Macross F

Following a catastrophic war against a race of giants known as the Zentradi, humanity has escaped towards the center of the galaxy aboard a fleet of colonial vessels called the Macross Frontier. As the extraterrestrial threat is left further and further behind, life on Macross Frontier proceeds as usual.

In the year 2059, a young mecha pilot trainee named Alto Saotome and his colleagues are preparing to perform an accompanying routine for the famous singer Sheryl Nome, who has come to Macross Frontier for a concert. During the performance, a biomechanical alien species known as the Vajra make a sudden appearance, breaking through the defensive perimeter surrounding the vessel and crash-landing near the concert venue, plunging the entire city into chaos. As the concertgoers evacuate, a young girl named Ranka Lee is left behind and gets targeted by the Vajra, but she is saved at the last minute by Alto. Following these events, the Strategic Military Services program notes Alto's skill in battle, resulting in his recruitment to combat the new alien threat.

[Written by MAL Rewrite]

Nome, Sheryl Main

Endou, Aya Japanese

Lee, Ranka Main

Nakajima, Megumi Japanese

Saotome, Alto Main

Nakamura, Yuuichi Japanese

Klang, Klan Supporting

Toyoguchi, Megumi Japanese

Sterne, Brera Supporting

Hoshi, Souichirou Japanese

Blanc, Mikhail Supporting

Kamiya, Hiroshi Japanese

Lee, Ozma Supporting

Konishi, Katsuyuki Japanese

O'Connor, Grace Supporting

Inoue, Kikuko Japanese

Nome, Mao Supporting

Wilder, Jeffrey Supporting

Ookawa, Tooru Japanese

Maruyama, Hiroo Producer

Kasai, Tsutomu Producer

Morotomi, Hirofumi Producer

Matsui, Chinatsu Assistant Producer

Reviews

Sep 10, 2008

KaminaKai

Recommended

*A Stunning Revival of a 25 Years Old Series.*

"Simple, easy to comprehend plot. Skillfully developed love triangle. Masterpiece level animation and music."

To those who are new to the Macross franchise, you can find some info on it here. Now first to clarify a thing for those who are confused with the "Macross Frontier Deculture Edition". The difference is simply that the Deculture Edition is the "pilot episode" of the TV series. Another way of putting it is an OVA version of episode 1 of the TV series which was aired ~3 months later.

Taking place 47 years (story-wise) after the original series, Super Dimension Fortress Macross. ... We are now in the year 2059 AD. The Space War with the Zentradi was long since over and the new migration fleet, Macross Frontier, is now under attack by a new alien race. The story revolves around a love triangle and how the three cope with each other while dealing with the threats from the aliens.

The battle animations are absolutely STUNNING. Fluid CG battle animations to very detailed character outlook are very much the highly for the show. One can even tell that the background for most scenery were well thought out and well designed. Oh, and very consistent quality of animation.

"1st Anime Album in 11 Years to Rank in Japan's Top 3"

"Two Macross Frontier Singles in Japan's Weekly Top 10"

"All four of the Macross Frontier singles that have been released have debuted at #5 or higher."

How does that sound for starter? The Macross series were largely famous for its music as they all played an integral part in every single Macross title. However, one can say Macross Frontier have taken the anime song industry to a whole new golden era! Both the singer and seiyu responsible for singing the second OP won awards for their fabulous works.

A lot of characters developments happened in the latter half of the series making it a bit boring to watching in the beginning (as far as characters are concerned). However this is balanced by Sheryl Nome's character development which was extremely well done especially toward to the end of the series.We also be Alto and Ranka mature over time (albeit very late in the series).

The series as a whole was very well made with amazing sound effects and graphic. The love triangle between the 3 protagonists was interesting to watch as well. It was painful to see the show end, but at least it was announced that a movie is underway.


*Update on February 10, 2009*
If you liked Macross Frontier, you may be happy to know that it was voted by anime fans a week ago as THE anime of 2008. In addtion, May'n (Sheryl's singing VA) also got voted as one of the top anime singer.

Reviewer’s Rating: 9

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by KaminaKai (62)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Oct 30, 2012

Starisu

Mixed Feelings

--- Warning: Contains spoilers ---

Most series can be summed up in a few words, and regardless of their implications, some descriptions may throw you for a loop. When you hear the words triangles, music, missiles, more music and even more missiles, what is it that you think of? Most well-versed anime viewers should be thinking of the Macross franchise, as this can effectively sum up a great portion of what it's all about, ranging from the original series to the latest installment entitled Frontier.

Macross Frontier happens to be a fairly ordinary anime that in its simplicity, loses direction as it progresses, only to attempt ... to get back on track after wasting lots of time. When you break it down, at least half of the episodes are fillers, and a majority of the rest are short arcs that don't really connect and flow together to form a solid plot like any good series would. Since this is not an episodic series, this format begins to hurt itself in the long run, as only little bits of crucial information about the grand scheme of things are revealed throughout the series. This makes the progression of the main plot very slow and unnecessarily dragged out. It's not until the final third of the series that it decides to focus on what can be considered the main plot. Up until this point, the plot was nothing more than a simple "Defend the human race from unknown aliens", which is already weak in and of itself as it's really just a poor excuse for some mecha action, but it decided to take a sharp 180 and go down the oh so wonderful conspiracy route.

With this development that couldn't help but be expected many episodes prior, everything starts to become a giant mess. This was hinted to a few times throughout the beginning of the series, usually only for a very short time period in select episodes displaying things like undercover discussions or trades, so it's not like it came on unforeseen by the audience. If anything, it happened far too late, as the motives behind Grace and Leon who were originally working together are hardly delved into, and they simply play the bad-guy role because the series needed a better antagonist than random aliens. Both individuals having very grandiose goals of wanting to rule the universe, you can't help but wonder how they actually planned on executing this in the first place. It is only explained after Grace O'Connor, the great evil mastermind behind everything, had her plans proceed to completion without any hitch at all. Now, having full control over the Vajra, it's pretty safe to say she holds much more power than anyone else currently, yet, of course, is defeated by the power of... music (Catchy j-pop music at that). A lot of build up was wasted in favor of going this predictable route, and it is basically the equivalent of beating the bad guy through the power of friendship. At the very least, they tried to give some basis for this being possible with information from earlier episodes explaining the power of music within the Macross universe.

Seeing as this all happened in the span of a few episodes, it's safe to say that pacing became a huge issue, and solidified the fact that most of the other episodes were nothing more than "filler" and short arcs. They could have used this time to begin to develop the plot, but that wasn't the case. They may as well have cut out these episodes in favor of getting straight to the point, rather than extending the series unnecessarily. With the remaining episodes not being devoted to plot advancement, some character development should be expected in them, however, it's nowhere near as much as there should have been for how much time was devoted to this aspect. A majority of the remaining episodes used most of their time focused on the love triangle between the three main characters, but the events and developments that took place were usually undermined due to the indecisive and undeveloped protagonist of the series, Alto Saotome. He is also better known by some of the characters as Princess Alto, and for good reason.

And while it may not all necessarily be because of him, he is directly involved in many of the simple plot conveniences used to keep the love triangle from moving forward. Whether it be going out to fight against the Vajra during a crucial time when he was supposed to be with Ranka, or Ranka seeing him with Sheryl and then wallowing in her own sadness about it afterwards. However, with Alto being the resident princess of the series, it's not a far stretch to say he certainly can act like one at times. Ranging from his daddy issues leading to him running away from home to become a pilot, or how he likes to ignore any real problems that he faces, there's almost nothing about him that doesn't scream "Princess". He even has gorgeous flowing locks of hair to accentuate this. In fact, I have no doubt that some would start to question his manhood, as he practically ignores any advances from both Sheryl and Ranka, which goes back to him being largely at fault for the triangle never progressing. Any time it seems like he's made up his mind about who he wants to be with, the next episode has some bad news for you, as he basically does the equivalent of saying "Just kidding!", and begins to show what can be considered interest in the opposite girl. As for the whole "Princess" nickname and his daddy issues, they are touched on briefly, but it comes off as nothing more than the writers quickly throwing together some semblance of a back story so that they could pass him off as more than your average self-insert main character.

Having Alto bounce back and forth between who it seemed he was interested in clearly shows which characters are supposed to be the selling point of the series, and of course, I can only be talking about Ranka and Sheryl. Long winded fan boy name calling and debates aside for now, they both have their ups and downs as characters.

Ranka, who is easily the character who receives the most focus in the series, happens to be the one who receives the least development for all the time she spent on screen (Go figure). She manages to slowly get over her timid nature when it comes to singing, but only because of the encouragement Alto gives her throughout the series. Although this was good however, even with her having the most interaction with other characters and general screen time, she never developed a reason for singing past doing it for Alto's affection. Due to the fact that the time spent on her was poorly utilized, her development was hindered in the long run. This is made especially apparent when you see that a few of the side characters have more motivation for their actions than she does. For the sheer amount of focus the series gave her character, seeing them do nothing with it past the first few episodes was disappointing to say the least.

Sheryl, on the other hand, plays a much more interesting role in the series. Many pass her off as "Bitchy", "Overly arrogant" and many other demeaning terms from the moment she appears on screen, but she manages to easily become the best character in the cast. With her status established right from the beginning, it's not unfitting for her to act much like she runs the place. Providing a stark contrast from Ranka, Sheryl is confident and domineering to an extent, yet still caring of others, shown by her attitude towards Ranka and Alto. She eventually softens up a bit, mostly due to her feelings for Alto since he doesn't worship her like everyone else in the colonies. The struggle she goes through while falling from the top as Ranka took over is far more believable than anything Ranka or Alto went through. Having to cope with her fall from stardom, as well as her impending death due to a disease, she accepts these facts and still tries to move forward, doing the only thing she can do: sing. This made her far more endearing to the audience by the end of the series, as this shows her confidence wasn't simply based on her status as the Galactic Fairy, but her strength of will that was built up through living her old lifestyle of complete poverty. While she did remain mostly static, what she went through didn't feel contrived, much like the case was with Ranka.

But of course, like many other series, one of the biggest problems Macross Frontier presents is the ending. Again, I find myself questioning Alto's sexuality, as the ending provides zero closure for what is considered the main focus of the series: the love triangle between the three main characters. This is Macross, the plot is only there to help move the romance forward, and that's one thing Frontier severely failed at. Not only was Alto himself preventing it from taking a big step forward with his indecisiveness and constant character changes, the sheer amount of conveniences that kept the character's relationships from developing sure didn't help either. Like I mentioned, the filler episodes would mostly focus on the love triangle, but focusing on it is not the same as actually having it progress. Regardless of how much it actually progressed by the end, a conclusion is needed, and that's something the series never provided. While it was very heavily suggested that Sheryl "won" before the finale, the final moments of the series throw the entirety of the few episodes Alto was together with Sheryl right out the window, and has Ranka enter the competition once more.

As we all know, Alto has a major fascination for the sky, more so than for the two girls who fawned over him for the entire series. So what does he do? He doesn't clearly choose either girl, but instead chooses the mother fucking sky. Whether it was intentionally done this way so that the Sheryl and Ranka factions wouldn't destroy the world due to a simultaneous outburst of angry fan boys crying over the fact that their waifu "lost", or because they wanted to leave it up for interpretation, it doesn't change the fact that giving no closure severely impacts the series in a bad way. And when one of the main selling points of the Macross franchise is left untouched, it leaves nothing more than disappointment in the eyes of fans and newcomers alike. While making no decision on which girl the main character wants to be with may be a common occurrence in most harem series, it should not be the case when there is only a love triangle at hand. When ample time is given to devote to two characters and their interactions with the main character, going down this route is nothing more than a bad decision as it should be nearly impossible to get fans to feel satisfied with this kind of ending. It was a shame to see them use this kind of cheap exit strategy after putting forth the effort to develop the relationships in the series.

After all of this, there's nothing left but disappointment in the series. There may have been good j-pop, great action scenes, as well as throwbacks to previous entries in the franchise ranging from songs, to name drops and simple phrases, but that only adds to the enjoyment factor. And as most intelligent people will know, even that isn't enough to save a series which continually makes mistakes along the way. At the end of the day, Macross Frontier had a lot of potential, but unfortunately it was ruined by Alto who could not manage to keep the series flying smoothly.

Reviewer’s Rating: 5

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Starisu (3)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Sep 10, 2013

rm2kmidi

Not Recommended

Having just finished the Macross Frontier, I have to say that this one falls way short of its predecessors. Hiroyuki Yoshino (who is also responsible for the abominations that are Code Gaess and Guilty Crown) seems to think that throwing together everything from his previous shows and whatever’s popular in other successful shows will make a great show. As one blogger rightly commented, “It’s not the number of ingredients that make a delicious dish”.

Now before I get into the meat of what didn’t work here; I want to give credit where credit is due. The music by Yoko Kanno, as always, was top notch. Although ... the pop music was a bit Engrishy, that’s common to all J-Pop and they can’t really be faulted there. I loved the overall designs of Macross Frontier with its whole San Francisco vibe. The fleet shot was also interesting as it made it look like a group of turtles or insects as well as giving the impression of the large-scale of these ships. I enjoyed all the concert scenes and thought the use of holography in some of Sheryl’s early concerts was pretty inventive and shows a progression in technology from the Sharon Apple concerts in Macross Plus. But despite this base design, the series went horribly askew when Yoshino took the reins of series composition.

Characters

The characters, although well-designed, were poorly developed. I couldn’t consider any of these characters endearing or lovable, and in a year’s time I will have probably forgotten all about them. They were shallow puppets that were used as tools to achieve the creator’s ends, without ever taking on a life of their own. While Ozama and Catherine’s relationship seems realistic and mature, but the vast majority of relationships were the typical high school romance crap. But they go above-and-beyond the call of duty here; not only are these relationships implausible, but they come out of nowhere and are resolved so poorly.

The cast, though well-designed, has obvious analogs in Super Dimension Fortress Macross or later incarnations in the series. The Captain resembles Global. You have the standard chatty girls on the bridge. The enemy, like Gepellnich (in Macross 7) is shrouded in mystery and you don’t get a good look at his/her face 'til the final few episodes. Ranka’s aesthetic is largely influenced by the design for Mao Nome from Macross Zero. Ozama Lee’s role takes on a lot of characteristics of Roy Focker from SDF Macross and Catherine Glass is a clone of Lt. Hayasse.

Finally, the villains are utterly worthless. Their plans are at times transparently obvious and at other times so vague that you could never be expected to understand what they’re talking about. The Vajira themselves, unlike the Zentradi or the Protodevilins of the previous series, are not sentient and react like worker bees to some queen. Even though these hive-mind creatures don’t really think for themselves (except for the pet), they seem to react to Ranka’s songs. Sounds stupid huh? Well, their explanation is equally stupid. I wont spoil it.

Plot

The plot was scattered and lazy. Political intrigue was full of plot holes and unrealistic to both the way other Macross ships are governed and the way governments function in reality (though this seems to be a consistent problem with Hiroyuki Yoshino). As stated before, they went out of their way to have lots of screen-time with villains saying a lot while remaining so vague that you could never decipher what they were saying.

In every previous incarnation, Macross ships have had a civilian leader (a mayor or president) and a military leader. In Frontier, part of the military is contracted out to SMS, some sort of private security firm; there doesn’t seem to be any reason for this arrangement. Most of the series only shows SMS getting involved in the conflicts, but toward the end, they start showing another full-sized military force operating out of the Frontier. Yoshino, having no political savvy whatsoever, portrays the President having absolute authority over the military; this goes against all precedent and seems to undermine the notion of separation of power clearly portrayed in Macross 7 and in the original SDF Macross. Though one might mistake the Captain of SMS as the equivalent of Max Genius, he is clearly not a military captain and in fact no one seems to fit this role. The military leaders outside SMS are a bunch of sniveling sycophants who do nothing but react to what’s going on outside the ship (almost as if Yoshino was trying to tell the audience how to react).

The foreshadowing flashbacks were poorly used and basically showed the same things over and over, trying to make the same obvious point. These flashbacks continue throughout through the end of the series, even though the message is already clear by Episode 10. The ending was particularly incoherent, and it really answered none of the questions. Relationships are abruptly resolved, if resolved at all, many other threads were just left dangling.

Conclusions

All in all, the plot was a sloppy mess. It wasn’t fun to watch and wasn’t engaging either emotionally or intellectually. There was never really a moment where I didn’t know where this was heading – no surprises. I don’t feel that this series did anything to expand the Macross universe or the underlying mysteries of the franchise; and despite lots of cameos we really learn nothing of the fate of characters from previous series (with a couple exceptions).

The worst part though, is while letting this man work on Macross series was possibly a good financial decision, it has ruined what was otherwise an original and authentic saga. Yoshino didn’t seem to care about what came before, except that there was material there to exploit. He merely saw fans of the franchise as potential viewers, then he roped in pop music fans, mecha fans, high school anime fans, and a dozen other tropes in order to maximize his viewership. The man has no integrity as an artist and no respect for a classic property that’s been going since 1982. It had been ten years since Macross 7, so I hope in 2017 (or hopefully sooner) when they get around to making another series, that the original creators don’t let this jackass anywhere near it.

Reviewer’s Rating: 2

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by rm2kmidi (1)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

5+ OPs/5+ EDs Anime

by ScarletCelestial

46 Entries · 3 Restacks

Best openings (according to AniDB)

by eblf2013

50 Entries · 5 Restacks

Mecha Anime That Aren't Gundam

by FanofAction

43 Entries · 8 Restacks

Q3 2022 Anime & Manga Licenses [Update 9/9]

In this thread, you'll find a comprehensive list of anime and manga licensed in the second quarter (Jul-Sep) of 2022. Summer 2022 anime which were licensed befo...read more

Jul 2, 2022 1:13 PM by Snow | Discuss (17 comments)

'Macross F' Gets New Short Anime Film

The Air Macross F Live 2021 livestream program announced on Saturday that the Macross F anime series will receive a new short anime film in 2021. Titled Gekijouban ...read more

Feb 6, 2021 9:57 PM by DatRandomDude | Discuss (13 comments)

	Poll: Macross Frontier Episode 25 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) kurotsuki - Sep 25, 2008	266 replies	by lkevsan »» Aug 15, 8:13 AM
	Poll: Macross F Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Westlo - Apr 24, 2008	61 replies	by ManuelFragment »» May 6, 9:30 PM
	Poll: Macross F Episode 17 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Westlo - Aug 1, 2008	60 replies	by Dzentelmen2 »» Oct 12, 2023 7:22 AM
	Poll: Macross F Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 ) darkside099 - Jul 4, 2008	72 replies	by removed-user »» Mar 27, 2023 6:08 AM
	Poll: Macross Frontier Episode 23 Discussion ( 1 2 ) angel999 - Sep 11, 2008	98 replies	by catfay »» Feb 21, 2023 3:22 PM

Ten of the Sexiest Asian Cosplayers Ever

Do you like cosplay? Do you like sexy asian cosplayers? Then come on in friend, because a glorious bonanza of images awaits you featuring fan favorites from Macross F, Re:Zero, One Piece, Pokemon and many more.

by AlanV

184,063 views

CollectionHotCosplay

Top 19 Tsundere Characters in Anime: What is a Tsundere?

Your harem or reverse harem anime isn't worth the time of day if it doesn't have a tsundere in it. But what is a tsundere, where did the term originate, and why are they everywhere? Read on to find out!

by 5camp

1,506,561 views

CollectionAnime TermsAnime ArchetypesCharacter AnalysisCute GirlsCute GuysMoe