DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Seem this series is continuing with the trend of its tournament battle elements. More of the team members vs team member stuff. I know this isn't the series' finale as there are two more episodes left but I had a weird feeling about the way the characters were used. Or rather, the way some of the powers were used and certain characters targeted. That being said, it felt like a show that I didn't find worth investing time into by this point. Not really having much hopes for the final two either. That depressing ending... |
Stark700Mar 29, 2018 8:22 AM
 |
| Still looked bad, but nowhere near the dumpster fire of last week. If the way I read the stories were accurate, this is where the extra work went, not the previous one. IIRC, they gave up on ep 9 as it was. |
 |
| Not as terrible as the previous episode, but it's still a bad episode. The backstory for Lynne came in too late and I simply didn't care. It appears the committee was forced to do those things. Some major schools just decided to drop out. |
 |
| The purpose of the plot revealed...very late in the series's lifespan...that honestly was very late to salvage any promise in this series. The animation (for luck's sake) wasn't continued from Episode 9, so that's a good point I can say about the entire "last" 25 mins that leaves the fate of this show into the unknown. Will I wait? Or don't bother? Maybe when it comes back... |
 |
Morag_23 said: BlackstarFallen said: Not as terrible as the previous episode, but it's still a bad episode. The backstory for Lynne came in too late and I simply didn't care. It appears the committee was forced to do those things. Some major schools just decided to drop out. It's just you who don't like it. You can be the voice of the majority, but not everyone. I'm pretty sure there are lots of people that don't like this show as well. What makes you think I'm speaking for the majority, I wasn't. I'm just voicing my own opinion, not for anyone else. |
|
| didn't she withdraw is she allowed to just butt in like that |
Morag_23 said: If there's people who say the animation is bad: 1. You have no taste. 2. It's because of people like you the team lost motivation. The animation was great today and one of the best I ever seen. I'm really sad episode 11 & 12 won't be broadcasting, so I really hope DVD will come in North America one day! You're either blind or have a stake in this show. Maybe both. We've seen the stories from inside the production. They don't jibe with what you're telling us. |
| |
| ... and with a single line from Lynne Daves, we now know why she's such a vicious conniving bitch, and I can no longer see this as something that works for kids. ._.;;; Why the hell did they have to go THAT casually into dark territory? >_< |
 |
| Abusive raped past for Lynne to justify her behavior :( Shizuka comes back and they win with a literal moon drop. 8/10 for hazuki. |
 |
ReclusiveBeeBody said: Lynne's backstory is meant to make you sympathize with her and understand her nasty behaviour, and while I understood why she is the way she is, I found myself not caring about her breakdown. It felt like it came out of nowhere. Sadly, if you view it from a realistic standpoint, if she continues on this way she'll end up abusing more people as she gets older.he only males in her life are messed up, so she'll find bad guys to be with who will hurt her. If she gets married (or not) and has kids, she'll probably abuse them as well. She fearful of the abuse from the orphanage, but she clearly enjoys hurting people, so I don't see that stopping unless she gets some therapy. Or some friendship magic. Whichever comes first. Simply positioning her as an orphan would have been enough to get sympathy points. Her underhanded anything goes methods would make sense if used to repay her adoptive father, even if just for taking her into his family. Talking about it for more than 3sec out of the entirety of the show would have done considerably more to make her even a tiny bit sympathetic than stating a past of physical and sexual abuse as a borderline offhand remark accompanied by a Chester the Molester rapeface closeup of an evil priest. :/ Don't mind me, I'm just shocked that they did this for no justifiable reason as far as I can tell. This small sequence in the 10th episode knocks it out of being recommendable for me. :( |
|
| Ehh, that rape past was really out of the blue but at least the animation seems to have gone back to acceptable levels lol. |
| The animation is back to usual. Huge respect to the animators that worked so hard for this series. Story is still bad, though. |
This is a fallacy, Sakurada Reset got bashed by a lot of people who dropped and considered it a miss halfway through its season. Yet, I've never heard nor read of DP giving up because their anime weren't well received in the community. Now, get your butthurt opinion somewhere else and grow up. |
| "We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
Morag_23 said: If there's people who say the animation is bad: 1. You have no taste. 2. It's because of people like you the team lost motivation. The animation was great today and one of the best I ever seen. I'm really sad episode 11 & 12 won't be broadcasting, so I really hope DVD will come in North America one day! If you're a professional then you should never blame the customer or audience for your own failings, lots of shows flop, lots of shows are panned by the anime community but the people making them always do their best and complete them like the professionals they are. Even if you're part of making something that's not very popular there is still pride to be had from completing it. I understand you like this show and you're frustrated but this show was not brought down by the audience, it was brought down by the monumental incompetence of the production team. I'm not a cheerleader, it's not my job to fluff the (apparently fragile) ego's of the people making this anime, ultimately it's not my responsibility so it's not my fault either. This episode was alright, moon beats matchstick, the idea of having people draw things from famous books to fight each other is an intriguing concept but there is really no compelling strategy involved, the execution has been pretty weak. There is also too much behind the scenes stuff, they should be trying to tell one good simple story instead three bad complicated ones. |
| Forum Signature |
| Seems like the animation went to normal again, at least to the level of before EP09, lol. But yeah, OK episode I guess. Guess that's the show's temporary finish as well, until they announce a date for the remaining two eps. |
  |
| Seems they redeemed this episode by bringing back the original animation quality overall it was ok episode but why didn't they just state "We'll see you again later" instead of "Next Week" in the preview.. Hmm |
 |
| Is always funny to see yankees portrait as the bad guys and vice-versa, when clearly both sides did no good in the past. The difference of animaiton to the episode 9 is YUGE. Few more weeks of delay and they could have done it properly, but i know the schedule was probably not what caused this situation. Someone with the novel knowledge could make it clear, but in the translation a saw 'abuses' were mentioned and a priest with a weird face is show, but the meaning of that was really "rape" in the hentai sense? |
| In the end Hazuki is still shit, their team can't do shit without Shizuka. |
 |
| Glad that the animation quality is at least back to normal. Episode 9 was just a bad dream. Nice reference to american zombie films. Too bad the zombies are easy to get rid of because there are not enough team members to protect Lucy. Santa with guns inside the sack instead of gifts. And I have to admit.. Little Match Girl is one of my favorite stories. - I still remember my mother reading me that story years ago. Too bad, the British school forfeit.. would have been nice to see what they can do. And lastly, glad that Shizuka is finally ok now. Throwing down the moon is a nice way to end the fight. This show would have been good if only the original creator is still alive. Perhaps the production problems could have been avoided. 6.5/10 |
wolfwing said: still liking the series, but is no one going to acknowledge that 5 v 3 is a bit...lobsided, like can anyone join as long as signed up no matter how many? The american school did have an army of zombies with them... |
| Oh! It improved! FIVE/FIVE! haha.. |
 |
| This show started out OK for me and I even thought it got better in the mid-episodes. Then production problems blew up the show. Thank God the animation improved in ep 10, I guess they just gave up on 9 and focused on improving 10. But even though the animation was better, it was still nothing to brag about. The plot was OK, it was interesting, enough to keep me watching. If the production issues hadn't existed I think this could have been one of my favorite shows this season. Instead... The show has now died after ep 10 and who knows if we'll ever see the ending. I'm assuming this is it, so 3/5 for the ep and 5/10 for the series. |
| To be honest, I've kind of lost the plot with this show. I don't *really* understand what's going on, and there are too many parts where nothing really happens for me to want to rewatch it to try to work it out. |
???? |
| And Hazuki was... lol this anime is weird. |
| I like to post in manga forum when I feel it is worth it, so people will think. "Shit, is her again" or something. People asked me where I read certain thing but the rules say no telling where did you read so maybe I am too boring for not saying? Or salty because you didn't check my profile that says don't ask because I hate people to ghost me after that. I love learning languages so maybe I did not read the manga in English. |
| Well, this episode looked a lot better at least. It's too bad about all the production issues. Guess we'll just wait for episodes 11 and 12 now, whenever they come out. |
GranSaiyaman said: About the animation most of the people here said the obvious and mostly what I was goin to say about those scenes, I obviosly complained while watching the episode, a 2 weeks break to improve animation and we got THAT? But then I saw the preview and it looked pretty decent, even better than most of the animation for the anime overall, made me think about something; what if they started working on the episode 10 and 11 during the break and then they worked on the 9 but had to rush it because they had no time to end it? That would be the only way for me to explain that, for me that would make a lot of sense because you want a good animation for the action scenes rather than a filler event such as too little training and more of a sleepover, but I don't really know if that's the case. It seems that is just like I said, this episode looked better, at least we got back to the normal-slighty better quality. It's a shame that the fate of the last episodes is unknown, even when this anime is "bad" I still was pretty interesed in its development. See you some day again Märchen Mädchen :/. |
| One day I'll be active here, in the mean time I'll keep track of what I watch offline 😅 |
| Shizuka went Majora's Mask on their asses. There are things I genuinely liked about this series. Well, okay, one thing, and that's the gayness between Hazuki and Shizuka. Everything else was mediocre to bad. The whole Hexennacht plot was never interesting, it was just another anime tournament. None of the other characters were made very compelling. The animation was average at best, episode 9 at worst. Was there a soundtrack? It's a shame, despite the issues I really was enjoying it for the first few episodes. |
| People just randomly entering the battle mid way really diminishes the tournament's value. I get why they did this but it would have been a much better show if Hazuki won on her own at the end. Even better if Hazuki "saves" the opposite team once again in the process. Honestly they should have just stopped at episode 8 if they weren't going to finish and release later as OVAs. |
| WELL IT LOOKED BETTER THAN LAST EPISODE. Anyway, Tragic bacskstory comes in like a bird crashing into the window of a moving car and they fight. Moonfall was pretty cool, and pretty hilarious to see as well and America lost, but... the method used to win... kind of pisses me off... How can you just jump into the middle of a fight mid-match like that? |
A Wild and Small Otaku has Appeared! |
| really is sad with what happened with this series and all the drama around it but even so they did do their best to atleast give us this final ep (for now) but overall i did like the series with that said atleast we got to see the american team well Lynne Daves lose as she was hte main issue with the team and also gotta say really liked Sachi just to bad we only get to see her fully for 1 ep but yeah it was overall a nice watch regardless of the issues it had ,now to wonder if the last 2 eps will ever happen but imo i think this will just be the end for the anime which really sucks |
| "one step at a time" |
Liddo-kun said: wolfwing said: still liking the series, but is no one going to acknowledge that 5 v 3 is a bit...lobsided, like can anyone join as long as signed up no matter how many? The american school did have an army of zombies with them... Yeah, but it's coming from one magical girl, pretty unfair that 5 vs 3 Also, i didn't understand why sadohara went full suicide, it wasn't enough to pull the strings? |
Morag_23 said: HereticHunter said: This is a fallacy, Sakurada Reset got bashed by a lot of people who dropped and considered it a miss halfway through its season. Yet, I've never heard nor read of DP giving up because their anime weren't well received in the community. Now, get your butthurt opinion somewhere else and grow up. Grow up? Wow... I ask you the same. Yet, someone on Twitter know someone on the team and state that, so I don't think a made a mistake. But, what you said is also true. Rather than saying to grow up to someone else, while you said other opinions are sh*t, just see what is true on the other side like I did! ;) Do not distort what I said, I never said other opinions are shit. About that twitter I don't believe its true that they lost motivation because of MAL Forums or the score, that's just a fallacy. They just used the worst idea to an anime believing it would succeed and it didn't (Like Sin: Nanatsu no Taizai, which also sucked and was the end of a company, not the best decisions...) And, if they actually lost motivation, that doesn't change the fact that this anime sucked like a lot, I mean, they are supposed to be on a professional environment, if they can't take this amount of pressure, then what? They can't expect people to praise them for doing a bad job. Searching through their anime, the only good one they have is Drifters, everything else is generic ecchi/moe/hentai. And seeing how successful Drifters was, I'm amazed that they didn't even try to do something similar. |
| "We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Märchen Mädchen Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Mar 22, 2018 |
102 |
by CottonModem
»»
Oct 8, 12:55 AM |
|
» Updating the description to 12 EPsKalvin_ET - Jun 22 |
2 |
by Kalvin_ET
»»
Jun 22, 4:23 PM |
|
Poll: » Märchen Mädchen Episode 5 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 8, 2018 |
28 |
by PrawnGuard
»»
Jan 2, 2022 4:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Märchen Mädchen Episode 8 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 1, 2018 |
37 |
by Serafos
»»
Jul 19, 2021 12:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Märchen Mädchen Episode 7 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 22, 2018 |
28 |
by Serafos
»»
Jul 19, 2021 11:27 AM |