| Shingetsutan Tsukihime or Fate/stay night? IMO, I like Shingetsutan Tsukihime more, its quick to the plot and it has more maturer darker theme. Arcueid antics are win! I also watched Fate/stay night, but its hazy to recall any of the episodes separate stories. |
 |
| KnK... oh wait |
| Tsukihime since I like Arcueid and Akiha. |
 |
| Out of those two, I prefer Tsukihime more, though out of Type-Moon stuff, Kara no Kyoukai. |
notsureifsrs said: KnK... oh wait Close topic. |
| All. |
 |
| Tsukihime is Nasu's single greatest achievement. And, OP, what is this "Shingetsutan" thing? |
| obviously, the one where there's Rin Tohsaka in it.. anyway, Fate/stay night remains to be one of the most well constructed and organized multi-route plot for a vn of all time, with a wider array of characters (not just this one guy with his harem and some villains that are blatantly evil).. it has also spawned a very epic prequel.. KnK wins the anime award, though.. |
DrHouse said: Kohaku needs to hurry up and be real so I can marry her. She's absolutely gorgeous and crazy as hell, I love it. Tsukihime is Nasu's single greatest achievement. And, OP, what is this "Shingetsutan" thing? Fate/Stay Night was my first VN. I played through the Fate and UBW scenarios, then took a break after hearing about Tsukihime. I decided to check out just a bit of Tsukihime before going back and playing through Heaven's Feel, how foolish I was. I ended up playing through all five routes of Tsukihime and playing Kagetsu Tohya before finally making it back to F/SN. Now if only we could get a Tsukihime anime... |
| Amagami SS. But I think our profile says it all.. |
 |
argilium said: obviously, the one where there's Rin Tohsaka in it.. anyway, Fate/stay night remains to be one of the most well constructed and organized multi-route plot for a vn of all time, with a wider array of characters (not just this one guy with his harem and some villains that are blatantly evil).. it has also spawned a very epic prequel.. KnK wins the anime award, though.. Yes for sure. I was able to play through Fate Stay night with so much interest and enjoyment. Tsukihime on the other hand just wasn't on the same level for me. But going by anime adaptions KnK is far superior to both Fate and Tsukihime. |
 |
| I know Fate/stay night before but I like Tsukihime more because 1. I love Hisui 2. I love tsukihime story more. |
Ragna92 said: Putting my vote for Fate/Stay Night too. There's just so much more meat to the story itself. Tsukihime, while nailing the dark mature vibe of a vampire story, fell on the usual tropes of the bishoujo games (although in a more subverted way).argilium said: obviously, the one where there's Rin Tohsaka in it.. anyway, Fate/stay night remains to be one of the most well constructed and organized multi-route plot for a vn of all time, with a wider array of characters (not just this one guy with his harem and some villains that are blatantly evil).. it has also spawned a very epic prequel.. KnK wins the anime award, though.. Yes for sure. I was able to play through Fate Stay night with so much interest and enjoyment. Tsukihime on the other hand just wasn't on the same level for me. But going by anime adaptions KnK is far superior to both Fate and Tsukihime. |
 |
| Fate/stay night over both KnK and Tsukihime |
 |
| Im watching it cuz of Fate/stay Night, but ill try Shingetsutan Tsukihime to enjoy more Carnival Phantasm. :P |
 |
| Hm... too hard to decide. I think I would go for Tsukihime if it was for plot wise... though FSN beats the s**t out of it when speaking in character development. It's not like I'm too onesided to one or to another, but as to romance I would also go for FSN since it offered us of a slight level for caring each other (SaverXShiro) while Tsukihime was kinda too direct and bold to me. Hey, it's strange enough a highschooler would have a loving night with a vampire in the same bed XD |
 |
Jean_Claymore said: Hm... too hard to decide. I think I would go for Tsukihime if it was for plot wise... though FSN beats the s**t out of it when speaking in character development. It's not like I'm too onesided to one or to another, but as to romance I would also go for FSN since it offered us of a slight level for caring each other (SaverXShiro) while Tsukihime was kinda too direct and bold to me. Hey, it's strange enough a highschooler would have a loving night with a vampire in the same bed XD Tsukihimes romance is just as much as Fate stay night if not more. Have you played Tsukihime? |
|
| Fate/Stay Night. The VN of it had great character development. I really enjoyed playing the UBW route <3 I like KnK as well! (I wish there was a VN!) |
Leon-Gun said: Ragna92 said: Putting my vote for Fate/Stay Night too. There's just so much more meat to the story itself. Tsukihime, while nailing the dark mature vibe of a vampire story, fell on the usual tropes of the bishoujo games (although in a more subverted way).argilium said: obviously, the one where there's Rin Tohsaka in it.. anyway, Fate/stay night remains to be one of the most well constructed and organized multi-route plot for a vn of all time, with a wider array of characters (not just this one guy with his harem and some villains that are blatantly evil).. it has also spawned a very epic prequel.. KnK wins the anime award, though.. Yes for sure. I was able to play through Fate Stay night with so much interest and enjoyment. Tsukihime on the other hand just wasn't on the same level for me. But going by anime adaptions KnK is far superior to both Fate and Tsukihime. |
sallym613 said: My god, I'm on my own here.Leon-Gun said: Ragna92 said: Putting my vote for Fate/Stay Night too. There's just so much more meat to the story itself. Tsukihime, while nailing the dark mature vibe of a vampire story, fell on the usual tropes of the bishoujo games (although in a more subverted way).argilium said: obviously, the one where there's Rin Tohsaka in it.. anyway, Fate/stay night remains to be one of the most well constructed and organized multi-route plot for a vn of all time, with a wider array of characters (not just this one guy with his harem and some villains that are blatantly evil).. it has also spawned a very epic prequel.. KnK wins the anime award, though.. Yes for sure. I was able to play through Fate Stay night with so much interest and enjoyment. Tsukihime on the other hand just wasn't on the same level for me. But going by anime adaptions KnK is far superior to both Fate and Tsukihime. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Carnival Phantasm Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Elite60 - Oct 28, 2011 |
98 |
by watsym
»»
Sep 7, 9:43 AM |
|
Poll: » Carnival Phantasm Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Yumekichi11 - Aug 13, 2011 |
143 |
by IceSlanser
»»
Sep 6, 5:11 PM |
|
Poll: » Carnival Phantasm Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Elite60 - Dec 31, 2011 |
141 |
by BLACKSIL3NCE
»»
Feb 23, 12:29 PM |
|
Poll: » Carnival Phantasm Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Elite60 - Dec 31, 2011 |
63 |
by Apreggi
»»
Feb 16, 7:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Carnival Phantasm Episode 10 DiscussionElite60 - Dec 31, 2011 |
46 |
by Apreggi
»»
Feb 16, 7:26 AM |