Did it make you cry?

Cried?

Yes

Aug 29, 11:07 AM

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

Was it sad enough to make you cry? Even a drop of tear counts.

Aug 29, 11:29 AM

BlizzardBoy026

Offline

Jun 2021

197

As if lol the characters were too broken for me to care about if they live or die.At one point I wanted both of them to just die.I can see though why someone would cry reading this

Aug 29, 11:31 AM

BlizzardBoy026

Offline

Jun 2021

197

That mangaka girl searching for Punpun was pretty sad though.

Aug 29, 11:46 AM

louvkinga

Offline

Jul 2024

im normally a really sensitive person so its not hard to make me cry but this manga really got the salty tears out of me, i sobbed so hard sometimes i had to stop reading it.

Aug 29, 11:54 AM

Windquake99

Offline

May 2023

Yeah but really only in the first part of the story, the second part was too weird to make me that sad

Aug 29, 11:58 AM

Mr_Sai

Offline

Sep 2022

409

meh manga doesn't make me cry unlike anime

Aug 29, 12:23 PM

Ristic17

Offline

Jan 2022

yes, it was so bad i had to cry and pray for myself to never read something like that shit ever again 😭🙏

Aug 29, 12:33 PM

Sagepool

Offline

Jun 2021

691

Made me go woah at the end

Aug 29, 1:15 PM

keinboesewicht

Offline

Dec 2020

324

i just felt empty honestly

Aug 29, 2:07 PM

#10

Hacker075

Offline

Mar 2021

318

BipulGamer07 said:
Was it sad enough to make you cry? Even a drop of tear counts.

Towards the end is a scene that I would say provides a lot of shock if you didn't see it coming. I started crying when I reached this point because I didn't expect it and the sheer shock made my body respond with tears. It was a strange experience I must say.

Aug 29, 2:30 PM

#11

rinnmakesmusic

Offline

Oct 2023

249

A couple of times. Towards the end it got pretty rough for me. Punpun went through a lot and you get a fly-on-the-wall view of all of the really traumatic bits. Masterpiece story but a fucked one at that.

Aug 29, 2:49 PM

#12

TrillJessie

Offline

Oct 2020

102

If anything, I was angry. Not anywhere close to tears

My Candies:

Aug 29, 3:35 PM

#13

BLUEBERYyummy

Offline

May 2024

106

I NEVAA CRYYY I NEVAAAA

Aug 29, 3:54 PM

#14

Vesko_07

Offline

Jan 2024

i didn't cry but fucking d.gray-man made me cry out of all anime lol

Aug 29, 5:10 PM

#15

Pokeleomon

Offline

May 2022

It emotionally scarred me, but I didn’t cry. Just punched the air wishing for the author to give poor punpun a better life.

Aug 29, 5:51 PM

#16

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

Mr_Sai said:
meh manga doesn't make me cry unlike anime

try reading Chi no Wadachi then. It's the only manga that has ever made me cry.

Aug 29, 5:59 PM

#17

Inte_macks

Offline

May 2020

No single event has ever made me cry more than reading oyasumi punpun (and I never cry at anything irl). While reading it I listened a lot to the song ”Last surprise” (you know the incredibly groovy one no one could ever cry to?), and punpun was so sad that I accidentally pavlov’d myself into getting teary-eyed whenever I hear the beginning to the song (I might be crazy, or punpun just might be the saddest thing ever)

Aug 29, 6:01 PM

#18

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

Hacker075 said:

BipulGamer07 said:
Was it sad enough to make you cry? Even a drop of tear counts.

If you're talking about

then I totally saw it coming

Aug 29, 6:36 PM

#19

oppTomioka

Offline

Nov 2020

made me cry from how ass it is

Aug 29, 6:49 PM

#20

stayKrillinEm

Offline

Dec 2016

No. With each chapter it started to feel like an endurance test in misery and I was a little angry by the end. I felt bad for certain characters (Punpun (sorta) and Aiko) but I never cried. I finished Blood on the Tracks earlier this year which was definitely a more emotional expierience.

Aug 29, 8:16 PM

#21

thischeetobussin

Offline

Nov 2019

251

Nah but it was definitely an unpleasant depressing feeling.

Aug 29, 8:29 PM

#22

ryzxgum

Offline

Apr 2022

6323

no, made me feel empty quite often though.

Aug 29, 8:32 PM

#23

MashirooYT

Offline

May 2021

BipulGamer07 said:
Was it sad enough to make you cry? Even a drop of tear counts.

I cried because it was such a waste of time had a mini panic attack type shi -manga messiah

Aug 29, 8:45 PM

#24

Daniel_funes99

Offline

Apr 2021

532

Nah, but i usually dont cry when I read stuff. It did have moments where I was like damn, or where I went silent for a little while but i didnt cry not even shed a tear tbh.

Aug 29, 8:52 PM

#25

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

stayKrillinEm said:
No. With each chapter it started to feel like an endurance test in misery and I was a little angry by the end. I felt bad for certain characters (Punpun (sorta) and Aiko) but I never cried. I finished Blood on the Tracks earlier this year which was definitely a more emotional expierience.

I read Chi no Wadachi recently and feel the same as you

Aug 29, 9:47 PM

#26

_Maslo

Offline

Jul 2019

I remember I cried so much that I had to stop reading for a few days to pick it up again, I was too young in my opinion and I felt similarly to the characters in my own life so it was a bit too much for me, I still loved the manga but its a bit embarrassing I cried even in school when I was thinking about it, I should have read it later in life. I want to reread it soon tho

Aug 29, 9:48 PM

#27

Aylr

Offline

Jun 2016

256

yeah, this manga scarred me for life. like, after I finished it, I was so emotionally wrecked that I couldn't read any manga for months, it really left a mark on me.

Aug 29, 10:10 PM

#28

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

Aylr said:
yeah, this manga scarred me for life. like, after I finished it, I was so emotionally wrecked that I couldn't read any manga for months, it really left a mark on me.

I wish I could've felt it this much :(

Aug 29, 11:03 PM

#29

Ledatsiuha

Offline

Apr 2024

i don't remember🫣

Aug 30, 12:35 AM

#30

Kausthap

Offline

Sep 2018

At least three times. Very strong manga

Aug 30, 1:20 AM

#31

Hacker075

Offline

Mar 2021

318

BipulGamer07 said:

Hacker075 said:

If you're talking about

then I totally saw it coming

I am quite good at getting invested in the things I read or watch to the point where I'm not even slightly thinking about what might happen. Just solely focused on what's in front of me. I had the same thing with Fight Club where I didn't figure it out until it was pretty much stated.

Aug 30, 1:41 AM

#32

Laplace_kun

Offline

Nov 2019

2197

Not actually, it did get me stressed at times tho.

"All truth is meaningless. In the end, 'meaning' comes from the mind of each individual human. Even when there is a single truth, it can mean different things to different individuals. The truth has no meaning in itself!" - Erika Furudo

Aug 30, 1:44 AM

#33

Dr_Thicc

Offline

Apr 2021

No, I’m just not a fan of how Asano writes his characters. So a lot of the emotional parts end up falling flat for me

Aug 30, 1:56 AM

#34

treverse

Offline

Dec 2019

years past and when I remember I am sad. every time.

Aug 30, 4:02 AM

#35

illmachine

Offline

Jun 2020

totally!! i finished the last chapter at like 1 am in the morning and there i sat in silent for like 5 minutes and then broke down in tears crying for a good 15 minutes or so. i was absolutely damaged and broken that i have no other response other than crying thinking abt what the characters in the manga are feeling 🥲

Aug 30, 4:45 AM

#36

Kaitaka12

Offline

Aug 2023

138

Maybe I did shed a tear out of pity for a character but I don't remember where or for whom exactly it was, I also don't particularly remember how I felt when I read Punpun even though I read it almost half an year ago

Aug 30, 4:50 AM

#37

N1cklz

Offline

May 2021

a lot yeah also left me broken for a long time couldn't enjoy any media after punpun

Aug 30, 9:35 AM

#38

IguanaDestroyer

Offline

Mar 2023

Nah, I’m not really one to cry. That being said the stuff that happened in it has really stuck with me and makes me feel sad when I think about it.

Aug 30, 9:40 AM

#39

Liberandum_

Offline

Feb 2024

that feeling of wanting to cherish her, I want you to believe that was real

from punpuns dad made me tear up

Aug 30, 10:13 AM

#40

FancyUnicorn

Offline

Apr 2018

Def didn't fuel my state into a spiral of depressing months

My Candies:

My Bonus Candies:

Aug 30, 12:59 PM

#41

Original_Orange

Offline

Aug 2017

I felt more shock than anything else when reading it and had a few times I put down the volume and had to take a walk before I picked it up again.

Aug 30, 1:46 PM

#42

-DxP-

Community Mod

Equanimity

Offline

Nov 2020

1564

No, I hardly ever cry, maybe once in 10 years (ok that's a bit of an exaggeration lol). Punpun is very deep, but I didn't really find it sad, Punpun rather made me think about life and shit.

A girl on the shore touched me a bit more emotionally, even though it was much shorter, Imo the MC's had a closer relationship than Punpun and Aiko. But I didn't cry here either.

Site & Forum Guidelines | How to Become a MAL Moderator

Aug 30, 3:39 PM

#43

187nev

Offline

Aug 2023

IT DID SO BAD I AM TRAUMATIZED

Aug 30, 5:50 PM

#44

luffysenchou

Offline

Jun 2024

1481

Nope, this manga didn't make me cry.

Aug 31, 12:48 AM

#45

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

209

-DxP- said:
No, I hardly ever cry, maybe once in 10 years (ok that's a bit of an exaggeration lol). Punpun is very deep, but I didn't really find it sad, Punpun rather made me think about life and shit.

A girl on the shore touched me a bit more emotionally, even though it was much shorter, Imo the MC's had a closer relationship than Punpun and Aiko. But I didn't cry here either.

Girl on the shore? Who're you talking about?

edit: I got it. It's another manga.

I'm somewhat like you. The only manga that ever made me cry is Chi no Wadachi. Give it a read :)

Aug 31, 7:36 AM

#46

-DxP-

Community Mod

Equanimity

Offline

Nov 2020

1564

Reply to BipulGamer07

Girl on the shore? Who're you talking about?

edit: I got it. It's another manga.

I'm somewhat like you. The only manga that ever made me cry is Chi no Wadachi. Give it a read :)

@BipulGamer07 yes, it's another manga by the same mangaka. I've been planning to read Chi no Wadachi for a while now, maybe I'll do it soon.

Site & Forum Guidelines | How to Become a MAL Moderator

Sep 1, 8:17 AM

#47

ForeverVirgin

Offline

Apr 2024

There were tears running down my face but i didn't cry

Sep 1, 9:05 AM

#48

Juanchoman

Offline

Sep 2013

629

Got teary eyed in some parts, but never cried. I got me thinking more of my life if anything.

sic mundus

Sep 1, 9:38 AM

#49

nicolis324

Offline

Oct 2022

I was emotional, in the fact that I was laughing at dark moments due to how messed up it was (that's just how I am tbh) and I enjoyed my time with it because of that. great story, but severely messed up

Sep 1, 10:14 PM

#50

Aylr

Offline

Jun 2016

256

Reply to BipulGamer07

Aylr said:
yeah, this manga scarred me for life. like, after I finished it, I was so emotionally wrecked that I couldn't read any manga for months, it really left a mark on me.

I wish I could've felt it this much :(

@BipulGamer07 sooo honestly, if I were to read it now that I'm older, and let's be honest, care much less about people and everything in general, it would probably barely affect me.

See All Discussions

» I feel like a psychopath caprisan - Aug 14, 2021	16	by INoLuv »» 2 hours ago
Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 59 Discussion Stark700 - Jul 22, 2013	30	by phantompain77 »» Yesterday, 11:14 PM
Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 58 Discussion Stark700 - Jul 22, 2013	13	by phantompain77 »» Yesterday, 11:05 PM
Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 57 Discussion Stark700 - Jul 22, 2013	22	by phantompain77 »» Yesterday, 10:31 PM
Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 56 Discussion Stark700 - Jul 22, 2013	26	by phantompain77 »» Nov 20, 10:22 PM

Did it make you cry?

More topics from this board

» I feel like a psychopath

Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 59 Discussion

Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 58 Discussion

Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 57 Discussion

Poll: » Oyasumi Punpun Chapter 56 Discussion

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters