DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- great end. Matsuzawa's confession was awesome. despte the somewhat open endness of the ending, I still call this a victory for team Matsuzawa. Overall, this is one amazing manga. I just love it. Easily gets a 10 from me. i guess all thats left is a coulpe of side stories. |
 |
| Meh... This was such a great manga and then everything went lop-sided for me when Tamura did a 180, last chapter. Ending was so-so but nothing was resolved. Yeah they both love tamura... so what... is that it? Now all that's left are some extras, which will most likely be about that guy and his sister (-_-)... |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| so so chapter, i dont like ending when there is no visible get-together... |
| The open-ended ending is great! If anyone has a chance of getting both girls, then our Tamura-kun is the right man for the job! xD This is definitely a victory for the Matsuzawa camp, but the Souma camp is definitely not down for the count! There is a chance that was provided to us with the open-ending, same with the grandiose harem ending! xD Chapter wise, that was a great confession by Matsuzawa. I could feel the thrill and the tension as Tamura looked for Matsuzawa to her eventual confession. Need an anime ova! |
| I thought it was a good ending. Makes me wonder if there will be any continues to it about what happen afterwards. |
| Good ending. It was not what i expected, but it was still good. A shame that he didn't end with Souma, i really liked her. But, well, i like Matsuzawa too. I decided when i was at chapter 15, that i would give it a 9-10/10 if Tamura ended up with Souma, and 8/10 if he ended up with Matsuzawa. But i'll give it a 9/10, because this is a manga that i really enjoyed reading, checking out every day to see if the scanlator released the next chapter. I give my congratulations to all the staff of SCX-Scanlations for the excelent job, even though there are still the extras to be released. |
     |
| I liked the ending of the manga. I was always rooting for Matsuzawa! :D But I was disappointed that the ending didn't show who Tamura was gunna be with. But we do know that he chose Matsuzawa! =w= But it could lead into another series! This would be a good anime too. Like a short OVA Out of all: 9/10 |
| THAT was teh ending? but i thought there were supposed to be 24 chapters but it ended on 20.... =_= |
 |
| didn't like the last comment on Tamura from the girls, it was just werid :S wonder what's next? (of side stories) possibly a future thing |
| Do I sense... the acceptance of polygamy here!? Well, no just kidding, but that wasn't quite conclusive, but man, what a good satisfactory ending that sat on the fence there! |
| Ehhhh. It was okay. But this is one open ended finish I could do without. |
<div style="text-align:right;"> </div> |
| Maybe i'm over-reacting here therefore i'm keepimg my first words under a spoiler, which in this case, they ain't. Kamadaki said: Perfect wording.Ehhhh. It was okay. But this is one open ended finish I could do without. This was double F*-up. It was an ending, but not an ending. He "choose" but it still was an open ending. Is that some type of thing to make it look not so clichêd? "Look, its and ending, but for f* sake we are also leaving an open ending at the same time! Look! How fresh can this get?!" WAY TOO LOUSY! DOUBLE PHAILURE! If they wanted a heartwarming ending, they PHAILED BADDLY! Whats the problem in making an real ending in first place?! You know, he choosen that girl, so for christ sake make he end with her, or simply kill him already! lol Open-endings are so ....... made of phailure..... I can only list like 2 or 3 mangas where the guy actually chooses someone and goes for it. Is it so hard to do it? An real ending? I phail when it comes tu suppress my emotions and writte something not so emotion biased, usually ending up offending someone. So in advance im posting this: I'm very sorry if my post offended you in any manner. That was not my objective. |
voidbringer said: THAT was teh ending? but i thought there were supposed to be 24 chapters but it ended on 20.... =_= If I'm guessing right, I believe that number includes the extra chapters involving the Tamura's friend and his sister. |
| Well, a 7 would be to cheap, and a 8 would be tad to good, but im going to give it a 8/10. |
 |
| Shit that was it? gah.... i wanted more =( 8/10 i wanted more. |
  |
| Beautiful ending (though it really didn't seem like an ending, thinking on the fact that Tamura really didn't choose one or the other. Though it would hurt for the other either way). Overall a great series for me and I give a 10/10. Kinda hoping for an OVA or maybe even a continuation to the series (seeing as though this can somewhat be continued off of and kinda curious to see what happens next?). |
 |
| great end. Matsuzawa's confession was awesome. despte the somewhat open endness of the ending, I still call this a victory for team Matsuzawa. Overall, this is one amazing manga. I just love it. Easily gets a 10 from me. I want more DX |
 |
| I hate open-ended endings. I was rooting for Souma, but I would of enjoyed this manga more if Tamura was more decisive. |
| Hmm.. what's with chapters 21-24? Oh nevermind, 20 chapters, 4 special chapters! About the manga.. I enjoyed the majority of it, but some parts of the love-triangle bit almost made me stop reading. The ending was actually better than I expected after it was clear that he would chose Matsuzawa. |
AwesmoeNov 23, 2009 1:16 PM
     |
| Why so open-ended? 8/10 still though, much better than other generic harem manga and anime out there. |
| ahh what a geat manga. though dissapointed that he didnt end up with souma, but oh well, 10/10! worth my time! |
  |
| This ending... eh.. It wasn't a solid ending so it lowered the score. I wish they would atleast kiss... I wish he would end up with Souma. |
| I love how this manga kept making me switch between who I wanted to get Tamura. Overall I loved Souma most, she showed the most affection so I felt bad for her. Great manga. Ending wasn't THAT BAD. We're all annoyed when we don't get what we want. Ahh, shounen romance really is best. My type of manga. |
| That was actually pretty good open ending but Souma really got the short end of the stick right here. She sacrificed and did a lot for Tamura. I know Matsuzawa has a robotic personality (that's why I like her and she's cute that way) and she isn't that good at expressing her feelings but I believe their relationship lacked something, some sort of interaction. That's why long distance relationship always doesn't not work. Overall, I felt it was rushed on Matsuzawa's side and it's a bit cruel for Souma so 8/10. I was about to personally give this a 9 or 10 but given that kind of ending, I was forced to lower it a bit but then again, as I said, it's still a pretty good ending. |
-QuasarJan 9, 2011 6:43 AM
| Ehhhh i gave this a 6 he should have picked Souma! |
| Wow what the fuck, obviously Souma was the better choice. Dumbass leads. :( |
 |
ayeyosteven said: Wow what the fuck, obviously Souma was the better choice. Dumbass leads. :( I totally agree with you 100%. SOUMA!!!!!! I feel sorry for her. |
| I read Manga in both English and Chinese. |
| It's really hard to choose... i still don't know who will i pick hmm... i still don't know (>_<) Ice Queen vs Lunar Bunny, for the love of Dr. Insect |
| i actually really like this ending.. it ties in with the whole "Watashitachi no Tamura-kun" title.. wouldn't make sense if someone clearly won.. since throughout the entire thing before the ending, no one really owns Tamura.. so "Our Dear Tamura-kun" could only result to such an ending.. |
| Great ending tbh although Matsuzawa should of kissed Tamara :P Oh well, it was a nice pleasant ending with resolutions. I wonder who he ultimately chose @ the end. Personally, I like both characters as they both have good qualities just presented differently. Anyways, it was a nice ride. 8/10 |
 |
| I burned through this in two days! I pretty much read the whole thing today at lunch and then after I got home. It was wonderful! Yuyuko Takamiya is such a great writer! Her characters are always vibrant and real, even when they do things that are out of the ordinary. In these characters, I can clearly see the seeds of some of the great characters to come in her work, like Taiga and Minori from Toradora!; Hotaka and Nika from Evergreen; and especially Kouko from Golden Time. Though each of these characters is different, the two three main characters in this manga really seem to be like building blocks from which you could create the other characters from. |
Now blogging at TheZenOf Mysterious Girlfriend X Anime Fan Club - It's about more than drool! Tari Tari Fan Club - Hyouka Fan Club - Chitanda Eru Fans Club~ |
| It was a nice story, and very typical. But I enjoyed because it was the first story that I was rooting for both girls because I loved Matsuzawa and Souma, since I usually support one. |
  |
| This wasn't really half bad. Loved it! 8/10 from me. Loved both girls. |
Live, Laugh, Love.  |
Faust721 said: wait ... what??great end. Matsuzawa's confession was awesome. despte the somewhat open endness of the ending, I still call this a victory for team Matsuzawa. Overall, this is one amazing manga. I just love it. Easily gets a 10 from me. i guess all thats left is a coulpe of side stories. I know that I have read this manga 3 years ago, but from what I remembered it was an ending where he chose no one... |
| My Reviews and Rants: http://bunny1ov3r.wordpress.com/ 痛就是爱 |
| Having re-read the ending after 4 years or so, I started to wonder... How the fuck did the 16-year-old me interpret the ending as one where the protagonist ends up with no one...? It was sort of harem-ending but clearly oriented toward Komaki. Maybe having been in relationships changed my perspectives on things. |
| My Reviews and Rants: http://bunny1ov3r.wordpress.com/ 痛就是爱 |
| wtf! He should let go Matsuzawa and go out with Souma, stupid ending. |
| Rereading this. Just realized that Souma never saw Matsuzawa in person, just heard her voice. I still like the open ending, because choosing one person over another would've made me really sad. |
| I read Manga in both English and Chinese. |
| Tamura no Baka. Poor Souma. T_T |
 |
| I'm happy with the ending but it's like True Tears again. I feel bad for Souma, she was such a nice girl and so supportive of Tamura. |
| It was a 8/10 for me up until Tamura became indecisive. It ended as a 6/10 for me just because I hated the ending , and I would have been fine with Matsuzawa as a choice had it been SHOWN and not implied. I still think Hiroka should have been the one to end up with Tamura tbh. This ending just really , really left a bitter taste in my mouth. |
| It's a rare feeling. To be disappointed in an ending where the girl I wanted to win had won. |
 |
| What's up with that half-assed ending... Really enjoyed this manga until the last few chapters :/ |
 |
| Noo why it must be an open ending. I hope Tamura choose someone in the end. Anyone read the LN maybe know the ending pls tell me |
| The confession from Matsuzawa was great. If only she went and kissed him. A satisfying ending. Even though it was implied that it was a win for Matsuzawa, I would have liked if he actually chose her. 9/10. |
 |
| Felt like nothing happened in this manga lol |
| Even when I was in crowd, I was always alone |
More topics from this board
» A Charming Japanese manga and anime seriesHenrycavill1 - Aug 18, 2023 |
1 |
by Henrycavill1
»»
Aug 18, 2023 4:05 AM |
|
» Watashitachi no Tamura-kun Chapter 20.5 DiscussionHawthorneKitty - Mar 15, 2009 |
3 |
by Leo
»»
Dec 27, 2017 3:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Tamura-kun Chapter 19 DiscussionFaust721 - Nov 15, 2008 |
11 |
by Leo
»»
Dec 27, 2017 2:28 PM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Tamura-kun Chapter 18 DiscussionFaust721 - Nov 14, 2008 |
14 |
by Leo
»»
Dec 27, 2017 2:19 PM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Tamura-kun Chapter 17 DiscussionFaust721 - Nov 14, 2008 |
13 |
by Leo
»»
Dec 27, 2017 1:53 PM |