- Last OnlineJul 26, 2008 8:30 AM
- JoinedJul 21, 2008
No friend yet.
RSS Feeds
|
Jul 26, 2008
I’m reading one story of this mangaka at a time, spreading the pleasure: even if I don’t fall totally in love with all her stories, I do enjoy them. The style is …I don’t know… bold? Rich? Not subtle at all? :) if not always flawless or very precise. And I do like looking at her characters :)
Rikara was a bit too trashy for me but was interesting to read anyway (see summary above).
Rougoku ni Saku Hana, story 2, was about a judge and a prisoner, and I liked it. There was one panel that struck me as awfully hot, and it wasn’t
...
even about sex.
#3, Lingering Attachment (Miren) was way too melodramatic for me.
#4, Semi-double Bed de Kimi to is set in modern Japan. Two guys from school football team move into the same one-room apartment after graduating, which means courting disaster. Love vs everyday life epic battle begins. Lovely and amusing.
#5, Tag Out! is about a boy who plays baseball and accidentally breaks his principal’s window and their school main sponsor’s glasses with the same ball. He enters the sponsor’s company to work as a cleaner/servant to repay for glasses. Love and schmex ensue.
2 out of 5 get a star from me.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
Ch. 1-2. This is a fairy tale, nice, as for me. Awfully romantic. I was very sad for the beast when he understood what heartache meant and offered Haukua his fur. IMO if the story were twice longer and some more space were devoted to character and plot development, it would make a good story. As it is now, it’s just enjoyable. The extra is funny: tail used as a belt, Youko grabbing food, aww.
Ch. 3. A slave merchant steals a beautiful boy to sell him to a public house. Little did he know that the boy wouldn’t mind at all. Or that he would.
...
Grammar could be better.
Ch. 4. A doctor’s apprentice Suiki finds a wounded samurai in the forest and takes him to his home to treat. The samurai is really bad-tempered and the boy has bad history with samurai. Romantic and lovely, and very tame.
Ch. 5. Is a story of an artist and a beautiful boy he saves who later comes to serve as his model. Only he doesn’t want to draw him. Pleasant to look at and lovely.
On the whole, quite readable and enjoyable.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
It’s a bit too comical and dramatic for me, but lovely and pleasant to look at too. The detective is what makes this manga, IMO, with his special ability (you’ll learn how he got it in ch. 5) and incapacitating phobias. He’s awfully cute: eyes that have corners down and skinny hands, like a small yuppy dog :) I was wondering why people kept calling him old man when he’s freaking younger than me, like, a mere boy! Then in the extra, the mangaka said she’d drawn him as 38. Well, ok, not an old man still but less outrageous :) Anyway, the story was
...
interesting to follow and pleasant to look at. What else to wish?
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
Stories #2, 4 (prequel) and the bonus (#5) are historical, with spies and sword fights. And also curling toes and beautifully tattooed arms. There’s some limb loss and gore in the prequel. And nice role reversal in the bonus story.
#1 and its tiny bonus (#7) are a classic NB’s story: an older, insecure uke (much older, even) and a young seme. This time a predator falls in love with his prey.
#3 and #6: is about a middle-aged man and a young boy he helps at a construction work site. It’s lovely.
Pleasant reading on the whole. I liked the Lost in the Darkness Before Dawn storyline
...
(2, 4, 5) best. I really liked how fighting scenes were drawn. Well, and I always like how Naono Bohra draws sex.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
Awww. The story itself is nothing special: a first childhood love that bears fruit when the characters are adult. Big guy crying is cute. I really like this mangaka’s recurring plot of somebody returning to their childhood’s love, their neighbour. It’s a tad naive but nice and sweet. Nicely drawn, too.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
The story and drawing are really lovely, hot in places. Not very sophisticated, on any of the levels, but pleasant and exactly like what I wanted
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jul 26, 2008
This is my favourite manga of all (well, so far). I love it to bits and pieces.
You've probably read manga where the drawing technique was better, more elaborate, unique in the end. You've possibly read manga with a much more solid, tight storyline. I find though that it doesn't really matter. A story doesn't have to be perfect to be utterly enticing. And Pet Shop of Horrors (further PSOH) is. So. Freaking. Charming.
Or maybe you are like I was: rather spooked with or uninterested in manga-style drawing (which, as it turns out at a closer look, isn't one style at all). I think PSOH can
...
be a good place to start getting acquainted with manga. Because it's eclectic and has elements that may appeal to different kinds of readers: horror/supernatural, mystery, crime/action, humour, morality tale, and then there are animals and very attractive main characters.
I began with the PSOH anime (available on YouTube). It consists of only four episodes (Daughter (from Vol 1.3, rabbit), Delicious (Vol 2.3(7), Mermaid), Despair (Vol 1.2, Medusa), and Dual (Vol 5.1, Kiri). People say that Count D's voice in Japanese is better but I really liked his English voice (I watched the English version).
I admit that by the end of episode one I was thoroughly creeped out. It still stands out in my mind as one of the creepiest episodes in the series, but to see it first, without any idea what I was getting into? Was a shock. But I was intrigued too: how come that animals are also people? I mean, how? And what's this Count D's agenda? He didn't seem evil, but the consequences of his business transaction were quite horrible. So I watched on. And by the end of episode four was absolutely, madly in love with him. So of course I rushed to find the manga. It's not difficult to find; I think it might be sold where you live, and if not and if Amazon isn't an option for you, it can be found on the net almost in any big place that trades manga.
There are ten volumes of the original PSOH manga, and three more of Shin Pet Shop of Horrors, the sequel (only two are scanlated so far) that features different main characters. The premise is as follows. In LA Chinatown, there's a Pet Shop. Quoting from the book: "Its proprietor, an enigmatic figure known only as Count D, beckons through his doors the injured and the scarred, introducing them to creatures friendly and bizarre. [...] Detective Leon Orcot [..] has traced a series of seemingly unrelated crimes to Count D and his Pet Shop of Horrors. A steadfast sceptic, Leon dismisses as trickery the inexplicable events he witnesses."
It begins as spooky; the morals are a bit annoying and repetitive, and detective Leon Orcot seems to be little more than a hot-tempered dunderhead. But it's still intriguing. So you read on. And it becomes less creepy, or at least much more varied. The dunderhead turns out to be not that bad. You begin to see the logic (or a logic) of Count D's actions. Then, gradually, the big story becomes a focus rather than those short ones of which it consists. Leon and Count D develop a sort of friendship that is actually 3/5 flirting and 2/5 shouting at each other. Enter Chris, a six-year-old third main character. You learn more and more about Leon, his past, and his life; in the end you learn a lot about Count D too (in Vol 10 in particular). You learn to treasure the drawing: D's expressions, comic relief scenes, outfits, animals. So when it ends, you turn to fanfiction as the only painkiller available -- 'cos it ended, and the very fact is devastating.
On the way it so happens that the two main characters and antagonists have a real potential. It's easy to develop a crush on Count D. He's enigmatic, mysterious, aloof, and the further the more appealing. But whom I really love is Leon. He's an ordinary guy to umpteenth degree, but he's so good it's impossible not to fall for him. Leon hides strength of character and integrity under his rude and messy outlook. He's like Harry: often clueless but true and good. By the end of the first series, my heart was so totally his that I couldn't completely get into Shin Pet Shop. You'll see why when you get there. Chris is plain wonderful. And animals? Awesome. T-chan in particular, but you won't meet him until the middle of the series. So, love it is :)
I want to say thank you again to iibnf for the anime and to RexLuscus whose enthusiasm made me try it and who's been a wonderful guide.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|