would you prefer if its in 3d animation aka 3dcg?

Oct 12, 9:21 PM

#2

GRG3

Offline

Aug 2022

226

i would prefer of 8bit didnt do blue lock at all. Why did Production IG pick Aoashi instead of Blue Lock😭😭

Oct 12, 9:31 PM

#3

SoulessAnime

Offline

Jan 2021

810

the manga art is slightly better than the anime's still frames and the anime has no animation so yeah I'd probably take a 3D different looking show over this, since at least it would feel unique to watch and there'd be actual movement in my moving pictures

Oct 12, 9:33 PM

#4

Oongbuh

Offline

Apr 2021

1497

If it was done well, yeah. Maybe an unrealistic expectation to imagine Orange levels, but anything nice.

Oct 12, 11:53 PM

#5

ajw215799

Offline

May 2022

207

deg said:
so ye would you prefer if blue lock anime adaptation is in 3d animation aka 3dcg since they heavily use 3d already anyway, i voted yes just to avoid too much slideshows

Hell no, the 3D CGI that gets used in anime is dog s**t, I can count on one hand the amount of times I’ve seen decent 3DCG in anime. In fact they shouldn’t use it at all

Oct 13, 12:12 AM

#6

T-A-N-V-I-R

Offline

Dec 2022

46

any kind of change is acceptable. it can't get worse from here

Oct 13, 12:25 AM

#7

EmmyMoomin

Offline

Oct 2020

580

Studio orange could do it justice in 3DCG

Oct 13, 12:28 AM

#8

deg

Offline

Jan 2009

101017

Reply to EmmyMoomin

Studio orange could do it justice in 3DCG

@EmmyMoomin even sanzigen and graphinica can do it justice with 3dcg imo

Oct 13, 2:31 AM

#9

Ripperdoc

Offline

Jan 2022

692

ajw215799 said:

deg said:
so ye would you prefer if blue lock anime adaptation is in 3d animation aka 3dcg since they heavily use 3d already anyway, i voted yes just to avoid too much slideshows

Hell no, the 3D CGI that gets used in anime is dog s**t, I can count on one hand the amount of times I’ve seen decent 3DCG in anime. In fact they shouldn’t use it at all

Can you name some?

Oct 13, 2:34 AM

#10

watsym

Offline

Mar 2023

669

If they do it like this https://myanimelist.net/anime/45649/The_First_Slam_Dunk , yes

Oct 13, 2:37 AM

#11

ajw215799

Offline

May 2022

207

Ripperdoc said:

ajw215799 said:

Hell no, the 3D CGI that gets used in anime is dog s**t, I can count on one hand the amount of times I’ve seen decent 3DCG in anime. In fact they shouldn’t use it at all

Can you name some?

Name good examples or name bad examples?

Oct 13, 4:02 AM

#12

Ripperdoc

Offline

Jan 2022

692

ajw215799 said:

Ripperdoc said:

Can you name some?

Name good examples or name bad examples?

Both, I am curious what people consider as bad and good CGI. :)

Oct 13, 4:03 AM

#13

ajw215799

Offline

May 2022

207

Ripperdoc said:

ajw215799 said:

Name good examples or name bad examples?

Both, I am curious what people consider as bad and good CGI. :)

Black Summoner as bad.
One Piece uses some good CGI.

Oct 13, 4:04 AM

#14

Ripperdoc

Offline

Jan 2022

692

ajw215799 said:

Ripperdoc said:

Both, I am curious what people consider as bad and good CGI. :)

Black Summoner as bad.
One Piece uses some good CGI.

What about Chainsawman or DS? I remember there was an uproar while they where airing.

Oct 13, 4:09 AM

#15

ajw215799

Offline

May 2022

207

Ripperdoc said:

ajw215799 said:

Black Summoner as bad.
One Piece uses some good CGI.

What about Chainsawman or DS? I remember there was an uproar while they where airing.

It’s been nearly 2 years since I last watched Chainsaw Man so I can’t comment on the quality of their CGI (as I can’t remember). I’d just prefer if they stopped doing 3D CGI in general because I’ve seen time and time again in anime where they’ve resorted to doing 3DCG for simple shots, presumably because they aren’t being given enough time (anime like Kingdom Season 1 or Atri)

Oct 13, 5:21 AM

#16

Ripperdoc

Offline

Jan 2022

692

ajw215799 said:

Ripperdoc said:

What about Chainsawman or DS? I remember there was an uproar while they where airing.

It’s been nearly 2 years since I last watched Chainsaw Man so I can’t comment on the quality of their CGI (as I can’t remember). I’d just prefer if they stopped doing 3D CGI in general because I’ve seen time and time again in anime where they’ve resorted to doing 3DCG for simple shots, presumably because they aren’t being given enough time (anime like Kingdom Season 1 or Atri)

I agree bro, I am not a fan of CGI myself. It just doesn't have the charm like in drawn pictures.

Edit: I do love CG explosions, fire and other special effects, but just not CG characters fighting.

RipperdocOct 13, 5:24 AM

Oct 13, 5:23 AM

#17

ajw215799

Offline

May 2022

207

Ripperdoc said:

ajw215799 said:

It’s been nearly 2 years since I last watched Chainsaw Man so I can’t comment on the quality of their CGI (as I can’t remember). I’d just prefer if they stopped doing 3D CGI in general because I’ve seen time and time again in anime where they’ve resorted to doing 3DCG for simple shots, presumably because they aren’t being given enough time (anime like Kingdom Season 1 or Atri)

I agree bro, I am not a fan of CGI myself. It just doesn't have the charm like in drawn pictures.

If you take for example, the newest episode of Bleach, that is the power of what hand drawn animation can do.

Oct 13, 8:02 AM

#18

utopia-

Offline

Sep 2024

254

I'd rather this not be adapted anymore, and choose some really good sports manga to adapt, and it's not with this studio, 8 bits it's horrible

Oct 13, 8:15 AM

#19

BauaMarega

Offline

Apr 2022

467

Reply to GRG3

i would prefer of 8bit didnt do blue lock at all. Why did Production IG pick Aoashi instead of Blue Lock😭😭

@GRG3 ya'll made fun of ao ashi back then in the name of blue lock and now you are begging for production ig.
KARMA

Oct 13, 11:23 AM

#20

Power_csm

Offline

Oct 2020

95

I would prefer the manga

Oct 13, 12:26 PM

#21

Futter

Offline

Dec 2020

43

GRG3 said:
i would prefer of 8bit didnt do blue lock at all. Why did Production IG pick Aoashi instead of Blue Lock😭😭

Because Aoashi is superior

» Will Sae later... Jollyne7 - Yesterday	11	by certifiedbinger »» 3 hours ago
» Manga adaptation prospects RobertBobert - Nov 23	18	by sloth848 »» 7 hours ago
Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 ) IzanaSolos - Nov 23	65	by utopica »» 10 hours ago
Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Softhenic03 - Nov 16	136	by sinaux »» Nov 23, 4:12 PM
Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Softhenic03 - Oct 12	188	by Rasco »» Nov 23, 3:39 PM

would you prefer if its in 3d animation aka 3dcg?

More topics from this board

» Will Sae later...

» Manga adaptation prospects

Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Blue Lock vs. U-20 Japan Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Preview MangaManga Store

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters