Wouldn't DanDaDan be better off as RomCom instead of Battle Shounen?

Nov 15, 7:18 PM

#2

kenny007

Offline

Sep 2023

3

well...........

Nov 15, 7:40 PM

#3

SleepyFaceMiko

Offline

Dec 2021

292

Nah, I think its just fine the way it is. Balanced between action, fights, romance and comedy.

Nov 15, 8:13 PM

#4

NicoD

Offline

Apr 2020

1

Dandadan is a mix of genres. The most prominent are comedy, romance, action and horror, but there's also a lot of drama, sci-fi, fantasy, and a few more genres, and that's what makes Dandadan stand out from other anime/manga. Focusing ONLY on comedy and romance would strip away what makes it unique.

Nov 15, 8:27 PM

#5

Liental

Offline

Apr 2024

43

That's crazy when the last fight had a whole ep dedicated to the spirit's impactful background. To then hand wave it as an interruption is wild. Stop trying to force it into what you want it to be since it's already a unique shounen. Watch something else like Blue Box, it's literally what you're describing.

LientalNov 15, 8:31 PM

Nov 15, 8:28 PM

#6

rohan121

Offline

Sep 2018

11528

Dandandan mc is Momo. The guy will likely get sidelined, and this is not the type of story to go full romcom.

Nov 15, 8:39 PM

#7

sloth848

Offline

Feb 2024

47

rohan121 said:
Dandandan mc is Momo. The guy will likely get sidelined, and this is not the type of story to go full romcom.

both characters are equally as important and there’s literally 0 chance okarun will get sidelined

Nov 15, 8:42 PM

#8

Fenrir_01

Offline

Aug 2022

98

Dragevard said:
I know this might ruffle some feathers because Dandadan is known for its wild battles, over-the-top supernatural creatures, and insane action scenes. Dandadan has something special beyond its fight scenes: its core relationship between Momo and Okarun. If we just focus on them navigating their weird and chaotic lives, it could be such a strong romantic comedy. Imagine all the great awkward moments, misunderstandings, and the slow burn as they grow closer. Honestly, I’d love to see that without the constant interruptions from battles. Dandadan has so much potential as a RomCom, and I honestly think the battle shounen elements are kind of distracting from the heart of the story.

It’s both, it’s not just a battle Shonen or a romcom it’s both

Nov 15, 8:45 PM

#9

sloth848

Offline

Feb 2024

47

Dragevard said:
I know this might ruffle some feathers because Dandadan is known for its wild battles, over-the-top supernatural creatures, and insane action scenes. Dandadan has something special beyond its fight scenes: its core relationship between Momo and Okarun. If we just focus on them navigating their weird and chaotic lives, it could be such a strong romantic comedy. Imagine all the great awkward moments, misunderstandings, and the slow burn as they grow closer. Honestly, I’d love to see that without the constant interruptions from battles. Dandadan has so much potential as a RomCom, and I honestly think the battle shounen elements are kind of distracting from the heart of the story.

there’s actually a funny story about that, the editor made the mangaka read 100 shoujo to understand how to write a good romance so that explains why the romance is so good. Also, to answer your question no i dont think it would be better if it was strictly romance, i mean the story would be completely different first of all and the fact that dandadan excells in so many genres is what makes it so special. When’s the last time you saw a good romance in a battle shonen?

Nov 15, 9:33 PM

#10

Saimatsu_Fan

Offline

Sep 2021

1086

there's many stories that focus on Romance and battlez dandadan isn't a new thing in this regard

Nov 15, 9:35 PM

#11

Reckless_weeb

Offline

Jul 2021

763

Nah it's better as it is. It has a perfect balance between every genre.

Nov 15, 9:38 PM

#12

SweatyFingers

Offline

Jul 2023

478

respectfully, that's the worst take I've seen in a while

Nov 15, 9:40 PM

#13

deg

Online

Jan 2009

100961

not its main genre should stay as action aka battle shonen

Nov 15, 10:15 PM

#14

LucenProject

Offline

Oct 2022

404

Dragevard said:
I know this might ruffle some feathers because Dandadan is known for its wild battles, over-the-top supernatural creatures, and insane action scenes. Dandadan has something special beyond its fight scenes: its core relationship between Momo and Okarun. If we just focus on them navigating their weird and chaotic lives, it could be such a strong romantic comedy. Imagine all the great awkward moments, misunderstandings, and the slow burn as they grow closer. Honestly, I’d love to see that without the constant interruptions from battles. Dandadan has so much potential as a RomCom, and I honestly think the battle shounen elements are kind of distracting from the heart of the story.

"Better off as?" How so? You sat and listed all these things it is known for and then suggested that it would somehow be better if it threw away the thing it is known for and exclusively focused on something it is very good at. But in what world does that make sense?

It's better to let people come for all those other things and stay for the romcom than to only bring in people looking for romcom. And that is even before considering the fact that if this mashup of genres is what the creator felt most passionately about making, it's absolutely what they should have made.

Just because we like to fit things neatly into boxes to categorize them doesn't mean new art should strive to fit neatly into those boxes. Quite the opposite.

Nov 15, 11:06 PM

#15

Laplace_kun

Online

Nov 2019

2196

The emotional and wholesome moments are the strengths of Dandadan to me so far because everything haphazardly and chaotic happens around it.

"All truth is meaningless. In the end, 'meaning' comes from the mind of each individual human. Even when there is a single truth, it can mean different things to different individuals. The truth has no meaning in itself!" - Erika Furudo

Nov 15, 11:19 PM

#16

TEOKXNG

Offline

Oct 2019

78

Stop making these

Nov 16, 12:09 AM

#17

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5332

Reply to rohan121

Dandandan mc is Momo. The guy will likely get sidelined, and this is not the type of story to go full romcom.

@rohan121 That guy gets more screentime and character development then Momo.

Nov 16, 2:22 AM

#18

Merve2Love

Offline

Apr 2020

2875

TEOKXNG said:
Stop making these

You mean L-Takes presented in an inane wall of Text, reiterating his attention seeking point two times over, multiple times a day?

That's what he LOVES to do, tho xD

Nov 16, 2:30 AM

#19

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

9877

It's better of as both, just the way it is.

No, this isn't my signature.

Nov 16, 3:26 AM

#20

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

I can’t agree that any unique and highly enjoyable anime that happens to feature a relationship should simply drop all the core story and become just romance. That would be like irl dropping all your hobbies and quitting job/ school to focus on having a relationship. It would make you a shallow person with nothing to talk about with your partner other than how much you love them. Sounds dull. And this is from a romance anime fan…
BTW @deg this is how to make a proper thread. No need for bait, just an honest proposition for people to discuss their opinions on. Even tho I don’t agree I find the idea interesting and replied truthfully as I was asked without animosity.

Nov 16, 3:29 AM

#21

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

ZXEAN said:
@rohan121 That guy gets more screentime and character development then Momo.

FYI not passing this off as my knowledge, it was a post 3 or 4 days ago, but the writer made it clear that Momo is protagonist. The current story revolves around Okarun’s family jewels so of course he gets a lot of screen time, but future episodes may sideline him if more arcs are covered in future.

Nov 16, 3:53 AM

#22

Arka_Chakrabarty

Online

Jun 2022

112

Nah the best part of Dandadan is mixing all the genres. That's what I love the most. For me, Dandadan is the spiritual successor of Gintama.

Nov 16, 3:54 AM

#23

Arka_Chakrabarty

Online

Jun 2022

112

ZXEAN said:
@rohan121 That guy gets more screentime and character development then Momo.

R u saying from the anime, coz from the recent arcs, I think it has been heavily implied that Momo is the protagonist.

Nov 16, 4:27 AM

#24

Lolies_areWet4Me

Offline

Nov 2024

9

Momo hot 🔥🥵 it could have been good ecchi series

Nov 16, 4:37 AM

#25

deg

Online

Jan 2009

100961

Reply to FutoiOtaku

I can’t agree that any unique and highly enjoyable anime that happens to feature a relationship should simply drop all the core story and become just romance. That would be like irl dropping all your hobbies and quitting job/ school to focus on having a relationship. It would make you a shallow person with nothing to talk about with your partner other than how much you love them. Sounds dull. And this is from a romance anime fan…
BTW @deg this is how to make a proper thread. No need for bait, just an honest proposition for people to discuss their opinions on. Even tho I don’t agree I find the idea interesting and replied truthfully as I was asked without animosity.

@FutoiOtaku there is nothing negative about my thread too you and others just taken offense for it

Nov 16, 5:02 AM

#26

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5332

Reply to FutoiOtaku

ZXEAN said:
@rohan121 That guy gets more screentime and character development then Momo.

FYI not passing this off as my knowledge, it was a post 3 or 4 days ago, but the writer made it clear that Momo is protagonist. The current story revolves around Okarun’s family jewels so of course he gets a lot of screen time, but future episodes may sideline him if more arcs are covered in future.

@FutoiOtaku @Arka_Chakrabarty I am talking about the future events.

Nov 16, 5:06 AM

#27

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

9877

FutoiOtaku said:
BTW @deg this is how to make a proper thread. No need for bait, just an honest proposition for people to discuss their opinions on.

It's a Dragevard thread so it's 100% bait, even if you don't see it that way.

No, this isn't my signature.

Nov 16, 9:36 AM

#28

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

Zarutaku said:

FutoiOtaku said:
BTW @deg this is how to make a proper thread. No need for bait, just an honest proposition for people to discuss their opinions on.

It's a Dragevard thread so it's 100% bait, even if you don't see it that way.

All threads are bait to some degree, they have to lure you in with a click bait title to make you bite. I just prefer those that don’t use negativity to generate angry replies, especially when they then pretend that wasn’t the intention and those being irritated are in the wrong. I accept everyone has a different opinion and all are valid to some degree, but titles about widely enjoyed high rated shows using words like mid and generic are designed to trigger anger not discussion.

Nov 16, 1:22 PM

#29

thischeetobussin

Offline

Nov 2019

251

No, the creativity and the weird yet ridiculous stuff is what makes the series unique and memorable. Taking away what makes something unique allows the series to become a lot more generic and dull. Dandadan is basically already a rom-com just with its own style and craziness with aliens and yokais added into it.

Nov 16, 3:59 PM

#30

GTRaijin

Offline

Aug 2014

754

FutoiOtaku said:

Zarutaku said:

It's a Dragevard thread so it's 100% bait, even if you don't see it that way.

All threads are bait to some degree, they have to lure you in with a click bait title to make you bite. I just prefer those that don’t use negativity to generate angry replies, especially when they then pretend that wasn’t the intention and those being irritated are in the wrong. I accept everyone has a different opinion and all are valid to some degree, but titles about widely enjoyed high rated shows using words like mid and generic are designed to trigger anger not discussion.

OP never even replies on his threads, like ever. He just makes them to get attention and that is all.

Nov 16, 7:13 PM

#31

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

GTRaijin said:

FutoiOtaku said:

All threads are bait to some degree, they have to lure you in with a click bait title to make you bite. I just prefer those that don’t use negativity to generate angry replies, especially when they then pretend that wasn’t the intention and those being irritated are in the wrong. I accept everyone has a different opinion and all are valid to some degree, but titles about widely enjoyed high rated shows using words like mid and generic are designed to trigger anger not discussion.

OP never even replies on his threads, like ever. He just makes them to get attention and that is all.

Ok, another user to look out for then. Less annoying than some, but still pointless. Noted. Thanks.

Nov 16, 9:58 PM

#32

NachoMist

Offline

Nov 2020

59

as someone who adores romcoms and straight up romances waaaaaay more than battle shounen, absolutely not no. the romance is a nice bonus cherry on top kinda deal it's not the heart of the story as you called it

Nov 16, 10:51 PM

#33

DenjiTakakura

Offline

Aug 2024

12

Dandadan IS a romcom, but its also a battle shonen. Just like with the people who endless debate over whether Momo or Okarun are the protagonist seemingly people here can't figure out the series can be both. The first chapter/episode is titled "That's How Love Stars, Ya Know," its telling you from the start that this is a love story. Hell during the special video we saw at the Dandadan theater screening Tatsu literally says the 3 pillars that make up Dandadan are Occult, Battle, and RomCom.

