| So far we got no harem. All the romance involves other characters that are not the male mc which is like the friend in a romance vn. |
 |
| Makeine is an anti-harem because the girls around the male protagonist are romantically interested in other guys instead of him. |
No, this isn't my signature-desu. |
A-lil-weeb-dog said: Is it a harem? If it is then I won't watch it Not a harem, and does not look like it will be at all. There is a little chemistry with Anna and Nukumizu but at this point in time there are no romantic feelings between them. Think of it as this way, the main character acts like the guy girls talk to about their love ones. So he’s basically friendzoned which is about as far from harem as it can get. |
A-lil-weeb-dog said: @A-lil-weeb-dog it's quite sad that this is your only train of thought getting into this show, but I don't blame you for thinking it like so.Is it a harem? If it is then I won't watch it It's a friendship harem, though obviously love and romance are related, but not to the MC and his rejected girls. |
 |
| The show is keeping it vague if the main character is even going to have a love interest let alone a harem, both are plausible but not really hinted at. Itys really he just happens to be around a bunch of people who got heartbroken, |
Immahnoob said: Jizzy, I know you have no idea how to argue for shit, tokiyashiro said: Jizzy as you would call yourself because youre a dick The most butthurt award goes to you And clearly you havent watched that many shows thats why you cant determine if a show is unique or not Or maybe you're just a child who likes common stuffs where hero saves the day and guys gets all the girls. Sad taste you have there kid you came up to me in the first place making you look more like a kid who got slapped without me even knowing it and start crying about it to me |
| I could once again remind you that this is not a harem and does not intend to be one, but God, how tired I am of harem phobia. Especially from people who try to pretend to be weebs. @KANLen09 I once thought the same thing about Akebi, lmao. But all jokes aside, I think Anna is a pretty obvious choice for a central love interest. |
 |
A-lil-weeb-dog said: Is it a harem? If it is then I won't watch it Then don’t watch it and do everyone a favor and go away. |
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
I could once again remind you that this is not a harem and does not intend to be one, but God, how tired I am of harem phobia. Especially from people who try to pretend to be weebs.
@KANLen09 I once thought the same thing about Akebi, lmao. But all jokes aside, I think Anna is a pretty obvious choice for a central love interest.
I could once again remind you that this is not a harem and does not intend to be one, but God, how tired I am of harem phobia. Especially from people who try to pretend to be weebs.
@KANLen09 I once thought the same thing about Akebi, lmao. But all jokes aside, I think Anna is a pretty obvious choice for a central love interest.
who's so desperate that they'd pretend to be a weebs? that's the most pathetic shit I've ever heard in my life. Don't my username fool you either, it's meant to be ironic.
And that's the first time I've ever heard of "harem phobia". Like people hate harem for a reason. They just like monogamy more.
| @A-lil-weeb-dog "ironic", yes, of course. Monogamy? Um, dude, you know that harem anime have nothing to do with polyamory or polygamy, right? But at least now you will know what the bias is called for people like you who constantly complain about harems. |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
rsc-pl said:
Then don’t watch it and do everyone a favor and go away.
A-lil-weeb-dog said:
Is it a harem? If it is then I won't watch it
Is it a harem? If it is then I won't watch it
Then don’t watch it and do everyone a favor and go away.
pathetic bait, try to be a lil more intelligent next time
| @A-lil-weeb-dog Your thread is a pathetic bait, so as I said, go away ironic “fan” |
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
| @A-lil-weeb-dog You literally created a thread to ask if it's a harem, directly indicating that you won't watch it if it's a harem. And as I hinted above, harem anime has nothing to do with polyamorous relationships. Only people not familiar with the genre may not like harem because of this. |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog You literally created a thread to ask if it's a harem, directly indicating that you won't watch it if it's a harem. And as I hinted above, harem anime has nothing to do with polyamorous relationships. Only people not familiar with the genre may not like harem because of this.
@A-lil-weeb-dog You literally created a thread to ask if it's a harem, directly indicating that you won't watch it if it's a harem. And as I hinted above, harem anime has nothing to do with polyamorous relationships. Only people not familiar with the genre may not like harem because of this.
people don't like harem because they don't like harem that is all there is to it. I don't like harem either, that's why when I see an anime that's eye catching but the promotional material shows something similar to harem, I ask the ones who have watched it so that I wouldn't get unrealistic expectations of it. I didn't even say harem is bad or this show is bad, I said I don't like harem because I don't enjoy harem shows, are we clear?
| @A-lil-weeb-dog So, why don't you like harems? But without all this about “because I prefer monogamy”. |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog So, why don't you like harems? But without all this about “because I prefer monogamy”.
@A-lil-weeb-dog So, why don't you like harems? But without all this about “because I prefer monogamy”.
That's one reason, I prefer monogamy because I like it.
Similar to how I prefer a Sprite over a kelp shake, because I like Sprite.
Get it? Are we clear now?
| @A-lil-weeb-dog No, because you haven't explained how harem anime contradict the idea of monogamy. Shouldn't the MC choose one single girl at the end of most of these shows? How is this polygamous? If you have multiple girls crushes on you, does that make you polyamorous? Or are you one of those people who think that gay crushing of one character on the other makes both characters gay? |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog No, because you haven't explained how harem anime contradict the idea of monogamy. Shouldn't the MC choose one single girl at the end of most of these shows? How is this polygamous? If you have multiple girls crushes on you, does that make you polyamorous? Or are you one of those people who think that gay crushing of one character on the other makes both characters gay?
@A-lil-weeb-dog No, because you haven't explained how harem anime contradict the idea of monogamy. Shouldn't the MC choose one single girl at the end of most of these shows? How is this polygamous? If you have multiple girls crushes on you, does that make you polyamorous? Or are you one of those people who think that gay crushing of one character on the other makes both characters gay?
bruh, Ok. You thought all of that up in your own head. I literally said none of that.
But if you want to hear what I think, then fine. Here goes:
Harem has 2 types, the one where the guy gets to choose one girl at the end of the show, that's Monogamy, the other one where he plays with all of them at the same time, that's polygamy.
So, the reason why I don't like harem as a whole is because I like Monogamy, which admittedly, Monogamy includes the first one. But, and a big BUT here. Personally for me and many others, we don't like seeing many girls fighting over one guy, or many guys fighting over one girl. What we like is 2 main characters and their story, and how they end up together.
Which leads to this: I don't like Harem because it doesn't suit my taste, you can't force me to watch something I don't like. That's why I ask before watching a new show, so I won't be disappointed when it turns out to be something I don't like. Are we absolutely clear here?
| @A-lil-weeb-dog So, you don't like the whole genre, while admitting that only part of it doesn't suit your tastes? Ookay, can you give me examples of polygamous harems and why you think that outweighs "monogamous harems" as you said? |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog So, you don't like the whole genre, while admitting that only part of it doesn't suit your tastes? Ookay, can you give me examples of polygamous harems and why you think that outweighs "monogamous harems" as you said?
@A-lil-weeb-dog So, you don't like the whole genre, while admitting that only part of it doesn't suit your tastes? Ookay, can you give me examples of polygamous harems and why you think that outweighs "monogamous harems" as you said?
bruh did you NOT read what I wrote? When Did I say I like the Monogamy Harems? I said, and pay attention I don't like seeing people fighting with eachother over someone and that's what monogamy harems are, so that's why I don't like either kind of harem. Any more questions?
| @A-lil-weeb-dog I never said that you like monogamous harems. So I can direct your question about reading to you yourself. I just asked a question about the fact that you first state that you don’t like harems because of monogamy, but then you state that some harems are still monogamous. And you still haven't answered what makes harems polygamous. |
RobertBobertSep 1, 3:03 AM
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog I never said that you like monogamous harems. So I can direct your question about reading to you yourself. I just asked a question about the fact that you first state that you don’t like harems because of monogamy, but then you state that some harems are still monogamous. And you still haven't answered what makes harems polygamous.
@A-lil-weeb-dog I never said that you like monogamous harems. So I can direct your question about reading to you yourself. I just asked a question about the fact that you first state that you don’t like harems because of monogamy, but then you state that some harems are still monogamous. And you still haven't answered what makes harems polygamous.
bruh, the first statement of mine was missing some information. It didn't explain fully because I didn't intend to at that point. But now that I have, are we clear why I made this thread now?
| @A-lil-weeb-dog There is nothing wrong with not liking love drama and conflict. But what does this have to do with monogamy and polygamy? Not to mention you'll also find a ton of this in completely non-harem shows, harems don't have a monopoly on love conflicts. |
|
| @Azeyuntolo because I find his argumentation very strange and as if demonstrating a complete lack of understanding of how the thing he dislikes so much works. @A-lil-weeb-dog Stop, stop. So you don't like polygamy or love conflicts? These things have no direct connection. And you still haven’t named me a single polygamous harem, which is why I can’t even understand why you think polygamy is meta for harems. Because of love conflicts? But there is a lot of this outside of harems and it is not directly related to polygamy as such. |
RobertBobertSep 1, 3:15 AM
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
Azeyuntolo said:
I'll be the one who answers truthfully here. It's not explicitly a harem show, but the core appeal of it is that of a harem show; a loser protagonist (that the audience self-inserts into) surrounded by cute girls. It essentially is a harem show. Best to avoid this one brother.
I'll be the one who answers truthfully here. It's not explicitly a harem show, but the core appeal of it is that of a harem show; a loser protagonist (that the audience self-inserts into) surrounded by cute girls. It essentially is a harem show. Best to avoid this one brother.
oh... Welp, thank you for being honest
| @A-lil-weeb-dog this guy's lying out of his ass, said cute girls are not romantically involved with the protagonist (as of now), so it does not count as a harem. They are, though, involved in a romantic triangle with two other secondary characters each (a guy who they like and another girl who becomes the guy's lover), so I guess that could count as your definition of "having girls fight over a guy", even though said guy is not the MC and they practically lose instantly (hence the name of the show). I think that you'll miss a really nice show with pretty good characters if you skip it because you think this is a harem, I'd say watch the first episode and if it's not your cup of tea just drop it. You don't need to watch three episodes to get the feel of this show, you get introduced to all main characters and the overall plot straight away. However, this show IS a school life slice-of-life comedy (with a bit of drama), so if that turns you off I'd stay away. |
KorhalChildSep 1, 7:15 AM
Reply to KorhalChild
@A-lil-weeb-dog this guy's lying out of his ass, said cute girls are not romantically involved with the protagonist (as of now), so it does not count as a harem. They are, though, involved in a romantic triangle with two other secondary characters each (a guy who they like and another girl who becomes the guy's lover), so I guess that could count as your definition of "having girls fight over a guy", even though said guy is not the MC and they practically lose instantly (hence the name of the show).
I think that you'll miss a really nice show with pretty good characters if you skip it because you think this is a harem, I'd say watch the first episode and if it's not your cup of tea just drop it. You don't need to watch three episodes to get the feel of this show, you get introduced to all main characters and the overall plot straight away. However, this show IS a school life slice-of-life comedy (with a bit of drama), so if that turns you off I'd stay away.
I think that you'll miss a really nice show with pretty good characters if you skip it because you think this is a harem, I'd say watch the first episode and if it's not your cup of tea just drop it. You don't need to watch three episodes to get the feel of this show, you get introduced to all main characters and the overall plot straight away. However, this show IS a school life slice-of-life comedy (with a bit of drama), so if that turns you off I'd stay away.
| @KorhalChild if a love triangle makes a show a harem, then 90% of romance shows are harem, including half of OP's own favorite romance shows. For some strange reason, he just decided that only harems have love conflicts. @Azeyun No, we don't know. Please don't pass off your own expectations of the show as some obvious dogma that everyone should accept. The author refuses to even consider the original LN to be a romance at all, let alone a harem. And I don't see them admitting that this is a harem show, they just said that this show has elements that the OP might mistake for a harem, but it isn't. |
RobertBobertSep 1, 9:35 AM
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@KorhalChild if a love triangle makes a show a harem, then 90% of romance shows are harem, including half of OP's own favorite romance shows. For some strange reason, he just decided that only harems have love conflicts.
@Azeyun No, we don't know. Please don't pass off your own expectations of the show as some obvious dogma that everyone should accept. The author refuses to even consider the original LN to be a romance at all, let alone a harem.
@KorhalChild if a love triangle makes a show a harem, then 90% of romance shows are harem, including half of OP's own favorite romance shows. For some strange reason, he just decided that only harems have love conflicts.
@Azeyun No, we don't know. Please don't pass off your own expectations of the show as some obvious dogma that everyone should accept. The author refuses to even consider the original LN to be a romance at all, let alone a harem.
there's a difference between a love triangle and someone having unrequited feeling towards others, and you know that. None of my favorites shows have love triangles (as main MCs)
| @A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about? None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou. |
|
RobertBobert said: @A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about? None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou. Sorry bro that is not what a love triangle is, this is Wikipedia speaking:  |
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about?
None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou.
@A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about?
None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou.
Sorry bro that is not what a love triangle is, this is Wikipedia speaking:
| @A-lil-weeb-dog How does this contradict the fact that the feelings of someone in the triangle are not reciprocated? The very idea of a love triangle makes it impossible for all three people to reciprocate their feelings, this is obvious. I thought you just didn't know tropes well, remembering how you stated that harem anime are polygamous, but it seems like you don't quite understand the logic of this even on a meta level. |
|
Reply to A-lil-weeb-dog
RobertBobert said:
@A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about?
None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou.
@A-lil-weeb-dog A love triangle is literally three people, of which 1 or 2 have one-sided feelings, what are you talking about?
None? Horimiya literally has a lesbian girl hopelessly in love with a female lead, as well as a big subplot about a girl with urequited crush on a male lead friend. And this is not to mention the romantic shows that you gave high ratings like Alice to Therese no Maboroshi Koujou.
You say Horimiya and Mabouroushi just means 2 things:
1, You haven't watch Horimiya, Sawada, the girl you mentioned had a crush on the FMC but that's it, no triangle there
2, I gave Maraboushi a nine because of how I rank animes, you should know this because the first thing in my Profile is literally giving you what ny rankings means, you must have ignored all the text because you have seen Mabouroushi on the list. And since you seem to have not watched Mabouroushi either, lete tell you, if that movie was a real love triangle, then that would turn the plot into dogshit incest
| @A-lil-weeb-dog Sorry dude, not only did I watch all the anime, I also read the manga. 1. Yes, it's a love triangle. Sawada's character arc was literally about how she tried to compete with MC, but eventually backed down after realizing they had a happy mutual relationship. This is a typical love triangle where the character loses because she is the third wheel in someone else's love story. |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Make Heroine ga Oosugiru! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 28 |
252 |
by FONZACUS
»»
Yesterday, 10:03 AM |
|
Poll: » Make Heroine ga Oosugiru! Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Jul 13 |
213 |
by AkiFosu
»»
Nov 22, 2:19 PM |
|
Poll: » Make Heroine ga Oosugiru! Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Sep 21 |
213 |
by Luchi231
»»
Nov 21, 1:45 PM |
|
» Any hope for season 2?!Reckless_weeb - Sep 18 |
37 |
by Luchi231
»»
Nov 20, 9:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Make Heroine ga Oosugiru! Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Sep 7 |
136 |
by Seabury
»»
Nov 16, 5:53 PM |