Dravise123 said:Daniel_Naumov said:
This is fine. You are unable to properly answer my remarks since you clearly understand how uncultured and lacking effort is your input on this episode discussion thread. Accepting the problem and understanding it is 2/3 of solving it. Be blessed.
I also feel that this ep was more for shock value but I’ll give some credit where it’s due , magase posing as the taiyou kid mother was a unexpected but nice touch ( idk if its just me but I didn’t see it coming)
The scene where magase was casually telling the chief to write down his “death message” in front of many other officers “spellbound” shows the cunningness of magase and gave me suspense of what is gonna happen next (I knew what was gonna happen but I wanted to see how it was animated)
Now after the praise, now for the shitfest
1. Sekuro torture scene was very unnecessary - I get the point was to break down Seizaki but wtf , I pretty sure he was already more than a little traumatized by seeing his friend off himself and so many others in the task force . That scene was nothing more than shock value , to its credit, the transition between the innocent family making lunch and sekuro getting mauled was disturbing. I’m not sure if that scene was originally the the Source material but if it was , that still was excessive
2. Magase herself- idc ,nothing the story does or says through flashbacks or backstory can ever make her redeemable or understandable. She is just a disturbed women . This is not inherently something point to everyone, it’s just a bad point to me to add a edgelord who gets off torturing people.On a side note , why does she have more favorites than the women she tortured on MAL?
3. Contradicting story - earlier we see the post operating interrogation, we can clearly see the officer interrogating Seizaki. There it was established that most of the police force clearly do not believe the existence of magase. A second later we see a stream of magase torturing sekuro, if seizaki is not on the case in the next episode with half of the police force after having very incriminating evidence of magase existence and her torturing a women working for the police, well it just proves further that torture scene was only for shock value because what police depart will stand by after a blatant murder of a women in their own industry
Thank you for actually trying to be a worthy person visiting forums, it means a lot that at least some still exist. I will address your points now.
1. You are wrong, that scene is crucial to the whole narrative. I understand why you would feel such way, and I still believe this is (sub)conscious dissatisfaction with excessive violence. Nevertheless, your or anyone's mental predisposition does not give or take value and importance of such scenes. We are shown how completely out of control is Magase Ai, and how little grasp of the whole situation Seizaki Zen has. Just like everyone else he believed that Itsuki is the one pulling strings. I doubt he does anymore. Shock value is honestly an empty phrase. Either the scene has meaning, or it does not and is frankly redundant. Just like Magase Ai claims everything has a meaning, that scene had extremely potent meaning in itself. This is not just some excessive violence - this is how insane crimes happen. Someone cuts someone else up. While someone's family is happily making dinner or thinking about the future. This is the real society we (them Japanese) live in. If it is to change we have to accept it even in such medium as art. The mindset comes first, but I digress.
Magase Ai specializes in psychology and she does what she does to unhinge Zen, to throw him off his refined self and to make him fall closer to her level - a villain. Which is why she does these evil things, to make him believe there is no other way to stop her but to shoot her. Since she would get away from prison and prosecutors. She was shown to control men after all. That scene is crucial to the whole narrative, because if what I say is to happen, then only through such gruesome, inhumane and shocking (as many seem to believe, I didn't twitch) experience can Zen believably drop from his pedestal and seek revenge instead of justice. Or maybe he would become a hero himself. To be seen.
In conclusion I strongly disagree with your understanding of the said execution scene, as you look at it through the prism of your own borders, you create a mental block. You do not go beyond to perceive it through the narrative, context, and reality. As it should be perceived, as the authors intend it (hopefully, proper authors should).
2.You don't want me to write a discourse into why the locals "favourite" the villain more than the victim. It is a cruel and humiliating narrative, the masses of MAL users. Some kid was calling mass-murderer a good guy several posts ago. Some questions... are better left unanswered.
However I will address the former point. The main problem with your second point is - you are talking about her character as if you know everything about her. Everything the authors wanted us to know or assume, anyway. Because, as you can see, we are merely on episode 8. It is not a newfound storytelling technique to prove an exposition, a massive one, for the villain right until the finale, to keep it all mysterious, almost meaningless. As I have pointed in my previous replies here and on reddit, she is doing what she is doing for a reason - most obvious one is to break Seizaki Zen and to bring him to shoot her. That's not an "edgelord" or a simply disturbed villain. There is more to it. I might be willing to spoiler another series and explain the depth her character might be going to, if you wish. Before we can with certainty say that her character is meaningless, we must witness it completely. This is not a simple series, it's a social critique and a statement, somewhere there, I hope.
3.Well the problem could be in two places - they do not believe something like Magase Ai could exist. Seizaki is the only one who actually knows she exists and is evolved, everyone else has perished, by that point. OR they could all be "on it" already, controlled to pretend that nothing is happening. As for the stream, as you said, it's in the next episode, so we can't tell what is going to happen. I could say that the stream website maybe does not have a saving function. Someone would argue that this is not possible in 2019. PPffft naivety. Even if they put all-points bulletin on her, they will still have to look for someone who had outsmarted... the whole society basically. Getting close to something as absurd as suicide-law. But please, stay determined and I am sure we will see how well and thought-out this series is. |