New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
May 4, 2009 6:14 AM
#101
Another fantastic episode! Judging from the first four episodes the rumour that the events in Higashi no Eden take place over 11 days could be true. Please continue being a messiah. |
May 4, 2009 6:29 AM
#102
Just started this series and its freaking great. Cna't wait for the next episode ^^ |
May 4, 2009 10:45 AM
#103
deafcon said: Pretty wicked episode. I can't believe this series is only going to be 11 episodes. I can't believe people are likening it to Death Note though. It's more similar to Bokurano or Gantz. same here to bad that this is going to have only 11 episodes I just started to like it more and more each episode -__- |
May 4, 2009 11:12 AM
#104
fantastic episode I feel only 11 episodes are going to leave holes which is probably what they want but as a fan you always want more |
~May you continue being the Messiah.... |
May 4, 2009 9:08 PM
#105
May 4, 2009 11:41 PM
#106
Am I the only one that liked the first two episodes but has been severely disappointed with the last two episodes? After watching the first two episodes, I thought this series had the potential to be one of my favorites and now I'm left wondering what the hell happened. First, I'll go over the obvious. There has been a drop off in production values. It's inevitable for most animes and it's been happening over the last 2 episodes. Given that this series is only 11 episodes, I'm really struggling to find it as acceptable as it is in something that spans a full season. The last two episodes have been necessities to push the story forward and establish the premise of the game but it seems its been treated as just that -- a necessity. I think it's been approached in a very dry, uninventive, and telegraphed manner that makes it seem as if they're treating it as a formality and just going through the motions. The life, death, and role of Detective Kondou pretty much never escaped the confines of being the pawn of the plot and his death was sold to establish the role of death but didn't even scrape the surface of death's severity because we never came to care about him. And the doctor from this episode pretty fell into an identical mold. A self-motivated participant whose life and death were under-utilized within the confines of the plot. To me, great characters are characters that find life in reality beyond where the story starts and stops. They're structured in a way where they make so much sense that we believe they're humans and thus associate with them on a deeper level. We let them become more than just characters in an anime because it feels like they're more than that. Even supporting characters should follow that mold. It really seems like this anime has severely underutilized their supporting characters thus far. Couple that with the dropping production values and it just feels like they aren't giving it their best swing at all. Nevermind the direction they've decided to take with some of the characters. I thought the general feel and atmosphere of the first two episodes was beautiful. I loved the dynamic that existed between Akira and Morimi. Their story was a simple, pure, and sweet tale of two lost individuals united by coincidence in a cold world filled with mystery and ambiguity. I thought that boat scene where Akira reached out to Morimi was pure simplicity and yet unbelievably beautiful. Both characters don't know who they are or where they're going and yet in that moment, he made the decision that despite the insecurity in his life, he wanted her to come along. She made the decision to step beyond the borders of her normality and put her faith not in her boring life but in Akira. And then just two episodes later, that was all totally and completely destroyed and forgotten. If they reintroduce her, they're going to pretty much need to reestablish all of that over again and it's highly unlikely they'll do so again with the same subtlety and naturalness. Quite sad. It's almost as if a different director has been working on these last two episodes. It seems the story has really tossed what it established in its first moments aside in favor of this very bland and dry plot pushing pair of episodes. It almost feels like I'm watching an entirely different show. They could've and should've carried everything forward together and within the same context rather than divided it so unnaturally. |
May 5, 2009 8:03 AM
#107
I started looking yesterday all four eps and were surprised how amazing good it is! The OP song is really good, it really fits this near-future animé. Can't wait to the next ep >__< |
May 5, 2009 8:06 AM
#108
KeroroGunsou said: Totally random, but I found it really cute how you put an accent aigu on the "e" for the word anime *giggles*I started looking yesterday all four eps and were surprised how amazing good it is! The OP song is really good, it really fits this near-future animé. Can't wait to the next ep >__< |
May 5, 2009 10:00 AM
#109
KeroroGunsou said: I started looking yesterday all four eps and were surprised how amazing good it is! The OP song is really good, it really fits this near-future animé. Can't wait to the next ep >__< Oasis is amazing indeed. School food punishment is cool too. You May Crawl Futuristic Imagination (East of Eden ed full MV) |
May 5, 2009 3:18 PM
#110
I haven't seen a drop in production. Don't know where your seeing that. It's still the best anime this season and is great. The doctor and detective served the roles to show their just pawns in the game that Akira just found out about. They did what they felt would either benefit the people or themselves and that's what they're suppose to do. Besides the time lapse between Saki and Akira parting ways is very tiny and they will run into each other again. It's not like it's been 4 weeks and it shattered and wouldn't make sense but it's only a day. Nothing is forgotten nor misplaced. Did you see the way she looked at the picture of them together? She obviously hasn't forgotten about him There's still going to be time to see their relationship grow but with the whole trying to find his memories and why he's being placed in this situation, there is no room for her to be in there for that time being. You can't analyze a plot like this that quickly because it has several different themes and stories going on that need to be intertwined at the end |
May 5, 2009 7:00 PM
#111
martin03345 said: I haven't seen a drop in production. Don't know where your seeing that. No offense intended, but if you can't see where they've been cutting corners with animation, you probably either don't watch enough anime or don't watch it closely enough. Here is a list of things to take notice of... 1.) The general quality of the animation (the detail and fluidity of the inbetweens). 2.) The number of independently moving objects on the screen at any given time (characters, cars, smoke, clouds, and other moving objects). 3.) the amount of movement those objects are doing at any given time (it takes more effort to animate someone running than someone talking). 4.) The amount of "panning" shots and buffer scenes where it's just sweeping over scenery or some other stationary picture. 5.) the amount of new and unique environments / background palettes. Look at all that, and you WILL notice a drop off. It's still the best anime this season and is great. If you're going to say something like that then don't turn around and say something like... You can't analyze a plot like this that quickly because it has several different themes and stories going on that need to be intertwined at the end. It's a little early for the double standards of fanboyism. If you're going to say it's too early to analyze and judge, then how are we supposed to come to your conclusion that this is the best anime this season (or that it's great)? The doctor and detective served the roles to show their just pawns in the game that Akira just found out about. They did what they felt would either benefit the people or themselves and that's what they're suppose to do. Except that since their individuality as independent characters was never fully established, the impact of this was never really utilized. We didn't know anything about them outside of their role as plot mechanisms. We weren't even really told anything about the extended reasoning or influences behind their decisions. We were just told what they did and its effect. You evidently think that was enough to associate with it and believe it. Pretty low standards if you ask me. It was quite simply a case of nothing gained, nothing lost. We didn't care they were pawns because they didn't make us care. Besides the time lapse between Saki and Akira parting ways is very tiny and they will run into each other again. It's not like it's been 4 weeks and it shattered and wouldn't make sense but it's only a day. Nothing is forgotten nor misplaced. Did you see the way she looked at the picture of them together? She obviously hasn't forgotten about him. Yep, the time gap between them parting ways was small. But, the actual gap in events was quite large when you think about how much we were given to digest. Since they parted ways, we've seen the detective die, found out the truth about the entire premise of the show, found out more about Akira, the limitations of Juiz, and seen another selecao die. All without Morimi in the mix and still without a hint she'll be joining us again. The show has separated the characters into different worlds just as fast as they brought them together through said boundaries and elevated them above them. We already knew they came from entirely different worlds. We already once saw them both agree to set aside the complications of the world for the simplicities of affection. Now, we're going to have to do it again... and given this series is 11 episodes, redundancy is your enemy. There's still going to be time to see their relationship grow but with the whole trying to find his memories and why he's being placed in this situation, there is no room for her to be in there for that time being. Funny you bring this up because she was actually helping him recover his memories. And, there is plenty of room for her to be in there. She already expressed the intent that she was okay with it and wanted to go along (only to be left behind as an afterthought). Part of the dynamic that made them so interesting was that neither really knew who they were. She was a product of her situation, lacked individuality, and didn't know what to do with life. He was obviously clueless about his situation and past. They were both reaching around in the dark trying to discover themselves and found companionship in doing so. He represented a bizarre world of the unknown. She represented normality. And, despite their differences, they found common ground along a common path. You can't analyze a plot like this that quickly because it has several different themes and stories going on that need to be intertwined at the end. Again, this series is 11 episodes. 4 have already aired. If this was your typical 26 episode series, we'd be halfway through episode 10. We're almost halfway through the show. It seems like you're forgetting that and often times failing to judge things in context. |
removed-userMay 6, 2009 6:33 PM
May 5, 2009 7:52 PM
#112
Hmm, I generally agree with what you're saying, Brian, but I think you're taking a harsher stance than I see necessary. Is it true that the past two episodes were necessities to push the plot forward? Yes. Did it feel only as a necessity? No, I don't believe so. I also feel like you aren't giving credit with what they manged to do with both Selecao in the short time that they were on screen. With Kondou, in his time onscreen, we saw the glimpse of a shattered, disillusioned man who, after failing at trying to save the world, only wants to escape fate and lead a hedonistic life with his mistress and Akira's money. Had he been a main character, we'd say that his hedonism and disillusionment would be his tragic flaw, leading him to die publicly in the city he tried to save while no one batted an eye. With Dr. Hajime, I think we also got a really good look at his motivation and considering length, the depth of his character. A man who, facing old age and a big ego as a surgeon, sunk into depression and alcoholism becomes a selecao and decides that he wants make sure that the rest of the elderly don't have to feel the same way as he does. Not to mention the fact that he jumped into this game never intending to win and accepting death peacefully is a really nice statement to make. With both characters, we're seeing the depths of despair that either lead them to becom selecao, or is the effect of their playing the game, and as a result leads us to question two things about Akira. 1) What happened to him that was so bad that he wanted to become a Selecao? 2) What happened to him that was so bad that he decided to erase his memories? I think you're undervaluing the strength of the characters because they had to work concurrently as plot devices, which sells them short greatly on their own. Concerning Akira and Saki's relationship, again, I think that you're undervaluing what's gone on. I think it's a little weird that you think that their relationship has been completely destroyed because she had a life to get back to. If this were a movie, then yes, I totally see what you're talking about, but because this is a televised series, I think that Saki does need to be able to walk away for a bit and really develop a need to be excited by Akira and not just swept away. Her feelings for him have not dissapated as you have said because she spent most of the day thinking about him. As you smartly pointed out, both characters are lost individuals, so, if this is going to work as a romance on top of an action thriller, we need to be able to have context of Saki as a character and what she is all about. We've had hints in the same way that we got hints on Akira in this episode, but because she hasn't lost her memory, and she's a bit of an Alice to this wonderland, we need more of a solid story on her so that it is more moving to see her jump down the rabbit hole. And regarding the structure of the series, because the movie was pretty much announced with the show, I'd expect for one part of the show to be wrapped in the series (probably the romance, or Akira's memories) so that the last (most likely Akira's duty as a Selecao) to take precedence in the movie. |
noteDheroMay 5, 2009 7:55 PM
May 5, 2009 8:37 PM
#113
For those who may not know, the Juiz and Selecao are the brazilian portuguese football terms for "Referee" and "Selection" and the Selecao badge shape is exactly the same as the Brazilian National Football Team, the CBF. Those who made this anime are really football addicted =) I think all japanese loves brazilian soccer because 2002 World Cup, which we won \o/ |
May 5, 2009 9:39 PM
#114
I've seen my fair share of anime and this show has not had a tremendous drop in quality at all. Maybe it's not as sharp as the first two episodes but if you haven't noticed, most series animation and production values drop off after awhile. Case and point would be Michiko e Hatchin which had phenomenal production values but some of the last episodes had some pretty poor production compared to others. The series nowhere near has anything of a major drop in production quality. Even with it not being as polished as the first two episodes, there's no where near a giant drop in quality that would make you have to sit and wonder what they are doing. It's still a great looking show and eye catching. And my statement about it being the best show this season isn't a show of fanboyism at all. It's 4 episodes in, for all I know it could end up being one of the worst. But right now with it's high production values, sound, and entriging plot, it has more to offer then other shows out there With what's shown so far, it proves to be a high grade anime and saying that one needs more time to analyze the story is not hypocritical at all. Yes it's almost halfway through the series but if you haven't noticed, it's trying to fit in a pretty big story for something that's only 11 episodes. The doctor and detective easily served their roles as characters within the series. With the organization that they are a part of, they are not suppose to be be individuals but just mere faces who are puppets in a way of what they are being asked to do. Glimpses of what they were trying to accomplish were shown which is good enough when what they are is just puppets. Kondou was shown to be ruthless and out for himself when using his money and not really bettering the nation. His motives and personality were truly shown while Dr. Hajime was shown to be like Dhero stated. From what we've seen you either are gonna wonder why they are pawns in the game or just see them for what they are, pawns. And there is nothing wrong with that at all because as I said, they are puppets of what is going on. They have the will to do what they please but also are puppets in the sense that they are attached to the game. The fact that there are so many events going on in such a small time span does not at all separate Saki and Akira into two different worlds. In fact they may be there for now but there will be a magnet that draws them back together. That's a given. Saying well she has now nothing to do with what's going on is false.Once again, Dhero summed it up perfectly as she's an Alice in Wonderland type character trying to figure out her emotions while Akira now needs to find out who he is. It's two different forms of discovery for the characters that will certainly lead back to one another. The fact that he was split from her to track down Kondou shows that he feels some semblance of emotion for her because he doesn't want her to get involved with the dangerous game he is in. So with the 4 episodes shown, its easy for you to say well they fucked it up because so little time is left but in fact there still is plenty of time especially with a movie coming out to sum up and tie everything up. Obviously the series won't cover every inch of ground that needs to thus you need take a breather and realize what is being shown now is being done well |
martin03345May 5, 2009 9:55 PM
May 5, 2009 9:50 PM
#115
Brian333 said: The last two episodes have been necessities to push the story forward and establish the premise of the game but it seems its been treated as just that -- a necessity. I think it's been approached in a very dry, uninventive, and telegraphed manner that makes it seem as if they're treating it as a formality and just going through the motions. I agree with you there, the presentation of the story has been too blatantly forced in the last two episodes. :( |
May 6, 2009 7:28 AM
#116
Anyways, these replies will probably be a little shorter and less detailed than I would like them to be. I just simply don't really have the same amount of time to consistently dedicate myself to discussions like these anymore. I'd love to type more but I work and am often times too tired to do much outside of the office. To noteDhero Just to start, I appreciate and respect the thought put into your response. noteDhero said: Hmm, I generally agree with what you're saying, Brian, but I think you're taking a harsher stance than I see necessary. Is it true that the past two episodes were necessities to push the plot forward? Yes. Did it feel only as a necessity? No, I don't believe so. I also feel like you aren't giving credit with what they manged to do with both Selecao in the short time that they were on screen. ... I'm too lazy to re-read everything I wrote again but just going off of what's in my memory, I never intended the post to bash the series. I think the first two episodes set the bar pretty high, and the series itself gives us good reason to hold it to very high standards (the studio, the director, etc). Quite frankly, I expected no less than a modern classic and was just a bit put off by the last two episodes. I understand the function of the two deceased Selecao. I understand what they were, their identities as characters and what they represented. It's just that you had to come to those conclusions in a manner that didn't do the material much justice. Now I'm not trying to suggest they should spoon feed us everything -- they simply do not have the time to do so -- but what I do have a problem with is the manner in which they communicated what you just wrote. It was pretty much dry as paper, lacked subtlety, and lacked any real draw in to make us care. That's my problem with how those two characters were handled. Since I figure it might've come off a bit more harsh than it should've, I'll just say that I thought the characters were great characters if you forced yourself to read into them and understand them. But again, given everything they were, the way their stories were told and the way they were established as characters didn't do much for them. The detective barely did anything. He stalked Akira down, beat him up, stole his phone, found out he couldn't use it, and then got stabbed to death by his wife. In Kondou's dying moments, he just nonchalantly had a little chat with Akira, gave his phone back, and then died. The big, enlightening moments that really filled us in on the Detective's identity and what the selecao were was pretty much communicated in an incredibly dry, uninteresting, straight-forward face-to-face conversation. They really could've gotten more out of that all on multiple levels. He could've made a bigger deal of his regret, remorse, his despair than what we were given. He could've been much, much more human. And pretty much the exact same thing holds true for the doctor. Incredibly dry, uninteresting, and straight-forward portrayal of an otherwise interesting background and character. His story, his motives, his intentions, and his entire life was pretty much given to us in a monologue over a handful of panning scenery shots and facial cuts. Never at any point was I ever really drawn into the doctor as a character. I just listened, came to the conclusions you detailed, and then that was it. The doctor was dead like a minute later. They really could've gotten more out of it all. They could've walked the halls of the hospital and used the patients the doctor saved as a background. I generally dislike the use of flash-backs but that might have been an option. They could've established him as a father who lost the rest of his family (cliche I know... but good execution often makes us forget about it). Even with the same general time constraints, they could've done more but didn't. As for Akira and Saki's relationship, I never intended to say that the relationship itself was destroyed. I was referring to the atmosphere, feel, and the moments that they had created up to the point where they split paths. I thought those things were compromised because their separation felt so... cheap. She just kind of got up and left and he just kind of laughed at the sight of the note and went on with his business. It's kind of like going home to a wife that's cooking your favorite meal for you in nothing but an apron... and then walking over to the couch and turning on ESPN to see what game is on. I think it's incredibly important that they establish both characters. But, given what we saw of their relationship in the early going, I thought they would be embarking together on their journey to discover themselves. He reached out to her and she gladly jumped on for the ride. I thought that they would've went about the process of character development in a less isolated manner. I think that would've been more interesting... seeing two, seemingly different characters discover themselves and their more profound similarities as they tread a singular path. But, I guess it's a choice they made. Perhaps developing the two separately will only further hammer in their differing backgrounds and maybe ultimately give more meaning to their reunion. I just think it's redundant. And I haven't really read much about the movie. To be quite honest, I would rather it not be a continuation. I think it would be fascinating if they made it about Akira before the series. I think the opening monologue from Saki in the first episode would be a wonderful tie in (and make perfect sense), too. edit: well that turned out longer than I thought it would... |
removed-userMay 6, 2009 10:15 AM
May 6, 2009 9:06 AM
#117
I know this is a double post and it's preferred we don't do this but if a mod sees this, I beg you exercise a little lenience. It's just a lot easier to read if I split my two responses across two posts. I'm not post whoring. I couldn't care less about that. To martin03345 martin03345 said: I've seen my fair share of anime and this show has not had a tremendous drop in quality at all. Maybe it's not as sharp as the first two episodes but if you haven't noticed, most series animation and production values drop off after awhile. Case and point would be Michiko e Hatchin which had phenomenal production values but some of the last episodes had some pretty poor production compared to others. The series nowhere near has anything of a major drop in production quality. Even with it not being as polished as the first two episodes, there's no where near a giant drop in quality that would make you have to sit and wonder what they are doing. It's still a great looking show and eye catching. Well, I really don't know what to say. Watch episode 4 and then go back and watch episode 1. I don't know what your definition of tremendous is but there has been quite a large drop off. And, as for questioning my knowledge of animes dropping off in production values, I don't think you need to worry about me since I opened my first paragraph regarding this issue by saying it's inevitable for most animes. I figured that would've told you I already knew it was common practice to front-load your budget a bit to sell the series early. And my statement about it being the best show this season isn't a show of fanboyism at all. It's 4 episodes in, for all I know it could end up being one of the worst. But right now with it's high production values, sound, and entriging plot, it has more to offer then other shows out there With what's shown so far, it proves to be a high grade anime and saying that one needs more time to analyze the story is not hypocritical at all. Yes it's almost halfway through the series but if you haven't noticed, it's trying to fit in a pretty big story for something that's only 11 episodes. What's hypocritical here is that you're basing your opinion of this series on your own conclusive analysis of the story (by saying it's intriguing) and then turn around to tell me that it's too early to judge and analyze the story when you already did just that. And, if it's a long and detailed story, wouldn't that mean that after 4 episodes, we've already been fed a lot of material to look at? It's not too early to analyze the plot. It's not too early to break down the story for what it is. There might still be a lot to get through but that doesn't change the fact that there is already a lot on the table. The doctor and detective easily served their roles as characters within the series. With the organization that they are a part of, they are not suppose to be be individuals but just mere faces who are puppets in a way of what they are being asked to do. Glimpses of what they were trying to accomplish were shown which is good enough when what they are is just puppets. Kondou was shown to be ruthless and out for himself when using his money and not really bettering the nation. His motives and personality were truly shown while Dr. Hajime was shown to be like Dhero stated. From what we've seen you either are gonna wonder why they are pawns in the game or just see them for what they are, pawns. And there is nothing wrong with that at all because as I said, they are puppets of what is going on. They have the will to do what they please but also are puppets in the sense that they are attached to the game. No, I disagree completely and while you reference noteDhero's post, you missed his point. These people are very much individuals with their own motives, their own dreams, their own goals, and their own lives. He's arguing that there is plenty there to disprove the notion that the story sold them out (which is what I was arguing). If you are going the route of establishing individuality to take it away in an effort to prove a point about slavery to a system (and they DID take this route), you have to establish their individuality for that entire dynamic to have a good payload. The resulting impact from killing a character that was just a slave and died the death of a slave is entirely different from seeing the death of an upstanding individual that lived to his fullest... only to have everything taken away from him by the fact that he was a slave in a system he could not beat. We were not made to fully care about these characters so the fact that they were pawns didn't matter as much as it could've. That's what I'm saying. If Akira ultimately succumbs to the worse of his fate as a Selecao, then that would say a lot about being a pawn (since we actually care about Akira and really feel for him). Kondou and Hajime? not so much. The fact that there are so many events going on in such a small time span does not at all separate Saki and Akira into two different worlds. How does it not? Saki went home to her family-run-bakery and a loving family. Akira just witnessed two men die and found out he's a participant in your weekly televised 80 billion yen game of "save japan or die." Not exactly the same worlds. Saying well she has now nothing to do with what's going on is false. She has nothing to do with what's going on. It's not false. She might be reintroduced back into the flow of the story but she hasn't had any serious impact on what has happened with Akira since they parted ways. Once again, Dhero summed it up perfectly as she's an Alice in Wonderland type character trying to figure out her emotions while Akira now needs to find out who he is. It's two different forms of discovery for the characters that will certainly lead back to one another. The fact that he was split from her to track down Kondou shows that he feels some semblance of emotion for her because he doesn't want her to get involved with the dangerous game he is in. At this point, I'm getting tired of restating my points to you... so this will probably be the last time I do. After that, it's up to you to brush up on your reading comprehension and use of logic. Remember the first episode? Akira opened up the closet in his room to find something that would suggest that he's a very dangerous man caught up in a very dangerous lifestyle. Despite all that, Akira and Saki found joy in each other's company. In episode 2, Akira opened up to her and even beckoned for her to come along on his journey to find out about the mystery behind who he was. Saki gladly jumped onto the boat and he took a self-titled picture called "Ground Zero" of the two of them with a destroyed part of Japan as the background. I hate to be blunt, but if you don't see the symbolism in that scene, I don't think anything I say to you will mean much. It was already established that he was dangerous and that he knew he was dangerous. Despite all that, he still reached out to Saki. Now, after all that, we're suddenly supposed to believe that her safety is a concern? Really? So basically, what has happened is that he's taking back the expression of interest and the moments they had thus far... or atleast that's just how it seems. In other words, they're throwing out what happened before and putting themselves in a position where they're going to need to approach it all again -- the decisive moment of crossing the border and traveling from the world of normality to the world of the selecao, the moment of confirmation / affirmation. What they had was amazingly simple and it was a nice contrast to the complexity and ambiguity of the world at hand. What they're doing is just unnecessarily complicating things in my opinion. So with the 4 episodes shown, its easy for you to say well they fucked it up because so little time is left but in fact there still is plenty of time especially with a movie coming out to sum up and tie everything up. Obviously the series won't cover every inch of ground that needs to thus you need take a breather and realize what is being shown now is being done well I didn't say they fucked it up. Nothing I've said hints at that degree of severity. Fucking a show up would look something like CG:R2. What's happened with this series is far from being an inevitable train wreck in progress. I'm just commenting and discussing what we've been given. If you don't want to take part, then don't. Don't tell other people to stop thinking critically about the world, though. |
removed-userMay 6, 2009 11:40 AM
May 6, 2009 10:56 AM
#118
I never said to stop thinking critically you overly pretentious douchebag. No where in your post directed to me did you mention front loading done by animation production of most shows. I'm giving my own view on the story and the characters and how I believe things are going right now. With how it's set up so far, speculation on both sides is possible, I just said why I think your wrong and not stating that you are, there's a difference. I have a different view on how the characters are suppose to serve their role within the story and who they are, kind of like how it happens with a lot of other series that require some though. But what do I know, god here just decreed I have the reading skills of a retarded hamster and the logic of a mouse. Wonder what the hell I'm doing in college then. |
May 6, 2009 12:17 PM
#119
To martin03345 martin03345 said: I never said to stop thinking critically you overly pretentious douchebag. You just told me to take a breather and realize that what's being shown now is being done well. That sounds to me like you're telling me to overlook some flaws because of the nature of the show and just accept the "fact" that something is good. No where in your post directed to me did you mention front loading done by animation production of most shows. It wasn't directed at you but it was my first post in this topic. Post #109, second paragraph: Brian333 said: First, I'll go over the obvious. There has been a drop off in production values. It's inevitable for most animes and it's been happening over the last 2 episodes. Given that this series is only 11 episodes, I'm really struggling to find it as acceptable as it is in something that spans a full season. and again in post #114 (which was directed at you), first line after the quote: Brian333 said: No offense intended, but if you can't see where they've been cutting corners with animation, you probably either don't watch enough anime or don't watch it closely enough. Three times there I mentioned that it happens in other animes and twice I made note of it being a frequent occurrence. martin03345 said: I'm giving my own view on the story and the characters and how I believe things are going right now. With how it's set up so far, speculation on both sides is possible, I just said why I think your wrong and not stating that you are, there's a difference. I have a different view on how the characters are suppose to serve their role within the story and who they are, kind of like how it happens with a lot of other series that require some though. But what do I know, god here just decreed I have the reading skills of a retarded hamster and the logic of a mouse. Wonder what the hell I'm doing in college then. Look, I'm really not trying to be pretentious or condescending and I think you're overreacting to a line or two that wasn't meant to be nearly as offensive as you're making it sound. I'm just getting lazy and would rather you take the time to really read my posts because it just seems like you aren't. It's not like I told you "go back to fucking elementary school and learn how to god damn read." Sheesh. Just the act of taking the time to respond to nearly every line if not every line of your posts with an honest, thought out, and proof read (though I probably still missed some errors) response should be enough to suggest to you that I think there is plenty worth replying to. If I was a pretentious douchebag, I would just not respond and say you aren't worth my time. That's what a pretentious douchebag does. And as for this common debate regarding the nature of opinions, I'll just say that opinions can be wrong. And, I'm not saying that mine aren't. My opinion could be that 1+1=3 and I would be wrong because the facts suggest otherwise. In an argument, it's about supporting your opinion with facts when said opinions are questioned. If you don't want to hear about what other people think about the validity of your opinions, then why are you on a message board? In your opinion, I'm wrong but when I question why you think so and challenge your opinions all while supporting my own, this is how you respond? |
removed-userMay 6, 2009 12:21 PM
May 6, 2009 1:00 PM
#120
The way you worded it though however only states that you see a drop in the animation production for Eden which is easy to see but it's not directed to other shows doing the same as well. You must be just implying it that it happens which it does, no disagreement there. And you don't seem very lazy while posting. Your last two post were extraordinarily long. If anything seeing as you been giving me advice, I suggest you learn to be more concise. It'd go with your lazy tendencies and make people more willing to read your posts instead of skimming through trying to find the gist. Also, claiming to being lazy is not an excuse to go out of your way to tell someone to learn to read or be condescending about the manner. Doesn't matter if you don't think it's offensive because others could think differently. Finally, I'm not angered by someone challenging my opinions, I welcome it. I still think that you should give the show a bit more time, maybe one more episode or two before jumping on it saying it's being rushed and forced. If by then the occurrences happen, then you would be absolutely right, but for now, I feel that more is need to be shown because the plot as a whole is not fully exposed. You feel that the characters had no depth and were just there to advance the plot. I don't have time right now to elaborate in great detail why but you know we don't agree on that Anyway I'm sorry if I caused confusion or acted like a tool myself |
martin03345May 6, 2009 3:25 PM
May 6, 2009 7:30 PM
#122
To martin03345 martin03345 said: The way you worded it though however only states that you see a drop in the animation production for Eden which is easy to see but it's not directed to other shows doing the same as well. You must be just implying it that it happens which it does, no disagreement there. I don't see why there is this confusion. I very clearly said that it happens frequently in other anime. It IS directed at other shows which do the same though no specific names were given (since the mass majority do it). Read the two lines I quoted from myself in my last post. And you don't seem very lazy while posting. Your last two post were extraordinarily long. If anything seeing as you been giving me advice, I suggest you learn to be more concise. It'd go with your lazy tendencies and make people more willing to read your posts instead of skimming through trying to find the gist. If you're trying to talk to someone, skimming through what they're trying to say and forming a response based off that isn't the best idea. In my opinion, doing so is inconsiderate and disrespectful to the value of what they're saying. If someone is devoting themselves to a conversation, you should return the favor out of respect. And by my standards, those weren't even terribly long. It's nothing more than a few minutes of reading. As for my laziness, it has more to do with just getting tired of repeating myself over and over again. If I'm replying to a progressive conversation, I'm fine putting the effort into trying to communicate my points but if it's just rehashing the same old unaddressed points of discussion, it gets very tedious. Also, claiming to being lazy is not an excuse to go out of your way to tell someone to learn to read or be condescending about the manner. Doesn't matter if you don't think it's offensive because others could think differently. I told you that from now on, you're going to have to put in the time/effort to understand what I'm saying rather than have me repeat my points. It's not an excuse. I'm letting you know that I'm not going to repeat my old points just because you missed them. It's tiring, it's work that should be done by you, and it makes it harder to push forward in a discussion. Anyways, back to Higashi no Eden... Finally, I'm not angered by someone challenging my opinions, I welcome it. I still think that you should give the show a bit more time, maybe one more episode or two before jumping on it saying it's being rushed and forced. Thus far, I haven't said anything conclusive about the future of this show. I'm merely commenting on what has already happened. It's not too early to do so. It's not like I'm saying the entire show is very dry/uninventive and will continue to be so in the future. You feel that the characters had no depth and were just there to advance the plot. I don't have time right now to elaborate in great detail why but you know we don't agree on that. No depth is a terrible exaggeration. They have some depth (and could've had more). I'm saying the portrayal did a poor job of presenting that aspect of their character and that they never fully established the characters as human-like characters we can sympathize, associate with, and understand. I'm also saying that what you previously said about the story intentionally selling the characters short of their full potential to show us they were pawns in the game is simply not believable. They very apparently tried to establish the individuality of these characters in an effort to increase the value of their deaths by making us sympathize with them. I'm just saying they didn't do a good job at that. Anyway I'm sorry if I caused confusion or acted like a tool myself Well apology accepted. I apologize if I deeply offended you somewhere or if this post is too long. I tried to keep it short. I tried. |
May 6, 2009 9:48 PM
#123
Once again for me being lazy and not fully reading your posts. Your right it is disrespectful for me to do so. I understand your argument better now. My bad |
May 7, 2009 12:52 PM
#124
This anime sucks me right in straight from the start with the amazing OP from Oasis. Everything fits so well: character design, the story, the music. Possibly one of the best anime this season without a doubt. The doctor at least seemed very altruistic, and him dieing near the end was a sad event at the least, but necessary to advance the plot. |
"Thousands have lived without love, not one without water." -Wystan Hugh |
May 7, 2009 7:40 PM
#125
May 10, 2009 2:49 AM
#127
May 14, 2009 1:43 AM
#128
May 14, 2009 10:35 PM
#129
Darkii said: Cross Game, still best this season. This. And, yeah, poor doc. ;_; |
逃げちゃ駄目だ。 |
May 16, 2009 9:40 PM
#130
May 17, 2009 10:56 PM
#131
A few more issues are finally explained that makes me understand clearly about him and others, and the story is just extraordinary because I am enjoying to watch this episode. I am more interesting to know about the supporter and Mr. Outside. |
May 23, 2009 6:05 AM
#132
Hiura-sensei is a great person, what a pity... V has been killed by the supporter for breaking the rules as the Messiah. With 10 billion dollars, each selected individual will become a Selecao who can use the money to make a prosperous future for Japan and those who decide to abandon their mission or to waste the money for their own personal ideals will be eliminated by one of the 12 Selecao who is also known as the supporter. It is okay to bribe officials and politicians, as well as gunning down witnesses to necessary murders. However, it is considered as rule breaking for not doing so. Rule breaking takes away the rights as a Messiah and thus, one shall be gunned down and his or her status on the special cell phones will indicate that the number had been killed. Currently, IV was stabbed to death by his wife over a mistaken text message to his lover and V got gunned down by the supporter for using the money to help the elderly that are abandoned by the country by using that money to build a private hospital as a means of charity. Number IX is the protagonist and he seemed to have wiped his own memory after a possible mass murder incident in which he slaughtered 20,000 NEETs by gathering them at an isolated location and set the place ablaze. Considering that number V was gunned down by the supporter, it generally implies that number IX is not the supporter but just another one of the Selecao. Based on that shadowy figure, the supporter appears to be a middle-aged man in a business suit. With the other Selecao unknown, I am going to assume the next appearance of a Selecao in a business suit in his middle age as suspicious. This anime seems to be based off the Jason Bourne series with a more unique story to it. Those missile incidents are also quite mysterious.. If I am one of the Selecao, I will definitely know what to do to save the nation from heading in the wrong direction but that would also mean that it is necessary to remove some obstacles and threats that prevent peace and prosperity. However, Juiz will definitely not disappoint! |
May 24, 2009 12:54 AM
#133
May 25, 2009 8:53 AM
#134
Absolutely_Steve said: First half of the episode was boring, but the second half managed to turn things around. Still a bit disappointing as it didn't explain a whole lot that wasn't pretty obvious and Saki is becoming little more than a nuisance, but overall a pretty decent episode. I had the same thoughts about this episode. |
May 30, 2009 2:25 PM
#135
Wow the plot thickens, so many things I want to know! |
May 30, 2009 11:31 PM
#136
i love this series! damn akira is soooo cute! i want to gobble him up... oh well the epi where they kissed is oh soooo... romantic.... uhuhu! all hail higashi no eden!!!!! episode 8 here i come! |
Jun 4, 2009 5:35 PM
#137
This anime is one of the best I've ever watched! I wanna know who made up this "game"! |
I don't have a signature XD |
Jul 19, 2009 6:22 AM
#139
kie_ said: Also WTF was these white things? And it was weird how quickly his temperament changed when dealing with them... after they bit (did they?) him. I liked the explanations that have finally provided some answers... That doctor guy really was too nice. I was kinda surprised that Akira didn't even hesitate to take the medicine, but I guess he doesn't have to worry about the Supporter coming after him yet... (though he wouldn't have known that beforehand, so it's still weird that he just took the medicine even though it could very well have been poison. DX ) |
Jul 27, 2009 2:33 AM
#140
So the rules of the game have been revealed and we got 11 dudes trying to save the country. |
Aug 27, 2009 11:37 AM
#141
Jan 26, 2010 5:23 AM
#142
I just realized the whole OP theme is in English. I know, I fail. |
Mar 8, 2010 6:49 AM
#143
More and more questions with each episode, despite some of them being answered. So we know that he's not the Supporter. But who is? We also know that spending the money on something really good for society isn't enough - the goal i to save the country. What I don't get is why didn't Hiura's work count as one of the means to saving the country...And why Akira thought that taking 20k NEETs hostage (cause I don't really believe he killed them) would count xD What is Akira smoking? Talking about the Johnny Horde, of course. Why the heck would he call that a Johnny? And why did one of the Johnnies unzip his pants? D: Also, it was pretty obvious that Saki was in love with her brother-in-law, I think Ryousuke was his name xP The poster just confirms it. |
CenedessMar 8, 2010 7:16 AM
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
Apr 1, 2010 1:59 PM
#144
Apr 5, 2010 11:59 AM
#145
i'm falling in love with this show ...! |
Jun 3, 2010 7:57 PM
#146
Yata-sama said: My thoughts after this ep: Akira = Kira Akira's Phone = Death Note Lol. Not quite though. |
Jul 12, 2010 1:17 PM
#147
kie_ said: WTF was these white things? I wondered that too x-x I'm eager to find out who the supporter is X3 |
Aug 9, 2010 11:36 PM
#148
LovingHate said: kie_ said: WTF was these white things? I wondered that too x-x I'm eager to find out who the supporter is X3 totally |
Aug 10, 2010 7:20 AM
#149
a litte boring but ok....4/5 |
Sayonara,papa! "Just how a mirror reflects you,people will also reflect your heart." ~Athena Glory,Aria "Whatever happens,happens" ~Spike Spiegel's thoughts on dying(Cowboy Bebop) |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Higashi no Eden Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )dbaranyi - Jun 5, 2009 |
169 |
by curvedtree
»»
Jul 13, 11:17 AM |
|
» WHAT THE HELL WAS IN THE TRUCKS?!Sagepool - Feb 24 |
7 |
by CrazyButNot4U
»»
Feb 25, 1:19 PM |
|
Poll: » Higashi no Eden Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grapeofdeath - Jun 18, 2009 |
432 |
by OneMoreFinal
»»
Oct 21, 2023 4:06 PM |
|
» IS THERE ANY "HARD" EDEN OF THE EAST FANShitsugaya111 - Mar 22, 2018 |
7 |
by rent-free
»»
Jun 16, 2023 9:43 PM |
|
Poll: » Higashi no Eden Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Plate - Apr 9, 2009 |
403 |
by prozyne
»»
Apr 9, 2023 1:35 AM |