Back to nalist's Profile nalist's Profile

Apr 8, 2025
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (11/? chp)
This ln is straight up feels like wn without any editing. It has its moments, but most of the time you are reading filler content without any relation to the plot. There is no structure to the story, there is no subtext or anything really - just a power fantasy with a good premise. The longer the story goes on, the more obvious it becomes that the author is simply operating on generic tropes and canned reactions from popular media.

Main thing here is MC tries to build relationships with a dragon girl, and when he does not do that - it feels like a filler. ...
Mar 31, 2025
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (23/? chp)
Dude going around while doing quests, saving people, killing bandits, selling modern knowledge on how to harden steel or make coking coal, while being a college student gamer. Moral problems with killing people? Nope. Problems with selling his convenient modern knowledge? Bah! Of course not. Pretty boring generic power fantasy.

This guy becomes a millionaire few days in (but he is not shown to use money on anything, beside his initial gear), and he is still doing his adventuring stuff for some reason. No politics, no drama, no romance, no actually life-threatening situations, no conflicts bigger than a few chapters, extremely rare fanservice. BORING.

Only thing ...
Mar 31, 2025
Preliminary (19/36 chp)
It is amazing how someone paid money to make this manga. First two volumes are kinda okay, sure, but then you start to understand that first questions - why this elf chick gave him this coin? What is her motivation? - will not get an answer in any interesting way.

Author give you a hope that he is writing a story about grooming a husband from an early age. Girl have money and power, she picks up a guy from slums and become his ray of hope. And then nothing. Old boring dungeon sword battles all the way, without anything interesting (AND without elf chick, or ...
Mar 27, 2025
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (31/? chp)
Story is okay until they start talking war. It is obvious that this all war thing was afterthought for the maincraft-isekai-being-a-slave-to-elf story from first few volumes. While this "war" is going, whole slave thing goes out of the window and we have standard OP MC with a harem (growing by the day) with little flavor from minecraft.

Here we have a passive hero, absence of mc action, lengthy building sequences. At least nudes are good and there is a few pages with sex. Kinda. Some good angles from time to time on body parts that matter. This all combined is barely entertaining and it will force ...
Mar 17, 2025
Mixed Feelings
This thing is just not aimed at the male audience. Although the MC (strong loli["but she is actually 300 years old"] wamen) is somewhat relatable and "stable", most of the other characters are just plain crazy. One minute you have someone as your sworn ally, the next they are willing to spill your guts on the floor and sell your mother into slavery, and vice versa. Crazy. There is little to no build-up to this, otherwise it would be a great story.

The beginning is decent, but after about 6 episodes things start to speed up. Court politics take the center stage, and unfortunately they ...
Mar 13, 2025
Preliminary (25/? chp)
Uninspired LN adaptation into manga. Generic isekai premise, poor intro, very artificial game world (which you can see bend to the will of author at the moments notice, without any regards to consistency), generic MC (whole thing about girl reincarnation is just about masturbation, and somehow it was made as boring as possibly feasible), generic story which deteriorates into a generic food porn. Lots of useless info dumps. Very basic fanservice. Combat is no better too (throwing knifes with magic, what a novel idea(lol)).

This story is just too mediocre. There is nothing that stands out, just an uninspired take at isekai, following all generic ...
Nov 24, 2024
Preliminary (3/? chp)
The basis of the story is that MC's stepfather/guardian deletes his pay-to-win trash mmorpg game account and (almost) all save data is lost, and then he is reincarnated in that same game.

Premise of inability to restore data from backup is rather extreme and calls for extreme justification, which was not given here, so if you apply common sense to the story, it falls apart (business without backups? lol). If you ever played at least a few mmo games, you should know that actually deleting account is not a trivial thing.

Most of the story revolves around MC getting back at his stepfather and finding/saving his sister. ...
Nov 24, 2024
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (11/? chp)
Just ugh. The first few volumes are pretty good (those that were adapted into the first season). After dealing with the first Demon Lord, the dude travels around without any particular direction and just does stuff. Defeat of the second one is the next thing that was decently written. The last interesting volume is about the Demon Overlord, but to get there you have to read quite a few volumes about nothing.

There is one good thing about the story - it has some nice suggestive content, from boob fondling to some decent indecency. Unfortunately, it does not happen often enough to justify reading boring volumes ...
Oct 22, 2024
Preliminary (1/? chp)
Mary Sue (Marty Stu?) Isekai. It feels like it is either a low effort translation or poor writing skills on the part of the author, or both. After trying to read this boring, uninspired cookie-cutter isekai at least five times, I am sure it is a case of both. I made it to the third of the first volume.

Nothing bad happens to MC, MC always solves problems immediately, he is capable of everything, he is always right and if not, he seems to be able to bullshit his way out out of everything. Every paragraph and every "part"(chapter) feels like an introduction to the story, ...
Oct 13, 2024
Preliminary (1/? chp)
Story about reincarnation in the same world. MC has not lived that many years, but still portrayed as quite knowledgeable and experienced person. Story is okay - court intrigues with a mix of magic and swords. Action is mostly packed into the final boss chapters. Overall it is written quite well, but there are a few flaws that do not let me rate it as a masterpiece:

First of all, the age of MC and her companion does not correspond to their actual behavior. There are few excuses why this is the case for both of them, but they are simply too calculating and understanding for ...


It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login