| I just bought Kirby manga mania vol. 1, is it this? |
 |
| Kirby Manga Mania is apparently made by another manga-ka than this one's manga-ka, so it's not this one. The manga you're looking for seems to be this: https://myanimelist.net/manga/51917/Hoshi_no_Kirby__Dedede_de_Pupupu_na_Monogatari |
 |
| i have no clue, but this manga is obscure ash, found my volumes at a comic store rite next to my school,  |
xay_sama said: i have no clue, but this manga is obscure ash, found my volumes at a comic store rite next to my school, i wish the anime site's pfp actually looked like the manga covers, |
xay_sama said: i wish the anime site's pfp actually looked like the manga covers, MAL uses the original Japanese cover, like all of the other infos. Their roles is to stay true to the datas, it's not their fault if the English publisher changed the covers. The Manga in your picture is that one, by the way : https://myanimelist.net/manga/51917/Hoshi_no_Kirby__Dedede_de_Pupupu_na_Monogatari |
 "Genius lives only one storey above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
Alexioos95 said: xay_sama said: i wish the anime site's pfp actually looked like the manga covers, MAL uses the original Japanese cover, like all of the other infos. Their roles is to stay true to the datas, it's not their fault if the English publisher changed the covers. The Manga in your picture is that one, by the way : https://myanimelist.net/manga/51917/Hoshi_no_Kirby__Dedede_de_Pupupu_na_Monogatari after doing a little digging in the post, manga mania/ "the english version", isnt really just a language version, but a new manga altogether, AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE IMAGE  |
xay_sama said: Alexioos95 said: MAL uses the original Japanese cover, like all of the other infos. Their roles is to stay true to the datas, it's not their fault if the English publisher changed the covers. The Manga in your picture is that one, by the way : https://myanimelist.net/manga/51917/Hoshi_no_Kirby__Dedede_de_Pupupu_na_Monogatari after doing a little digging in the post, manga mania/ "the english version", isnt really just a language version, but a new manga altogether, AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE IMAGE which begs the question, why not just make a new post about it altogether instead of lumping it as just description lump for the original, since manga mania has an entirely new cover, is unique enough to not be able to compare, ( which is why your comment confused me), and im pretty sure, has a different author, and aims for an entirely different narrative, |
xay_sama said: why not just make a new post about it altogether instead of lumping it as just description lump for the original Well, it's a compilation, so if we add it to the database, the chapters will technically be in double, which is something MAL does not want. That's why compilations and re-edition of already made Mangas are not allowed, like the numerous ones of Junji Ito, or that different One-shots gets deleted when their Volume groupement is finally released. xay_sama said: and im pretty sure, has a different author, and aims for an entirely different narrative, It's the same Author, Hirozaku Hikawa. The chapters really were just taken from the Manga, they were not re-written and/or re-drawn. It's just that only some chapters were selected, with the rest not integrated in the compilation, and their orders were changed. Now, if you can get both the original Japanese edition of the Manga and the compilation, you would be able to add the potentially new chapters into the database, if there is. Edit : It seems like no one ever tried to add the compilation to the database. You can try, maybe you or a mods will be able to find more infos that will allow it into the database : https://myanimelist.net/panel.php?go=mangadb&do=add Nevermind. |
Alexioos95May 13, 12:38 AM
"Genius lives only one storey above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
xay_sama said: alright, but your last two paragraphs/semtences/points prove why it should by a new addition altogether, I edited my post very shortly after you quoted it, so i'll repost here : It seems like no one ever tried to add the compilation to the database. You can try, maybe you or a mods will be able to find more infos that will allow it into the database : https://myanimelist.net/panel.php?go=mangadb&do=add Ah, nevermind, it did got denied in early 2023, even if there is no log about it. |
"Genius lives only one storey above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |