Why'd they remove the biggest anime film of the year so far from MAL?

Mar 17, 9:57 PM

Offline

Mar 2015

I really don't get it. Compilations are on this site, and it's been stated already that the editing will be different from the show.

Mar 17, 10:29 PM

KurokamiPhantom

Offline

Mar 2015

109

Was it ever listed here to begin with? I don't recall seeing it. I do agree, though. There's no reason for it not to be listed as its own thing.

Mar 17, 10:38 PM

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

Reply to KurokamiPhantom

Was it ever listed here to begin with? I don't recall seeing it. I do agree, though. There's no reason for it not to be listed as its own thing.

@KurokamiPhantom Yeah it was listed, but not approved. Now it's completely gone.
https://myanimelist.net/anime/60721/Kidou_Senshi_Gundam__GQuuuuuuX_-Beginning-

Mar 17, 11:59 PM

SHIZA_KAISER

Offline

Apr 2024

I still don't understand why. There are so many specials and compilation movies on MAL. Why did they remove GQuuuuuux? It even came out in theaters both in Japan and abroad.

Mar 18, 1:51 AM

Fortress_Maximus

Offline

Feb 2012

4173

I really don't know what logic is being followed.

Releasing the TV version later than the theatrical version has been done before with The Origin and Unicorn so we have Advent of the Red Comet and Re:0096 as separate entries from them on MAL.

Novels I have read/am reading pending approval: since November 10 2022

Mar 18, 1:52 AM

InfinityDude88

Offline

Jul 2020

657

I fully agree. If it had just been the episodes back to back then I would understand not listing it, but from what we saw it was clearly edited into a film format making it unique from the TV entry. If they counted The Origin theatrical rerelease from last year (which was only released in a few theatres in Japan for a limited time with essentially no change from the OVA) then it would be downright hypocritical to not include this.

Mar 18, 11:24 PM

n_2000

enjoy life

Offline

Jun 2014

104

I don’t get this. Mods please put it back lol

Mar 19, 12:13 AM

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

Reply to n_2000

I don’t get this. Mods please put it back lol

@n_2000 yeah lol. Please.

Mar 19, 4:57 AM

LostSpectre

Online

Jan 2013

6534

nah tag all the mods in this thread there's simply no reason it shouldn't be listed lol

If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that.

Mar 19, 5:55 AM

#10

Raxivace

Offline

Dec 2012

The mod's souls are weighed down by gravity tbh.

Mar 19, 6:56 AM

#11

Guilmon1

Offline

Apr 2024

1839

Reply to Raxivace

The mod's souls are weighed down by gravity tbh.

@Raxivace I must say that without a doubt it's the best and most usable gundam quote

Mar 19, 10:21 AM

#12

complexities

serial obsessive

Offline

Jan 2012

190

Guess I'll just mark the first 3 episodes of the series as watched then. 😐

complexitiesMar 19, 10:25 AM

Forever a reader, rarely a watcher. Also listens to music.
★
⸢There are three ways to survive in a ruined world.⸥
⸢I’ve forgotten a few by now. However, one thing’s for certain.⸥
⸢And that is, the you reading these words will get to survive.⸥
⸢This story is for just that one reader.⸥

Mar 19, 10:25 AM

#13

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

If GQuuuuuuX -Beginning- was on MAL I would cry real human tears.

Mar 19, 10:32 AM

#14

deg

lagom

Offline

Jan 2009

103754

well the moderators did add this at least "A special edited version of select episodes was previewed at screenings in theaters throughout Japan on January 17, 2025. Regular broadcasting began on April 9, 2025." https://myanimelist.net/anime/60449/Kidou_Senshi_Gundam__GQuuuuuuX/moreinfo

Mar 19, 12:43 PM

#15

Raxivace

Offline

Dec 2012

Reply to Guilmon1

@Raxivace I must say that without a doubt it's the best and most usable gundam quote

@Guilmon1 Well that one is easy to fit into any situation. Hard to just accuse people of thinking the world is square or something lol.

Mar 19, 12:44 PM

#16

Guilmon1

Offline

Apr 2024

1839

Reply to Raxivace

@Guilmon1 Well that one is easy to fit into any situation. Hard to just accuse people of thinking the world is square or something lol.

@Raxivace that was certainly out of nowhere

Mar 21, 9:04 AM

#17

JarrodTTD

Offline

May 2016

I agree, the movie should have its own entry.

Mar 22, 8:18 AM

#18

Scyfher

Offline

Sep 2023

120

MaL has disliked Gundam for a while now. So it doesn't surprise me at all.

Mar 22, 10:08 AM

#19

utopia-

Offline

Sep 2024

445

Maybe because it's irrelevant

Mar 22, 10:50 AM

#20

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

Reply to utopia-

Maybe because it's irrelevant

@utopia- It's so irrelevant that it's the highest grossing anime film of the year so far.

Mar 22, 8:59 PM

#21

UptightGnome

Offline

Aug 2015

It's been confirmed that a substantial amount of content is exclusive to the film https://x.com/TORAPOI/status/1900741888204018161

There are dozens of compilation movies on MAL with less justification for a listing than this. Don't understand the nitpicking from mods

Mar 23, 12:23 AM

#22

Billy-storm

Offline

May 2021

Reply to UptightGnome

@UptightGnome woah the one year war part is only in the movie!?!?! I didn't know that. AAAAAAA I HATE THAT THEY WON'T ADD THE DAMN ENTRY

Mar 23, 12:45 AM

#23

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

Reply to Billy-storm

@UptightGnome woah the one year war part is only in the movie!?!?! I didn't know that. AAAAAAA I HATE THAT THEY WON'T ADD THE DAMN ENTRY

@Billy-storm It's in the show, but edited differently. Probably not in one chunk.

btw
https://x.com/G_GQuuuuuuX/status/1903712650707820732?t=aPyoaNmKyxZdd8g4svq2Tw&s=19

Mar 23, 3:02 AM

#24

deg

lagom

Offline

Jan 2009

103754

mal added it now here https://myanimelist.net/anime/61295/Kidou_Senshi_Gundam__GQuuuuuuX_-_Beginning

Mar 23, 3:22 AM

#25

kuribo-04

Offline

Mar 2015

YEEES
The world makes sense again.

Mar 23, 7:49 AM

#26

Billy-storm

Offline

May 2021

God finally. I still don't understand why they decided to reject it for so long, but at least we actually have it now

See All Discussions

» 1 cour or 12 episodes total deg - Mar 23	16	by Adnash »» Yesterday, 4:44 AM
» "Alternative Version" of Gundam 79? Lucifrost - Mar 23	3	by kuribo-04 »» Mar 27, 10:29 AM
» I need to watch the -Beginning- movie? seasonanimes_ - Mar 23	3	by WestOnAndrewAve »» Mar 24, 9:39 AM
» Do the WANT to kill Gundam? :/ ( 1 2 3 ) MyllerPhiem - Dec 4, 2024	145	by Nao120 »» Mar 23, 12:34 PM
» AnimeJapan Red Stage Announcements: KV, Promo reel and Ending Fortress_Maximus - Mar 23	0	by Fortress_Maximus »» Mar 23, 3:47 AM

Why'd they remove the biggest anime film of the year so far from MAL?

More topics from this board

» 1 cour or 12 episodes total

» "Alternative Version" of Gundam 79?

» I need to watch the -Beginning- movie?

» Do the WANT to kill Gundam? :/ ( 1 2 3 )

» AnimeJapan Red Stage Announcements: KV, Promo reel and Ending

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters