Is it possible for this to become a popular hit???

Oct 4, 3:31 AM

Online

Mar 2021

348

Mackyreels said:
I hope this became a hit for madhouse so anime studios adapt more manga like this. (its never gonna happen)

It’s kinda difficult for any other anime this szn to stand out cuz we already got so many high profile stuff like Dandadan, Bleach, Re zero, Uzumaki and Blue box taking all the hype unless any series does something very exceptional or unique I don’t think that many of them will get any attention cuz most anime fans are already preoccupied with the above mentioned shows it’s kinda sad honestly but I’ll still be watching this cuz it’s one of the very few mangas that got the osamu tezuka grand prize.

UruichiOct 5, 3:34 AM

Oct 4, 3:34 AM

#3

utopia-

Offline

Sep 2024

254

^ Exactly that, there are a lot of animes this season with hype, I think it's difficult for this to be successful

Oct 4, 11:34 AM

#4

DragyG

Offline

Dec 2018

1260

Uruichi said:

Mackyreels said:
I hope this became a hit for madhouse so anime studios adapt more manga like this. (its never gonna happen)

It’s kinda difficult for any other anime this szn to stand out cuz we already got so many high profile stuff like Dandadan, Bleach, Re zero, Uzumaki and Blue box taking all the hype unless any series does something very exceptional or something interesting I don’t think that many of them will get any attention cuz most anime fans are already preoccupied with the above mentioned shows it’s kinda sad honestly.

The only one I'm gonna watch in that list is Re:Zero but you have a point.

In most cases when an anime shines it's because there weren't that many major series in the same season.

Edit: Didn't know blue box was for ao no hako

DragyGOct 4, 11:37 AM

Oct 5, 3:35 AM

#5

Uruichi

Online

Mar 2021

348

DragyG said:

Uruichi said:

It’s kinda difficult for any other anime this szn to stand out cuz we already got so many high profile stuff like Dandadan, Bleach, Re zero, Uzumaki and Blue box taking all the hype unless any series does something very exceptional or something interesting I don’t think that many of them will get any attention cuz most anime fans are already preoccupied with the above mentioned shows it’s kinda sad honestly.

The only one I'm gonna watch in that list is Re:Zero but you have a point.

In most cases when an anime shines it's because there weren't that many major series in the same season.

Edit: Didn't know blue box was for ao no hako

You’re missing out Dandadan and Uzumaki both of them are great shows which are very unique in their own ways especially Uzumaki being the only good adaptation of Ito’s works, and Dandadan easily has the potential to contend for Aoty.

Oct 5, 4:56 AM

#6

DragyG

Offline

Dec 2018

1260

Uruichi said:

DragyG said:

The only one I'm gonna watch in that list is Re:Zero but you have a point.

In most cases when an anime shines it's because there weren't that many major series in the same season.

Edit: Didn't know blue box was for ao no hako

You’re missing out Dandadan and Uzumaki both of them are great shows which are very unique in their own ways especially Uzumaki being the only good adaptation of Ito’s works, and Dandadan easily has the potential to contend for Aoty.

Honestly I really hate horror and gloomy things so Uzumaki is definitely a no go for me

Oct 5, 4:56 AM

#7

Armandoriel

Offline

Jul 2017

346

Honestly? I doubt it, it doesn't have cute anime girls or waifu bait, nor it's quirky enough that people would spam gifs of it every week.

If the adaptation is good, it'll just be a hidden gem that will fly under the radar to most of the anime community. Sure, there would be some youtuber making a video about it and it'll gain some popularity, but it's going to be far from popular hit.

Of course I wish I'll be proven wrong and this show gets the attention it deserves.

More...

Oct 5, 4:59 AM

#8

Uruichi

Online

Mar 2021

348

DragyG said:

Uruichi said:

You’re missing out Dandadan and Uzumaki both of them are great shows which are very unique in their own ways especially Uzumaki being the only good adaptation of Ito’s works, and Dandadan easily has the potential to contend for Aoty.

Honestly I really hate horror and gloomy things so Uzumaki is definitely a no go for me

That’s fine you do you

Oct 5, 6:50 AM

#9

hazecloud

Offline

Jan 2018

33302

kinda agreed with what has been said above. if no waifu, people gonna sleep on this.

Oct 5, 6:53 AM

#10

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

159

Reply to hazecloud

kinda agreed with what has been said above. if no waifu, people gonna sleep on this.

@hazecloud we only have people getting burned at the stakes :(

Oct 5, 7:02 AM

#11

W3TFT

Offline

Apr 2020

502

Does Vinland Saga have cute waifus?

I hope in this show's potential.

ow + nw = 90-2000s

Oct 5, 1:18 PM

#12

dezhavhu

Offline

Aug 2015

181

The manga is quite popular in Japan, but it might be really hard for it to boom in the west, since this is basically a story about science. I know the story is just going to be the struggles of research instead of going into the actual technical parts of it, but I assume not a lot of anime fans would take interest in it. As an astronomy nerd myself I would love for it to get recognition but I doubt that it'll happen.

Oct 5, 1:36 PM

#13

Oongbuh

Offline

Apr 2021

1497

Doubt it. Too many popular series this season, and in general it's hard for historical anime to become really huge.

Oct 5, 1:50 PM

#14

WhiteTestament

Offline

Jan 2009

172

Already has a higher than expected score, but gaining traction and recognition while airing in a season stacked with bleach, rezero, dandadan and others will be difficult.

I can see maybe the second Cour in a less busy season be more well received.

Oct 5, 3:03 PM

#15

akarow12

Offline

Apr 2017

54

i don't think so, this manga is seinen story-based adaptation. So it's hard to follow or just boring for majority of anime fanbase.

While the Animation is better than most seinen manga adaptation, it's still nowhere popular Seinen likes Kiseijuu, AoT or Vinland Saga.

Oct 5, 3:05 PM

#16

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

159

Reply to akarow12

i don't think so, this manga is seinen story-based adaptation. So it's hard to follow or just boring for majority of anime fanbase.

While the Animation is better than most seinen manga adaptation, it's still nowhere popular Seinen likes Kiseijuu, AoT or Vinland Saga.

@akarow12 oh well lets hope for a miracle in popularity. Also Aot is a shonen, its just feels like seinen because of the themes of the story.

Oct 25, 5:17 AM

#17

Gucci100

Offline

Oct 2023

1

I hope it will be good madhouse will animated this ?

Oct 31, 3:46 PM

#18

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

159

Reply to Uruichi

DragyG said:

Uruichi said:

It’s kinda difficult for any other anime this szn to stand out cuz we already got so many high profile stuff like Dandadan, Bleach, Re zero, Uzumaki and Blue box taking all the hype unless any series does something very exceptional or something interesting I don’t think that many of them will get any attention cuz most anime fans are already preoccupied with the above mentioned shows it’s kinda sad honestly.

The only one I'm gonna watch in that list is Re:Zero but you have a point.

In most cases when an anime shines it's because there weren't that many major series in the same season.

Edit: Didn't know blue box was for ao no hako

You’re missing out Dandadan and Uzumaki both of them are great shows which are very unique in their own ways especially Uzumaki being the only good adaptation of Ito’s works, and Dandadan easily has the potential to contend for Aoty.

@Uruichi uzumaki was a disaster

Oct 31, 3:58 PM

#19

Zarutaku

Online

Sep 2016

10002

Don't think so, it doesn't have mass appeal.

No, this isn't my signature-desu.

Oct 31, 8:42 PM

#20

aurora_yuuki

Offline

Jan 2020

1866

Reply to Zarutaku

Don't think so, it doesn't have mass appeal.

@Zarutaku Gonna go down as one of them underrated gems.

“𝖨𝖿 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝖽𝗂𝖼𝗍𝖺𝖻𝗅𝖾, 𝗂𝗍 𝗐𝗈𝗎𝗅𝖽 𝖼𝖾𝖺𝗌𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖻𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁𝗈𝗎𝗍 𝖿𝗅𝖺𝗏𝗈𝗋.” – 𝖤𝗅𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝖱𝗈𝗈𝗌𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗅𝗍

Oct 31, 11:42 PM

#21

brandondb0

Offline

Mar 2022

10

Nah it doesn’t have any waifus, echi, dimwit MC, and has little action. At best it will reach popularity of Vinland Saga season 2

brandondb0Oct 31, 11:46 PM

Nov 1, 1:16 AM

#22

Uruichi

Online

Mar 2021

348

Mackyreels said:
@Uruichi uzumaki was a disaster

Yeah Ik time traveller

Nov 1, 1:19 AM

#23

OvergrownRover

Offline

Feb 2021

1487

It’s already very popular in Japan (the only place where an anime’s popularity matters)

Yesterday, 2:01 AM

#24

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

159

Reply to WhiteTestament

Already has a higher than expected score, but gaining traction and recognition while airing in a season stacked with bleach, rezero, dandadan and others will be difficult.

I can see maybe the second Cour in a less busy season be more well received.

@WhiteTestament yeah i can see orb getting more popular in 2nd cour because theres no dandadan and bleach i think.

Yesterday, 9:44 AM

#25

Kimurah

Offline

Dec 2016

1349

Reply to Mackyreels

@WhiteTestament yeah i can see orb getting more popular in 2nd cour because theres no dandadan and bleach i think.

@Mackyreels

ROFL

That's not how it works.

If a show wasn't good enough to draw in the big numbers in viewership in it's first cour, it's not going to increase the numbers on a second cour just because way better produced shows aren't running in that season. Take a look at Sengoku Youko, it had a weak start and it's numbers dwindled by the time it hit the 2nd season.

This show will have even less viewers by the time the 2nd cour hits because most of those who didn't settle for scraps and dark blotches of piss poor production would have moved on to watch something else.

» This is the Anime of the Season, everyone. Come here and watch it, if you like serious stories like Vinland Saga! MyllerPhiem - Oct 5	32	by Mackyreels »» 1 hour ago
» will Neil degrasse tyson be in it TornadoZW - Oct 5	5	by Mackyreels »» 4 hours ago
Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 8 Discussion Stark700 - Nov 16	45	by YoAraragi »» 5 hours ago
» I feel strange with this one mydaddy - Oct 26	26	by Mackyreels »» 5 hours ago
Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 9 Discussion Stark700 - Nov 23	44	by YudiYusantoS »» 9 hours ago

Is it possible for this to become a popular hit???

More topics from this board

» This is the Anime of the Season, everyone. Come here and watch it, if you like serious stories like Vinland Saga!

» will Neil degrasse tyson be in it

Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 8 Discussion

» I feel strange with this one

Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 9 Discussion

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters