Best Girl
Utaha
29.7%
184
Megumi
62.7%
388
Eriri
6.0%
37
Michiru
1.3%
8
Izumi
0.3%
2
619 votes
| As much as I like Megumi as main girl and how the story revolves around her, is she really the best girl though? |
  |
| Well it’s not a surprise. Personally, if you take into account, popularity polls, manga and LN reception, the one that comes on top is Utaha. If you have read the LNs is even more apparent that this was more of a love triangle rather than a harem, despite the amount of girls in the cast. At the end of the day, this was Megumi’s story so with that much plot armor it was impossible for her to lose but if she wasn’t so one sidedly benefited by the author and it was a little bit more balanced Utaha should have won everyday. Oddly enough, that was also the point the story was attempting to convey. Tomoya needed normal and he couldn’t get that from Utaha, even though she never wanted to be idolized or worshipped by him, the irony was that the thing that brought them together was also the thing that separated them. Utaha was too broken in every aspect and that’s why she didn’t win. She has her own spin-off that’s satisfying AF though. Utaha is the best girl in the story, if this wasn’t Megumi ‘s story... |
 |
| katou sama anyday🛐 and this is coming from a major stockings fan. |
| Utaha is the only correct answer. |
 |
RandomGuyScott said: Well it’s not a surprise. Personally, if you take into account, popularity polls, manga and LN reception, the one that comes on top is Utaha. If you have read the LNs is even more apparent that this was more of a love triangle rather than a harem, despite the amount of girls in the cast. At the end of the day, this was Megumi’s story so with that much plot armor it was impossible for her to lose but if she wasn’t so one sidedly benefited by the author and it was a little bit more balanced Utaha should have won everyday. Oddly enough, that was also the point the story was attempting to convey. Tomoya needed normal and he couldn’t get that from Utaha, even though she never wanted to be idolized or worshipped by him, the irony was that the thing that brought them together was also the thing that separated them. Utaha was too broken in every aspect and that’s why she didn’t win. She has her own spin-off that’s satisfying AF though. Utaha is the best girl in the story, if this wasn’t Megumi ‘s story... I totally agree my man, i'm glad to read what you wrote. |
|
| not a big fan of the show but utaha senpai is on another level. the onee-san vibes. god. |
 |
Dragevard said: As much as I like Megumi as main girl and how the story revolves around her, is she really the best girl though? Utaha from the very start of this show. There was never any contest. MxS7HGS said: If I was Tomoya, it'd be impossible to choose. I don't want to tie myself with just one woman. Harem route all the way! Harem route is the way of real men throughout history |
CarbonMDJan 18, 2022 2:37 AM
 |
| Finally got around to watching this. Honestly, Megumi went down a level for me after watching. Utaha and Eriri definitely better girls. Utaha being my #1 with Eriri a very close 2nd. I mean they say it in the movie, he only chose Megumi because she's basic compared to the other two. Abysmal_Saint76 said: RandomGuyScott said: About that go and check any of the popularity poll you will never found Utaha topping Megumi whilst Megumi even appears in top 10 most popular girl whilst Utaha is nowhere to found. Even in MAL she is way behind Kato. I don't know which poll did you find Utah being popular over Megumi. Also he was in love with Megumi from his 1st meeting with her whilst he continuously rejected Utah. She even betrayed him. You are being salty since your stocking girl didn't win, just admit it. There's not even a love triangle to begin with when he didn't even love Utah and LN ended up with tomoya confessing his love to Megumi and she is the only one for him, finally kissing her. In movie they got engaged possibly marriage and living together. He loved Utah as a author not as a girl. She did steal the kiss but that also he didn't reciprocate. Why plot armour when he already fall in love with Megumi on very 1st sight and of course she is the titular main heroine so the ending was obvious. You guys just turned blind eyes. Well it’s not a surprise. Personally, if you take into account, popularity polls, manga and LN reception, the one that comes on top is Utaha. If you have read the LNs is even more apparent that this was more of a love triangle rather than a harem, despite the amount of girls in the cast. At the end of the day, this was Megumi’s story so with that much plot armor it was impossible for her to lose but if she wasn’t so one sidedly benefited by the author and it was a little bit more balanced Utaha should have won everyday. Oddly enough, that was also the point the story was attempting to convey. Tomoya needed normal and he couldn’t get that from Utaha, even though she never wanted to be idolized or worshipped by him, the irony was that the thing that brought them together was also the thing that separated them. Utaha was too broken in every aspect and that’s why she didn’t win. She has her own spin-off that’s satisfying AF though. Utaha is the best girl in the story, if this wasn’t Megumi ‘s story... You got me wanting to read... |
| Utaha's betrayal killed everything. I didn't care much for Eriri. It's an easy win for Megumi , he shouldn't even be friends with the other 2 hoes , but can't expect much from a beta cuck mc |
| The choice between Magumi and Utaha is really hard. But if I want to choose one of them, I prefer Utaha senpai more |
 |
| what the hex Izumi? |
こんにちは！私の名前はマルハザクです！  こんにちは！私の名前はマルハザクです！ |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Saenai Heroine no Sodatekata Fine Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )shanimebib - Oct 26, 2019 |
221 |
by Thyriad-oPPailov
»»
Dec 14, 10:03 AM |
|
» Best girl? My thoughts after the movieMilly1227 - Sep 19, 2022 |
31 |
by Nathan_Murphy
»»
Nov 14, 2:12 AM |
|
» Question for LN readersRonninn - Jun 1 |
1 |
by ArashikageX
»»
Jun 1, 9:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Have they faithfully adapted the LN? (No spoilers allowed unless BBCoded properly)CrazyButNot4U - Apr 24 |
2 |
by TraipsingShadow
»»
Apr 24, 9:59 AM |
|
» Loved This Showflakor8 - Apr 2 |
9 |
by GarixKun
»»
Apr 3, 6:14 PM |