Nov 16, 11:45 PM

#34

Miyukikurogane

Offline

Nov 2022

20

Dandadan is actually a romance story with supernatural elements similar to inspectre I guess

Nov 16, 11:55 PM

#35

Sasori_Nagashi

Spiral Warrior

Offline

Jan 2017

252

No. I mean, it already is anyway but what you're trying to say; no.

I'm level

on mal-badges. View my badges.

Nov 17, 1:50 AM

#36

flymango

Offline

Jun 2024

59

Dragevard said:
I know this might ruffle some feathers because Dandadan is known for its wild battles, over-the-top supernatural creatures, and insane action scenes. Dandadan has something special beyond its fight scenes: its core relationship between Momo and Okarun. If we just focus on them navigating their weird and chaotic lives, it could be such a strong romantic comedy. Imagine all the great awkward moments, misunderstandings, and the slow burn as they grow closer. Honestly, I’d love to see that without the constant interruptions from battles. Dandadan has so much potential as a RomCom, and I honestly think the battle shounen elements are kind of distracting from the heart of the story.

Respectfully no.

Nov 17, 4:08 AM

#37

Rayane-47

Offline

Aug 2021

853

Ngl...It Would Be Amazing As A Romance, Just Like U Said With The Diffrent Plot Points And Stuff But...It's Still Great As It Is Now

Nov 17, 7:23 AM

#38

WaterMage

Offline

Jan 2024

1006

It could work but it won't be nearly as good as it is rn. What it is rn is perfect.

Nov 17, 8:06 AM

#39

Gray_eminence

Offline

Apr 2023

168

please never give your opinion ever again 🙏

Nov 17, 10:15 AM

#40

Chits_99

Offline

Jun 2021

262

Dragevard said:
I know this might ruffle some feathers because Dandadan is known for its wild battles, over-the-top supernatural creatures, and insane action scenes. Dandadan has something special beyond its fight scenes: its core relationship between Momo and Okarun. If we just focus on them navigating their weird and chaotic lives, it could be such a strong romantic comedy. Imagine all the great awkward moments, misunderstandings, and the slow burn as they grow closer. Honestly, I’d love to see that without the constant interruptions from battles. Dandadan has so much potential as a RomCom, and I honestly think the battle shounen elements are kind of distracting from the heart of the story.

your biggest mistake here is to think dan da dan would be great romcom without all this shit. who knows it could have been if authore did that from the start. but dandadan has good romcom because of the way it is and it looks great only because of it core theme otherwise it would just be another average seasonal romcom.

Nov 18, 10:49 AM

#41

alexswrld

Offline

Oct 2024

67

as someone who is mainly enjoying dandadan because of the romance aspect i can say i see where ur coming from but i disagree. i think the beauty behind it is the fact that its subtle romance that slowly builds up behind all of the crazy supernatural stuff.

Poll: » Dandadan Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Softhenic03 - Yesterday	166	by hanakocheeks »» 44 minutes ago
Poll: » Dandadan Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Softhenic03 - Nov 14	1126	by ippos-apostle »» 1 hour ago
» Vinland Saga in 2023, now Dandadan in 2024 (SPOILERS) ( 1 2 ) Koustubh - Nov 18	57	by Gator »» 2 hours ago
» MAL 3x3 -Treetrunks - Nov 18	25	by utopia- »» 3 hours ago
Poll: » Dandadan Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) IzanaSolos - Sep 13	317	by vinnywizanime »» Yesterday, 9:28 PM

Wouldn't DanDaDan be better off as RomCom instead of Battle Shounen?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Dandadan Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Dandadan Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Vinland Saga in 2023, now Dandadan in 2024 (SPOILERS) ( 1 2 )

» MAL 3x3

Poll: » Dandadan Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters