the titans, but about people and horses as well. The movement is so rigid as well. It's like a slideshow sometimes, and this episode is a perfect example of that. The only thing that has actually gotten better animation wise is the closeups and lightning effects, but that's about it. Will probably continue reading the manga instead because I personally don't want to ruin such a good series like SnK. |
ReaperCreeper said: I like to think that Rod's titan form is so fucked up because he first turned when he was older than the other shifters we've seen. Uh, ignore Eren's dad. His titan form was also probably fucked up because he licked the fluid off the floor last episode, it was meant to be injected into the spine. Along with that he did not get the full dose. |
Parkrover said: Am I the only one who is disappointed because this scene wasn't animated? Ohhh no, you're not the only one bro. I'd love to see this scene animated too. Even could be better off with a smack in the face.... |
 |
| A good episode. Not very excited, but ok. |
| Well that titan sure was ugly... Poor dude though. Seems like people are complaining about the CGI? It wasn't that bad though imo. |
Username23489023 said: ft9dipesh said: They plan to use titan's crystal power just like how the walls were first made (apparently). The Ape titan is still around and he doesn't seem like the kind of dude that'll just let them plug up the hole. He can climb walls easily so staying up in the walls is not an option. No reason for humanity not to have tried it but with the ape titan around there's no way it would work.. If ape titan’s goal was letting other titans in, he would move the rock blocking the hole in the second wall. The rock only blocks the access to Trost district, is not a breach in the actual wall, is a breach to one of the city that acts both as bait and as first line of defense. Also, since there appeared both the armored and the colossal... you know, nobody woudl sign to go against a place where those two probably are. And the ape's plan is both to study humanity weapons against them and to capture Eren and the power of the founding titan. |
| Waifus only represent ideals |
| Eren's tears were delicious. Loved seeing him cry. Rod Reiss' 120 meter titan form looked pretty funny crawling with its disproportionate body on the land, slithering in the background while Erwin and his crew tried to figure out a way to handle it. Honestly, I don't mind the CGI. I was able to sit through an entire season of Berserk in CGI. I guess the one thing that was weird about Rod's titan form was the CGI smoke seemingly coming out of nowhere. It was just... there. Eren's hardened titan form will forever be a monument inside that cave. That side glare Mikasa shot Historia when she admitted to wanting to kill Eren just to please her father. LOL They took out the scene in the manga where Levi pulled her up in the air by her collar when she was all like, "I'm unfit for the role." How that scene is deemed inappropriate but showing dead bodies with gore is fine is beyond me. |
| 臭い- |
GangstaShiba said: Didn't think of that, but makes sense. Eh, I'll take a bit of both.ReaperCreeper said: I like to think that Rod's titan form is so fucked up because he first turned when he was older than the other shifters we've seen. Uh, ignore Eren's dad. His titan form was also probably fucked up because he licked the fluid off the floor last episode, it was meant to be injected into the spine. Along with that he did not get the full dose. |
|
Emerald_Winter said: I prefer the manga version of this episode. Eren's titan transformation was good, as for rod reiss it was okay. Also, I can't believe they brought up the queen talk in that situation and like that. They should've just followed the manga. So, 3.5/5 They couldn't. Historia was kidnapped since episode 2. |
| Historia comically trying hard to look badass. Eren crying like a little girl and mumbling shit. Mikasa... just being Mikasa (whose whole personality is nothing but being histerically obsessed by Eren) It becomes more and more annoying. I wonder whether Eren will be kidnapped for the fourth time next season. |
Nemo_NiemandSep 11, 2018 1:35 AM
 |
Metal_Ice786 said: Emerald_Winter said: I prefer the manga version of this episode. Eren's titan transformation was good, as for rod reiss it was okay. Also, I can't believe they brought up the queen talk in that situation and like that. They should've just followed the manga. So, 3.5/5 They couldn't. Historia was kidnapped since episode 2. what? I was talking about this scene |
Emerald_WinterSep 11, 2018 5:06 AM
Julle said: It is. There was a lot of things cut from this arc. The character that suffered the most cuts was Frieda. She was one of the MC in this arc influencing very deeply Historia's decisions. Another character that was downgraded was Levi. The dude was awesome in the manga but in the anime it was ok I think. The Coup d'etat was much more difficult in the manga and had more thing happening behind it. I honestly prefer the arc in the manga even though people call it boring (for some reason) but the anime is not bad either.tzarye14 said: If you want to read the manga you need to start this arc from the beginning. The manga and the anime are different in story and characters even though they have the same plot points... Wow, is that true? Sucks to hear that.. Why would they do something like that? So I suppose the manga is better then? If you want to read the manga, read this arc and then go on. I'm pretty sure that from here on the manga and the anime will be different in some aspects. |
azertz99Sep 11, 2018 7:04 AM
| "Shut up already, you topless wimp" Ha, I really like Jean. Also, after being annoying for most of season 2, I'm finally starting to appreciate Historia. In fact, even the generally stoic Mikasa found it in her to joke with Historia. Good episode. |
I've chosen my words wisely. The ape has been shown picking a 3D gear and inspecting it. Reiner and Berthold were surprised to see him, so they know him, also at the end of S2 we see his human form so is appropiate to speculate he works with them or above them. |
| Waifus only represent ideals |
GangstaShiba said: CorbanEsp said: I've chosen my words wisely. The ape has been shown picking a 3D gear and inspecting it. Reiner and Berthold were surprised to see him, so they know him, also at the end of S2 we see his human form so is appropiate to speculate he works with them or above them. While there has been evidence for speculation, you said it as definitive. CorbanEsp said: And the ape's plan is both to study humanity weapons against them and to capture Eren and the power of the founding titan. Just saying for people who don't want to see anything that may ruin their experience of the anime. But everyone's plan is to capture Eren. The whole anime up to this point can be summarized with "They took Eren". I haven't made any spoiler, not of what I've said can foreshadow anything of what will happen. You are being too picky with what's a spoiler, let people make their guesses. |
| Waifus only represent ideals |
| And another CGI titan... Also that caterpillar-like movement.. Meh... Ringo19 said: Ofc, that's why its title is 'Attack on Titan', which can also mean Attack on 'the titan', and they refer it to Eren's titan. You'll soon find out the reason why other titans are after Eren. I know that the original title is a reference to Eren's Titan, but I'm not sure if the English version was supposed to have some meaning. |
kyojin_desuSep 11, 2018 12:53 PM
 |
| Eren stepping up his game to become the #1 soyboy of anime universe. Excellent quality ahead: |
Suddenly, someone slaps you with a brick wall. |
bakuramariks said: Some really impactful scenes was removed for Levi, which was pretty disappointing. Anyone not quite on board with Levi in the first 2 seasons probably wouldn't be won over from this.I wanna be honest but that'll break my heart. I am not happy with the adaptation so far, except for 1-2 episodes. I've read this arc and it offered me so many emotions, mysteries and new stuff which i think the anime didn't offer me the same experience in gradually revealing and adding new stuff to the story. This arc made me feel the world they live in is something bigger than their lives in general. It's not because i've read the Uprising, no. Cut scenes, added stuff, changed dialogue, fast pacing... No. One of the things i am disappointed with is how WIT Studio decided for Levi to stay the same. The same, cold, unresponsive almost, badass character, but in the manga i saw his true inner world. I saw him who he truly is. He expressed emotions. Even just with his eyebrows! Besides that, anime onlies will never witness one of the best quotes from a character. I put it into spoiler tag althought this is passed gone and will never happen so anime onlies can rest assured that it won't spoil you anything not happened yet. Also, how can they change this to this How can that be?! Why?! The episode was good tho. And Rod will give me nightmares. Ezz-sama said: Woah woah chill out with the "masterpiece" word, the manga was pretty damn good this and I know it's better than the anime, but chill out with the hyperbole.Esquirtit said: I guess AoT is just garbage without action, I expected way more because I loved the 1st and 2nd season. Honestly after that retarded coup d'etat it's getting more and more stupid, I hope the next arc will have some great action again like people say Read this arc from the manga and you will know it's masterpiece here in the anime it's mediocre DirentaSkeet said: I'm not particularly annoyed at the CGI and I feel people tend to overreact to CGI, but the state of the industry shouldn't be a factor when critising anime. If I'm genuinely annoyed at something, I'll point it out even if I understand why it's like that.For anyone complaining about the CGI, please be mindful of the current situation in Japan where animators are underpaid, making only 10k$ a year with a recent survey. I do tend to notice CGI, but it doesn't tend to be that bad. It only really pisses me off when they have bad CGI, yet having panning shorts with the crappy CGI as the main focus. |
| If your favourite character is Tsutsukakushi Tsukiko, you are my soul mate. Been a long time since I've been here, I'll continue expressing myself freely and believe everyone should too. My MAL Interview |
| I had a really horrible impression on that CGI. Shocking. Deeply disliked it. Anyway, I guess (hope) it's due to lack of money. |
| Jeez that Titan is terrifying. Imagine the difficulty drawing that thing frame by frame. |
| Mankind knew that they cannot change society. So instead of reflecting on themselves, they blamed the beasts. |
| Rod looked like a giant mega skinned Scorpion. I liked Eren's aftermath carcass or corpse, it was magically beautiful. I see Historian has agreed to be the queen and hey don't punch Levi. Levi is still the best, I hope he gets Kenny. Thank you Writers of AOT, for a bit of focus on Levi. |
How I learned to stop worrying and love the bomb --- Dr Strangelove  |
Master_Yoma said: He looks good chained up. What a waste of an MC, he sucks him and that Historia chick.Eren was a lot better chained up |
| How I learned to stop worrying and love the bomb --- Dr Strangelove |
Julle said: I don't think that they are skipping things. Isayama always said that the anime is the final version of the story and most of what they cut from Frieda involved the Founding Titan too. It's like he's trying to retcon some things from this arc while trying to make it more interesting and engaging. Keep in mind that the anime and manga are two different stories even though they use the same plot ploints as reference.tzarye14 said: It is. There was a lot of things cut from this arc. The character that suffered the most cuts was Frieda. She was one of the MC in this arc influencing very deeply Historia's decisions. Another character that was downgraded was Levi. The dude was awesome in the manga but in the anime it was ok I think. The Coup d'etat was much more difficult in the manga and had more thing happening behind it. I honestly prefer the arc in the manga even though people call it boring (for some reason) but the anime is not bad either. If you want to read the manga, read this arc and then go on. I'm pretty sure that from here on the manga and the anime will be different in some aspects. Thanks a lot man, really appreciate this! Sucks that I started watching this third season instead of reading it, as they're skipping out on important things. I actually felt that Frieda had very little developement, and actually wanted to see more of her. I can see why people find this arc boring. It's probably just because it doesn't have as much action. But I personally don't care about that. I found this arc to be very interesting, but yeah, the animation quality is not holding up well. I'll definitely read the manga before the anime from now on, since they seem to go in a different direction. Why are they even changing the direction to start with? That's just stupid if you ask me. It's like they're toying around with the series. Anyways, thanks again mate, I'll definitely start this all over again, but with the manga this time. Cheers! |
| kick the runt historia ! jk love levi |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I cant wait for the next episode. What will Erwin's plan be? |
 |
| well that came to a closing end.. histeria in a hot spot again |
 |
Katsu_54 said: Raging-Man said: The cgi was awful, way to ruin the flow of a good season. what make you find CGI animation so bad ? the CGI was horrible, just admit it, also its a recurrent thing since season 2 but they are also making the horses CGI. This season could have been easily a 10 but these minor mistakes are what makes this a 9. Manga is still a 10 for me. |
 |
| Sort of dissapointed to not see Levi grabbing historia and forcing her to become queen as in the manga. Then, Mikasa's response would have made much more sense. But hey, this episode was amazing nonetheless. I'm really getting a feel for this anime again, after this great deal of exposition. I never expected this series honestly, but I'm just nutting at the fact that this is going to be 24 episodes. |
Emerald_Winter said: I prefer the manga version of this episode. Eren's titan transformation was good, as for rod reiss it was okay. Also, I can't believe they brought up the queen talk in that situation and like that. They should've just followed the manga. So, 3.5/5 I haven't read the manga. What happened there? And yeah, while this episode was okay, that small-talk about being a queen was kinda dull. I think the creators wanted it to sound like "hehe Levi is still cool and Historia's situation is epic", but it looked average to me. Not bad, but not good either. About the episode itself: wow, Rod Reiss is HUGE. ;D |
| somehow, i think that rod reiss is just a parody of rothschild. Titan secret society ... wtf |
Julle said: Modernoir said: I think you're being too hard on the series tbh. The Uprising arc was notorious because it brought down the sales of the series by quite a bit because of how slow and thorough the arc was. The Uprising arc was far more detailed in the manga, but you have to understand that this also brought a lot of issues, Isayama himself (the author) is the one who's confirmed to have made the changes to Uprising for the anime and he's given his approval for it too. While being able to read the series makes info-heavy chapters a bit easier to manage, turning that into an anime would have been WAY harder, we'd have been going at a glacial pace from episode 1 onwards if they didn't change things around. As a result, we may have lost a lot of smaller, more nuanced moments, but thanks to it the pacing of the arc has been far faster while still keeping the essential scenes and even delivering them to even greater effect than the manga (Historia's scene where she rejected the serum was handled so perfectly I can't begin to gush about it. They even added a Kenny vs Levi fight scene in the cave, which was a way smarter move since Kenny's only "hurrah" in the manga was his first fight with Levi.) I think when the season continues people will be less critical of how the anime has handled the Uprising arc, since the next arc REALLY deserves the majority of this season's episodes. It's going to be fantastic if they pull things through well. Though overall I hope you consider what I'm saying, they didn't just cut things because they wanted to, there's a lot of things you have to consider when adapting a manga to an anime and I think the cuts they've made for Uprising have been justified overall as a result. If you want my opinion, I think you should stick to the anime, there's so much the anime does that highlights and improves upon the source material that I think you'd be better off continuing with the anime. (Or a better idea, read the manga alongside the anime so you can enjoy them both.) Very informative, thanks a lot! I had no idea about all that (about the uprising arc). What did you personally enjoy more? I'm not gonna drop the anime, just had this thought that maybe it would be better if I read things first, before continuing with the anime. The only downside however, is that I won't be able to enjoy the anime as much. But yeah, the animation is bugging me a lot nowdays. Maybe I'm being too hard on the series like you say. But Shingeki started off really well with the animation, and then it just got worse, and worse. I suppose it makes the flaws stand out more by going in a direction like this. It would've been better if it started off with worse animation and improved in time, instead of the opposite direction.. So is the next arc already gonna start this season? Isn't this season gonna be just like 12-13 episodes, like last season? I've heard so many people being hyped over the next arc, is it really that good? Would you say it could compete with the previous arcs? A lot of questions at the same time lol! Thanks again! Most probably yes, because this season is a 2 cour and there's like 24+ episodes in total. The next arc is quite a finale. More epic than Season 1's Annie v Eren finale, and more epic than Season 2's 4 Titan Shifter/Erwin finale. It'll probably also reveal the massive world spoilers that manga readers have been hiding for a great while. |
 |
Adnash93 said: Emerald_Winter said: I prefer the manga version of this episode. Eren's titan transformation was good, as for rod reiss it was okay. Also, I can't believe they brought up the queen talk in that situation and like that. They should've just followed the manga. So, 3.5/5 I haven't read the manga. What happened there? And yeah, while this episode was okay, that small-talk about being a queen was kinda dull. I think the creators wanted it to sound like "hehe Levi is still cool and Historia's situation is epic", but it looked average to me. Not bad, but not good either. About the episode itself: wow, Rod Reiss is HUGE. ;D |
Hmm, then it was more complex and realistic to be honest. Anime took it kind lightly, at least I had that kind of a feeling while watching this episode. I put half of my post in a spoiler bracket, just in case. ;p |
| Historia's character development has been a thing of beauty. I wonder what Erwin's plans are for holding off Rod Reiss...? |
  |
| In this season Historia is becoming more badass. Also Eren has big changes too. He is in an emotional mode more than a rage mode. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 14, 2018 |
447 |
by SuhSun4
»»
Feb 2, 12:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 2, 2018 |
329 |
by Nevcara
»»
Jan 7, 3:11 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 16, 2018 |
190 |
by Antonio2021124
»»
Dec 31, 2024 7:47 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Oct 7, 2018 |
247 |
by CocoaGalaxy
»»
Dec 27, 2024 12:40 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Sep 23, 2018 |
215 |
by CocoaGalaxy
»»
Dec 26, 2024 2:31 PM |