swapnilabeyy said: ive watched way better episodes from one piece than this one. There are a few episodes that would have an even higher score than this special, if they had separate entries that is. |
No, this isn't my signature. |
| The thing is that this is not only an amazing episode of One Piece but simply an amazing episode for the art of animation as a whole. Also for the short run-time it tells a great story and it even manages to make the viewer sympathize with unnamed characters you have never seen before. No matter how you look at it, this episode is special and achieves things in 24 minutes that most full cour series do not achieve during their whole runtime. |
| Pretty sure most people watching it are superfans of one piece for staying so long. Sequels generally recieve less views, but get higher ratings than former seasons since many of the nonfans drop out. |
 |
Reply to Zarutaku
swapnilabeyy said:
ive watched way better episodes from one piece than this one.
ive watched way better episodes from one piece than this one.
There are a few episodes that would have an even higher score than this special, if they had separate entries that is.
| @Zarutaku Yeah, if this Fan Letter special episode fares so well in terms of scores, I can imagine at least two One Piece episodes that could've had similar mean score. Maybe even a higher one. Objectively speaking, Luffy going Gear 5 episode was technically superb in almost every aspect to the Love Letter. The only inferior element was not having scenes with lighthearted life of regular folks (obviously), which might be the biggest advantage of the Love Letter. But some "chilled One Piece fans" are gonna mald when you say it, or that you didn't like the special that much, claiming that you're a fake fan who watched it only because Frieren ain't top1 or whatever other reasons they saw in their hallucinations. ;D Kinda hilarious, but somewhat upsetting. |
Reply to Adnash
@Zarutaku Yeah, if this Fan Letter special episode fares so well in terms of scores, I can imagine at least two One Piece episodes that could've had similar mean score. Maybe even a higher one. Objectively speaking, Luffy going Gear 5 episode was technically superb in almost every aspect to the Love Letter. The only inferior element was not having scenes with lighthearted life of regular folks (obviously), which might be the biggest advantage of the Love Letter.
But some "chilled One Piece fans" are gonna mald when you say it, or that you didn't like the special that much, claiming that you're a fake fan who watched it only because Frieren ain't top1 or whatever other reasons they saw in their hallucinations. ;D Kinda hilarious, but somewhat upsetting.
But some "chilled One Piece fans" are gonna mald when you say it, or that you didn't like the special that much, claiming that you're a fake fan who watched it only because Frieren ain't top1 or whatever other reasons they saw in their hallucinations. ;D Kinda hilarious, but somewhat upsetting.
| @Adnash lol look at the comedy on display here again. this is what happens when you watch one piece on tiktok, you think luffy going gear 5 episode is one of the best in the series lmao. the fan letter is objectively better. better pacing, no reused scenes and more consistent animation. there's A LOT of better episodes than that in one piece, it isn't even the best out of all the 6 episodes that gear 5 was featured during that fight. stop acting like you've watched it, it's clear as day that you haven't and it's giving second-hand embarrassment at this point. |
ryzxgumOct 21, 10:01 PM
 |
Reply to ryzxgum
@Adnash lol look at the comedy on display here again. this is what happens when you watch one piece on tiktok, you think luffy going gear 5 episode is one of the best in the series lmao. the fan letter is objectively better. better pacing, no reused scenes and more consistent animation. there's A LOT of better episodes than that in one piece, it isn't even the best out of all the 6 episodes that gear 5 was featured during that fight. stop acting like you've watched it, it's clear as day that you haven't and it's giving second-hand embarrassment at this point.
| @ryzxgum My friend, do you have any obsession regarding me, so you have to maniacally hunt for my posts and rant about them? 😂 At least read them, preferably with at least minimal caution. Technically I consider ep. 1015 and ep. 1071 better than the Love Letter, with the latter, to which you referred, as much better in terms of technicals. If you are that curious, I prefer ch. 1015 out of the two aforementioned episodes. But no need to elaborate, you will just see what you want to see. You not only had to nitpick and just ramble about "no it's not like that!!1 I disagree!", but also claim that me not liking the Love Letter that much equals not watching One Piece at all. ;D I wouldn't call your rants as the comedy on display, though. They are not even pathetic, but rather sad. I wish you all the best. |
Reply to Adnash
@ryzxgum My friend, do you have any obsession regarding me, so you have to maniacally hunt for my posts and rant about them? 😂 At least read them, preferably with at least minimal caution. Technically I consider ep. 1015 and ep. 1071 better than the Love Letter, with the latter, to which you referred, as much better in terms of technicals. If you are that curious, I prefer ch. 1015 out of the two aforementioned episodes. But no need to elaborate, you will just see what you want to see. You not only had to nitpick and just ramble about "no it's not like that!!1 I disagree!", but also claim that me not liking the Love Letter that much equals not watching One Piece at all. ;D
I wouldn't call your rants as the comedy on display, though. They are not even pathetic, but rather sad. I wish you all the best.
I wouldn't call your rants as the comedy on display, though. They are not even pathetic, but rather sad. I wish you all the best.
| @Adnash it's really not that hard to open a thread, read a username and remember the ramblings of a certain goof. welcome to the internet. thanks for wasting my time by moving the goalpost again talking on a subjective level when i've already said why there's objectively better episodes mentioning things like pacing and reused scenes. Adnash said: ^guess this gets thrown out the window once you have no better response to what i said, huh? another nothingburger of a message just to further embarrass yourself, there really is no limit to your clownery lol.Objectively speaking |
ryzxgumOct 22, 3:48 AM
|
Reply to chukesh007
Maybe some moments in a One piece episode would be good .
But This episode was
- a complete story ( Good + heart touching ❤️)
- consistent Animation with awesome Artstyle ( best ngl )
- Unique than other episodes and open a different perspective of viewing one piece.
If this episode was before koby's speech , people would recognise koby more in marinefold .
( although I'm a certified koby Hater )
- Relatable kinda as they are also fans like we are .
That's it I don't think as a whole episode, this is the best episode in One piece or Any Special of other series
But This episode was
- a complete story ( Good + heart touching ❤️)
- consistent Animation with awesome Artstyle ( best ngl )
- Unique than other episodes and open a different perspective of viewing one piece.
If this episode was before koby's speech , people would recognise koby more in marinefold .
( although I'm a certified koby Hater )
- Relatable kinda as they are also fans like we are .
That's it I don't think as a whole episode, this is the best episode in One piece or Any Special of other series
| @chukesh007 You guys are just overrating the episode because of your biased love for the series. Pokémon Twilight Wings and PokeToon does exactly the same thing for a highly beloved franchise and yet they're barely scratching a 7.50 score. |
| This special is emblematic of the ideas of One Piece as a whole. Like, this shows the impact the Straw hats have had on the entire world at the ground level, how no one truly makes it on their own, stuff like that. It's also pure fan service while keeping a consistent tone with the rest of the series. |
| "Dreams are worth fighting for" Backloggery | YouTube | Heatmap |
Reply to Guilmon1
@ShadowUnown Pokémon twilight wings is genuinely one of my favourite Pokémon projects but the 5 minutes standalone structure is probably the reason it isn't highly rated so the comparison isn't the best
| @Guilmon1 Thing is, it is the best comparison, too perfect actually. It has every positive point the guy there just said, including the "perspective of a fan" and superb directing and animation. I dont see how the duration of each episode is relevant here, if its "5 minutes" each episode (actually 10 for the last and best one, which you can most easily compare with the conveniently similar "OP Fan Letter", thats half the time of it already) that means 35 minutes total at least. But still: Pokemon Twilight Wings - 7.52 One Piece Fan Letter - 9.26 (!!!) ...Okay??... |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Fan Letter Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )IzanaSolos - Oct 19 |
279 |
by aurora_yuuki
»»
Nov 19, 10:39 PM |
|
» let´s be honest. hype > quality....why? ( 1 2 )AkaiSanji - Nov 3 |
65 |
by Serfort30
»»
Nov 15, 8:44 AM |
|
» I watched this and I liked it(I've never watched One Piece)utopia- - Nov 3 |
18 |
by AquaBlue-sama
»»
Nov 5, 2:02 PM |
|
» No, you shouldn't watch this around the Sabaody, or Marineford arc.Polatrix - Oct 26 |
10 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Nov 3, 6:49 AM |
|
» How caught up do I need to be to watch it?RizzardKing - Oct 24 |
28 |
by LilyVarbik
»»
Nov 3, 6:47 AM |