Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jan 18, 12:44 PM
#1
Offline
Oct 2011
124
I don't know the original or if they did something to fuck up the anime.

But the world & the story don't seem to match, everybody is a SoaB, everybody acts like an asshole, everybody seem like a kaifuku character, yet the story itself seems very light in content & storytelling and nothing really terrible is going on to justify the way people act or speak, what am I missing here?
Jan 18, 1:10 PM
#2
Offline
Oct 2021
1
@voidian how everyone acts is a shot for shot from the manga. They kept out a couple of side things that didn’t serve the anime purpose but how the villagers and guards act is 100% accurate
Jan 18, 8:29 PM
#3
Offline
Feb 2022
403
YamiBryant said:
@voidian how everyone acts is a shot for shot from the manga. They kept out a couple of side things that didn’t serve the anime purpose but how the villagers and guards act is 100% accurate

Then is it a "problem" from the source material, directly? Or things will be unfolded later? Or is it my dumb brain that can't comprehend the story?
Jan 18, 9:39 PM
#4

Offline
Apr 2021
3032
The four main characters are not like you described everyone else.
ejleonJan 18, 9:58 PM
Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.

Jan 19, 2:47 AM
#5
Yuri Christ
Offline
Apr 2022
1
@baymaxemon Stuff will get revealed later. Highkey recommend reading the source for a lot of context.
Jan 23, 9:54 AM
#6
Offline
Oct 2020
7
I will repeat what I've written elsewhere. The problem is the terrible pacing and skipping of an entire volume (volume 0) which was important before going into this arc.

- The first three chapters had world building and introduced 3 important characters and their skills (Keinzell, Ato and Rosen) -> you only see the missing two in the opening
- Chapter 4-5 is Keinzell's backstory -> anime only viewers have little idea what/who the guy even is

Volume 0 was needed to tell us "who" our MC is, "what" his motivations are and "why" we as the audience should care.

All this is missing in the anime. So far they adapted 4 chapters in EP1 and 4 chapters in EP2 (the entirety of volume 1), which results in rushing certain scenes, making emotional impactful scenes less relevant and adding time to useless enemy monologues. The annyoing evil dude talked the same nonsense in the manga, but he had less lines, which made him less cringe in the manga. Peepi also managed to defeat a random soldier, which was cut in the anime. A lot of gore was skipped and all sexual content is missing.

What also makes no sense now is what Wied said 5 minutes into ep2: "He (Keinzell) will be fine, at least if he is who I think he is." The anime audience has no context to that line. Keinzell build a certain reputation for himself in volume 0. Without going into spoilers, he got nicknamed "the hero of the borderlands". Wied heard of this new hero, so he suspects Keinzell must be the one. So Wied's line in the anime is completely useless and could have been cut as well since it's only confusing without volume 0 content.

That's why I think the pacing is horrible and the adaption is subpar. The manga deserved better. I bought all 23 volumes and never regretted buying them.
Jan 24, 1:02 PM
#7

Offline
Aug 2012
1888
Reply to baymaxemon
YamiBryant said:
@voidian how everyone acts is a shot for shot from the manga. They kept out a couple of side things that didn’t serve the anime purpose but how the villagers and guards act is 100% accurate

Then is it a "problem" from the source material, directly? Or things will be unfolded later? Or is it my dumb brain that can't comprehend the story?
@baymaxemon they skipped some stuff so that is why is a bit confusing.
Feb 7, 1:51 PM
#8

Offline
Oct 2014
19
Reply to Vileste
I will repeat what I've written elsewhere. The problem is the terrible pacing and skipping of an entire volume (volume 0) which was important before going into this arc.

- The first three chapters had world building and introduced 3 important characters and their skills (Keinzell, Ato and Rosen) -> you only see the missing two in the opening
- Chapter 4-5 is Keinzell's backstory -> anime only viewers have little idea what/who the guy even is

Volume 0 was needed to tell us "who" our MC is, "what" his motivations are and "why" we as the audience should care.

All this is missing in the anime. So far they adapted 4 chapters in EP1 and 4 chapters in EP2 (the entirety of volume 1), which results in rushing certain scenes, making emotional impactful scenes less relevant and adding time to useless enemy monologues. The annyoing evil dude talked the same nonsense in the manga, but he had less lines, which made him less cringe in the manga. Peepi also managed to defeat a random soldier, which was cut in the anime. A lot of gore was skipped and all sexual content is missing.

What also makes no sense now is what Wied said 5 minutes into ep2: "He (Keinzell) will be fine, at least if he is who I think he is." The anime audience has no context to that line. Keinzell build a certain reputation for himself in volume 0. Without going into spoilers, he got nicknamed "the hero of the borderlands". Wied heard of this new hero, so he suspects Keinzell must be the one. So Wied's line in the anime is completely useless and could have been cut as well since it's only confusing without volume 0 content.

That's why I think the pacing is horrible and the adaption is subpar. The manga deserved better. I bought all 23 volumes and never regretted buying them.
Vileste said:
That's why I think the pacing is horrible


I'm literally dropping the anime right now as ep 5 aired cause the pacing is terrible and I don't understand anything of what is going on or why should I care about these characters, terrible adaptation.
Feb 10, 3:01 AM
#9

Offline
Jan 2014
6263
This is what happens when you try to sanitize a dark fantasy with heavy sexual and violent themes by trying to make it all ages and removing entire arcs and scenes for censorship reasons. Nothing makes sense, everything feels out of place and it ends up being for literally nobody.
Feb 12, 8:47 AM
Offline
Oct 2011
124
Reply to LoneWizzy
This is what happens when you try to sanitize a dark fantasy with heavy sexual and violent themes by trying to make it all ages and removing entire arcs and scenes for censorship reasons. Nothing makes sense, everything feels out of place and it ends up being for literally nobody.
@LoneWizzy This is what killed anime in the US, by the way.

In the 90s anime in latin america was flourishing, you'd have a hard time finding, today, a grown man close to being middle aged who have not heard of or even watched Saint Seiya, Dragon Ball, Captain Tsubasa, among others. EVERYONE watched those back then because they were awesome.

Meanwhile the US censored and sanitized all of the content, it turned to shit, so anime never took off until recently, so they are doing it again and killing some shows that should have been amazing.
https://youtu.be/Vev5Gp2skhI?si=ad267brYhQuNSERZ
An explanation about the topic.

This is so depressing, it sounds like it should have been something similar to Claymore, too bad back then animes had a bad habit of never finishing their stories and/or creating nonsensical fillers to wrap them up in the worst possible way (Hi Soul eater)
Feb 12, 9:35 AM

Offline
Feb 2024
1494
Reply to Voidian
@LoneWizzy This is what killed anime in the US, by the way.

In the 90s anime in latin america was flourishing, you'd have a hard time finding, today, a grown man close to being middle aged who have not heard of or even watched Saint Seiya, Dragon Ball, Captain Tsubasa, among others. EVERYONE watched those back then because they were awesome.

Meanwhile the US censored and sanitized all of the content, it turned to shit, so anime never took off until recently, so they are doing it again and killing some shows that should have been amazing.
https://youtu.be/Vev5Gp2skhI?si=ad267brYhQuNSERZ
An explanation about the topic.

This is so depressing, it sounds like it should have been something similar to Claymore, too bad back then animes had a bad habit of never finishing their stories and/or creating nonsensical fillers to wrap them up in the worst possible way (Hi Soul eater)
@Voidian

Way to completely miss the point, the anime's aim was never to adapt the manga faithfully, it was only made to promote the source material. I already made a thread about it here https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2201605
JoeChipFeb 12, 10:49 AM

More topics from this board

» Finally episode 4 is showing promise

BanryuTV - Jan 31

31 by ayatenre »»
12 hours ago

Poll: » Übel Blatt Episode 5 Discussion

Stark700 - Feb 7

20 by Comander-07 »»
Yesterday, 2:40 PM

Poll: » Übel Blatt Episode 3 Discussion

Stark700 - Jan 24

49 by Comander-07 »»
Yesterday, 2:45 AM

Poll: » Übel Blatt Episode 4 Discussion

Stark700 - Jan 31

49 by Radix53 »»
Feb 12, 9:13 PM

Poll: » Übel Blatt Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jan 17

56 by JoeChip »»
Feb 12, 8:45 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login