Back to xxdeathx's Profile xxdeathx's Profile

Art: 8/10
I loved the fights, which were animated in great detail, and the 20th century Britain setting, which influences the school area and character designs. Charlotte is probably one of the better designs, especially her clothing (that hat) and personality. Now if only she was voiced by Rie Kugimiya.

Story: 4/10
The problem is that this anime had too much stuff and can't cover it all in 12 episodes.

The plot is fragmented and inconclusive at best. There was supposed to be an overarching plot about a competition among 100 people whose last one standing (remind anyone of Sekirei?) would be rewarded greatly. Instead the Evening ... Party isn't even a main plot point as it soon gets ignored in favor of a storytelling style like Strike the Blood's—short arcs, a few episodes long, about separate mini-villains. Slight spoilers: the ending isn't much of an ending.

Character: 6/10
Yaya was really cute, probably the most jealous character I've ever seen. Her attachment to Raishin is legendary. Charlotte's also pretty good and her interactions with Raishin are amusing.

However, similar problem with story was that the anime failed to thoroughly explore character backgrounds. Aside from Yaya, Charlotte, Henri, and Frey, none of the other characters get enough attention. There are also a few flashbacks of Raishin's tragic past when his entire family was murdered, and he supposedly came to this school to take revenge. Maybe defeating Magnus is a long term goal that won't happen for a while, but you'd figure that the people around Magnus would be more alarmed that this guy committed mass murder rather than idly chatting with him (the female sensei) or using him as a bodyguard (the headmaster). Aside from Raishin, it'd help to know more about what Shouko has to do with him, who Magnus is, and why they interact the way they do. The members of the harem—well Charlotte and Henri got a lot of focus in the last arc, although their past is still a little muddy. Frey and Loki could use more development too. The worst offenders are the two other dolls that go with Shouko. I don't even remember their names because they only showed up a bit in one episode, yet they feature heavily in the ending theme animation with Yaya as the spinning dolls. I was led to believe that they were important characters but it seems they don't have much to do with the central story after all.

Enjoyment: 9/10
Dialogue and jokes are great. Loki's "I am a humble and tolerant man..." speech gets me every time. Yaya is always there to spice things up. Everyone misunderstanding Raishin, Yaya, and each other and abusing Raishin for being a pervert got a little repetitive after the 50th time but harem protagonists always get shit from everyone. The fights were pretty badass but having Raishin/Yaya get beaten up before someone else saves them or they figure out how to beat their opponent is kind of repetitive and predictable. The automata system in the anime is interesting, but I feel the fights and anime overall would more enjoyable if the audience understood its mechanics better.

Sound: 10/10
As far as music goes, the opening theme was good and ending theme is #1 catchiest of the season. I think the original version is the best though, maybe I got used to it from playing it on Osu all the time, but it feels weird when a different voice begins singing it.

Voice acting was excellent too, especially Yaya's. Same voice actress as Himeji in Baka and Test.

Overall: 8/10
As a harem series, Unbreakable Machine-Doll excels in character interactions and designs. I really like the feel of its unique setting in 20th century Britain when most other animes are in modern-day Japan. Action scenes are also great, but the mechanics aren't explained well, nor are the characters' backgrounds. Plot is often nonexistent, which is quite a shame, given the setting's potential. Still, it was a fun series to watch and Yaya deserves a second season.

SAO Extra Edition is mostly a recap of the important events in the original anime series told by Kirito and the main female characters (Asuna, Sugu, Silica, Lizbeth) while they're at the pool. Pool? Well, just the female characters. Too bad Kirito is stuck telling his flashbacks to an investigator somewhere else. At least the viewers get to enjoy the girls in swimsuits as they teach Sugu how to swim and talk about their own memories of meeting Kirito inside SAO.

Story: 7/10
A large part of this special is just flashbacks told from the characters' point of view. As far as the story goes, Kirito ... is persuaded to relieve the events of SAO for investigative purposes, while the girls get to frolic around in the pool and also reminisce about how they first met Kirito. The last half hour or so is original content; everybody goes into ALO to do an underwater quest. It's nothing special, no death trap, but still enjoyable for any fan of this series.

Art: 8/10
This anime series has always had excellent art quality and beautiful background scenery inside the game. A lot of it is recycled from the flashbacks but in the quest we get to see a whole new underwater world too. And of course, as the pool/beach episode, there is no shortage of the female characters in swimming attire. It's all pretty cute.

Sound: 9/10
The soundtrack from the original series makes an impressive reappearance in Extra Edition, starting with Crossing Field as the opening theme. The other opening and ending themes for both arcs are inserted during the most important flashbacks, which was done very effectively to highlight them. There are also new songs (insert and ending) which are pretty good.

Character: 9/10
Honestly, I feel that most SAO fans are just pleased to see their favorite characters back in action, be it having fun at the pool, going on the quest, or playfully chatting with each other. Since the recaps are told by each character, we get to hear the character commentary as well as dialogue between characters in the present. Silica & Lizbeth teasing Asuna about Kirito, everyone being jealous of Sugu's chest, Silica worrying about her own, etc. This kind of episode won't have much character development except the typical romance and pool cliches. Except Klein: I didn't know he was such a doomed womanizer.

Enjoyment: 9/10
I really enjoyed this type of episode. As I said before, we get to see all the characters again, in a relaxed atmosphere free of all the pressure and drama so rampant in the 25 episode series. This allows us to see them in a different light as they do everything for fun instead of to survive. It's a welcome relief episode with a lot more comedy. Now, people typically dislike recaps because they may be redundant, but fortunately these flashbacks were mostly action/turning point scenes. It would not hurt to watch them (and then hear the characters' witty comments).

Overall: 9/10
An excellent recap/pool/fun special episode with a way different mood from the other 25 episodes. Nobody's in trouble and the world doesn't need saving, so everyone can sit back and enjoy themselves after their grueling adventure earlier. And then get ready for the next season of Sword Art Online!