Attack on Titan
| its just MAPPA's style when it comes to aot |
| AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA |
| if it bothers u this much, don't watch it and shut up. People make posts for the most stupid things recently in relation to aot, it's getting old. |
| I mean I could understand not liking or preferring the shaded lines but calling it dumb is just dumb in itself. |
 "To the boy who once sought freedom, goodbye." ποΈ |
| So...MAPPA's adaptation looks dumb, because of some lines you didn't like... Yup...this one seems like an unbiased and well communicated opinion to me^^ Can't you just be like the other dudes, posting "aNiMAtiOOn baaAAdddD, mAppA sUcKs!!!!!111" ...or something like that? No need to sugar coat, my dude. It's alright. |
 |
IceCreamScene said: I really dislike the black lines, in seasons 1-3 they were used to show negative emotion but now they're used as casual shading and frankly it looks dumb. I get that it's more faithful to the manga this way, however the manga is in black and white so it makes sense, the anime is not, so why? I can understand your feelings. Perhaps they should've smudged the edged like they did in the FSP1 trailer. However their potential was wasted because of the schedule they were going through. Their art was a little simplified after FSP1 for the sake of animation and FSP2 looks dope, they made the art just a little bit more detailed in FSP3 and look still how great an animation they pulled out. Basically, the bold black lines done by wit looked cool, but honestly speaking sometimes it looked lame aswell. The linework in their art was more simple, but they were honestly horrible in season 1 and 2 because if how carelessly they were drawn to my eyes (they haven't even drawn a single smooth line, I don't have the images now, if I had I would've shown you), you can notice them if you zoom them in a little bit (and they are clearly visible if you watch them on TV). In season 3 though they improved their art by miles, every line was smooth and the art was also more detailed. However, after mappa took in the art took a jump. However it was so detailed some people didn't like that. But you'll get used to it as you continue watching final season, trust me. In the beginning I was a little disappointed too because I was really attached to the artstyle of wit studio, but once I got used to final season's art, my mind completely changed lmao.  |
MonsterSkasJul 20, 2023 3:39 AM
Snowflake_S said: Idk if its just me but in the past 24 hours, people on MAL have been attacking MAPPA and AOT π MAPPA is a horrible studio. And AOT is not the greatest. Good. |
Raionshin19 said: Deviiilchan said: if it bothers u this much, don't watch it and shut up. People make posts for the most stupid things recently in relation to aot, it's getting old. I know right? It’s getting on my nerves. Mappa did an amazing job especially when you consider the working conditions during Covid Yeah, people sometimes really forget under what confitions animators, not only at Mappa, have to work and that, especially with big shows like aot, there are time limits too. |
Snowflake_S said: Idk if its just me but in the past 24 hours, people on MAL have been attacking MAPPA and AOT π Average mal user activity |
Leon888 said: It didn't suck tho, that's were you're simply wrong. Like said before, if you hate it so much why don't u just not watch it and shut up? People like you want to be different so badly.Deviiilchan said: Because people, they don't have to know, if you watch a movie and that movie sucks, you don't go see all the problems that arose during the production of that movie... the anime sucked and it's irrelevant if the animators whether or not they had problems during productionYeah, people sometimes really forget under what confitions animators, not only at Mappa, have to work and that, especially with big shows like aot, there are time limits too. |
Leon888 said: Deviiilchan said: are you stupid ? I could ask you the same question, if you don't like negative comments why don't you stop watching them and shut up? lol, like we have to shut up when a show is bad, just because otherwise fanboys like you will cryIt didn't suck tho, that's were you're simply wrong. Like said before, if you hate it so much why don't u just not watch it and shut up? People like you want to be different so badly. Alr attention seeker, lol. u r not special for hating on something that is objectively good you know? If u hate it this much ..to take time out of ur day to spend this much time thinking abt it, maybe there's something wrong w ur head xd |
Monster_Skas said: IceCreamScene said: I really dislike the black lines, in seasons 1-3 they were used to show negative emotion but now they're used as casual shading and frankly it looks dumb. I get that it's more faithful to the manga this way, however the manga is in black and white so it makes sense, the anime is not, so why? I can understand your feelings. Perhaps they should've smudged the edged like they did in the FSP1 trailer. However their potential was wasted because of the schedule they were going through. Their art was a little simplified after FSP1 for the sake of animation and FSP2 looks dope, they made the art just a little bit more detailed in FSP3 and look still how great an animation they pulled out. Basically, the bold black lines done by wit looked cool, but honestly speaking sometimes it looked lame aswell. The linework in their art was more simple, but they were honestly horrible in season 1 and 2 because if how carelessly they were drawn to my eyes (they haven't even drawn a single smooth line, I don't have the images now, if I had I would've shown you), you can notice then if you zoom them in a little bit (and they are clearly visible if you watch them on TV). In season 3 though they improved their art by miles, every line was smooth and the art was also more detailed. However, after mappa took in the art took a jump. However it was so detailed some people didn't like that. But you'll get used to it as you continue watching final season, trust me. In the beginning I was a little disappointed too because I was really attacked to the artstyle of wit studio, but once I got used to final season's art, my mind completely changed lmao. Thank you for clearing this up, at first I thought @IceCreamScene was being racist taking about black peoples speaking lines, but after I read more I was just confused. Honestly I think the shading just has a more rough and edgy look that fits the tone of Attack on Titan very well, it makes it stand out more compared to most anime. I never thought anything else of it. |
EP1C_G4YM3R said: Monster_Skas said: I can understand your feelings. Perhaps they should've smudged the edged like they did in the FSP1 trailer. However their potential was wasted because of the schedule they were going through. Their art was a little simplified after FSP1 for the sake of animation and FSP2 looks dope, they made the art just a little bit more detailed in FSP3 and look still how great an animation they pulled out. Basically, the bold black lines done by wit looked cool, but honestly speaking sometimes it looked lame aswell. The linework in their art was more simple, but they were honestly horrible in season 1 and 2 because if how carelessly they were drawn to my eyes (they haven't even drawn a single smooth line, I don't have the images now, if I had I would've shown you), you can notice then if you zoom them in a little bit (and they are clearly visible if you watch them on TV). In season 3 though they improved their art by miles, every line was smooth and the art was also more detailed. However, after mappa took in the art took a jump. However it was so detailed some people didn't like that. But you'll get used to it as you continue watching final season, trust me. In the beginning I was a little disappointed too because I was really attacked to the artstyle of wit studio, but once I got used to final season's art, my mind completely changed lmao. Thank you for clearing this up, at first I thought @IceCreamScene was being racist taking about black peoples speaking lines, but after I read more I was just confused. Honestly I think the shading just has a more rough and edgy look that fits the tone of Attack on Titan very well, it makes it stand out more compared to most anime. I never thought anything else of it. Basically its all about enjoying a show. There's really no need of over-analyzing, both the studios have done a really good job, and they were two of the best studios which could've ever adapted the show. Honestly, AOT is all about plot, but what we're getting is both good plot and good animation, I'm happy enough with it, there's no limit to how better things can be, but I'm almost satisfied with what they pulled out. Next, I'm really curious about what they'll do to the ending, I hope they'll nail it, it's studio MAPPA we're talking about. |
Leon888 said: You've never seen what actually terrible animation looks like. Monster_Skas said: i just know that mappa ruined aot with their terrible animation in the final season, these problems has never arisen with WitExactly man. Tho I've always liked mappa I often found it weird when people tried to defend FS P1's animation by saying stuff like "they had less time" or "they made it during covid". Their logic is right, but that doesn't change the fact that FS P1 still had poor animation compared to previous seasons. However, people often blame mappa for what they did to FS P1, that shouldn't be done, cuz the devil is someone else. Mappa really isn't that bad, they know their shit. |
Leon888 said: Deviiilchan said: Attention seeker, doesn't it make you special to stick up for something that objectively sucks, if seeing the truth in the face makes you cry that much, maybe there's something wrong w ur head ;)The only one crying is you though. Alr attention seeker, lol. u r not special for hating on something that is objectively good you know? If u hate it this much ..to take time out of ur day to spend this much time thinking abt it, maybe there's something wrong w ur head xd Leon888 said: The only one crying is you though. It does, objectively speaking, not suck. Yiur opinion is just wrong there, but it's still yours I guess. There is a reason why aot is still popular and loved by a lot of people and, surprise, why almost no one shares your view on this. Deviiilchan said: Attention seeker, doesn't it make you special to stick up for something that objectively sucks, if seeing the truth in the face makes you cry that much, maybe there's something wrong w ur head ;)Alr attention seeker, lol. u r not special for hating on something that is objectively good you know? If u hate it this much ..to take time out of ur day to spend this much time thinking abt it, maybe there's something wrong w ur head xd |
| I like MAPPA's animation style. Removing the thick black lines is a good choice. π With WIT Studio, it feels as if the black lines are really thick. It's not bad to cast shadows and all that; but, WIT Studio could have done better without it. |
 ------------------------- Marianne ~Effort, Fortitude, and Tenacity |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 31, 2021 |
823 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 23, 7:26 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 24, 2021 |
989 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 23, 1:32 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 17, 2021 |
1048 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 23, 12:29 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 10, 2021 |
989 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 21, 7:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 27, 2020 |
463 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 21, 7:02 PM |