Am I gay if I fantasize to this? (NOT A TROLL THREAD, MODS)

My guy, like who you like and don't stress out over labels so much. Mental and physical genders often don't line up, that's sort of the whole point about transgender gender identity and when/how a person might modify physical bodies to match internal identities.

At the end of the day you're still ultimately sleeping with a 52 year old guy in a biologically female body, so if you're hung up on classifications you might need to have some honest conversations with yourself lol

The real question is why are you acting terminally horny over a show with absolutely zero fanservice.

If you are male and if it is just "the thing"… Where's the gay part on man attracted by a woman? Where is the complicated part?
When it comes to physical attraction, the only thing that matters is the physical part.



When I read the title of the thread I thought the question would go around the series concept itself; in other words: "If it would be gay to want to be in the MC shoes." The real question was disappointing. (sigh)

i would impregnate the old man fck it

No, because biological sex is defined by the body, not the mind.

Physically gay, mentally straight. So half-gay half-not.

@Zarutaku What if it's a full on dude who you slept with while they were taking a gender-bending drug? lol

@LostSpectre So, basically Onimai premise? No, that wouldn't be gay either.

@Zarutaku Nah. I had Ishuzoku Reviewers in mind when I said that. They had to limit the usage of gender-bending drugs to one sanctioned area, because there were too many issues where people hooked up, only to find themselves in bed with another dude the following morning haha.

@LostSpectre No idea, what if I took the drug and made out with another girl, would I be lesbian or straight?
Best answer is: Regardless with whom I would have sex, my sexual orientation would still be the same.

@Zarutaku Huh? That wasn't the point at all. The question is whether or not you would still be completely fine sleeping with a bio-female despite knowing/being well aware (before or after the fact) that it's a guy, and let's say it's someone who is at least an acquaintance, not a total stranger who you will never meet again. lol

Also, I'm obviously assuming you're straight, otherwise this line of questioning would be useless.

@Zarutaku Hmmm. That's an interestingly progressive take in contrast to your earlier statement, though. lol

@LostSpectre It seems coherent, the body is what matters during sex, doesn't matter what gender they identify in their mind, I would also be fine with a reverse-trap.

@Zarutaku Eh. It's definitely not the typical POV from someone who takes that type of hardline stance on gender/sex.

@LostSpectre What hardline stance, that biological sex depends on the body? I would say that's just realistic rather than hardline.

@Zarutaku Well, I'm speaking in the context of said stance being anti-trans, unless I'm misinterpreting that?

@LostSpectre I don't really mind transgender, only thing I find disturbing are sex transformation attempts, because they don't work and ruin one's biology.

@Zarutaku I'm pretty sure they "work" if you want said biology to serve a different sexual purpose, but we're way off track at this point. lmao

i would impregnate the old man fck it

@NoHeart You make it sound simple, but this is my issue with every "genderbender"-doujin: Imagine you're a guy and your best friend is suddenly turned into a hot girl. Would you make out with "her"? Would that make you gay? You know that this is a guy's mind, you've known him your whole life. Does the body change everything? I'm not sure.

I saw some youtubers do dumb questions and one was "who'd you rather have sex with, your mom's mind in your gf's body or your gf's mind in your mom's body?" What would you pick and why?

@Zarutaku What if it's a full on dude who you slept with while they were taking a gender-bending drug? lol

@MyllerPhiem Someone else already answered:



-----



I still don't see de issue; if you were the one who became female then, and just then, there would be an issue, but if you remain male… you are just a normal dude attracted to a woman.

quoting myself:



On the other side, this is a more interesting question:



Answer: Look for another girl, maybe a biological girl who was a man in her previous life.

¯\(ツ)/¯

@NoHeart Nah, answer the last question, lol.

I overlooked that question and feel compelled to answer, but it depends on the following: Could it be my mom when she was young?
If yes then I'd choose gf's mind in mom's body, else mom's mind in gf's body.