metalinvader665's Profile - Reviews

Last OnlineToday, 12:09 AM
GenderMale
LocationUnited States
JoinedDec 14, 2010

Anime List Manga List

All (0)Friends

No friend yet.

Also Available at

rateyourmusic.com

RSS Feeds

Recent Manga
Recent Manga by Chapter
Blog Feed

Mar 27, 2016

Gundam: G no Reconguista (Anime) add

Mixed Feelings

It's amazing this is the lowest rated Gundam show on this site. It honestly doesn't deserve it. It didn't fuck up nearly as much as Gundam Age or Gundam Seed Destiny--I mean, at least someone put some thought into it. But the point is, it did fuck up. You learn in writing class 101 that every story has to have a denouement, a fancy way of saying "ending". Gundam: G no Reconguista has none. And that is why it fails. And fails hard, which is a shame to say as I tried to love this show as much as I could.

Yoshiyuki Tomino is the director, ... you know, the guy who created Gundam in the first place back in 1979. This was his first anime he directed in over a decade. I have great respect for the man--he directed so many classics, even outside of Gundam, like Dunbine and Ideon, plus he has an interesting personality. After all, why are his shows full of that odd but quirky and lovable writing that some people describe as "Aspergers-like"? Maybe a criticism, but that "odd" sense gives Tomino's shows their charm.

Tomino's most recent Gundam show he directed was Turn A Gundam, which many say is the height of the franchise. I'm inclined to degree--the atmosphere, the emotion, the sheer charm behind it, most certainly makes it unforgettable. Now this show--you knew from the PVs, you knew from the director, you knew from the art, and you quickly learned from the story, it clearly intended to capitalise on that aspect.

That's obvious from moment one, when you learn this is "after Universal Century" when civilisation is rebuilding itself. Okay, cool. So what will we do with this? We introduce a very interesting setting--we have a religion worshipping a space elevator in Brazil or somewhere nearby in Latin America, we have an interesting, enthusiastic protagonist, Bellri Zenam (first Brazilian Gundam protagonist), defending said space elevator, and we have a supporting cast full of intrigue. You've got some shady guys from the Moon (ancestors of the Moonrace of Turn A Gundam?), enemies of the future Brazilians in what's implied to be the future United States, and various other players in the intrigue like space pirates. It sets itself up well, evidenced from the introduction of the main Gundam when it crashes into some mobile suits from ZZ Gundam in an early fight scene--yes, Gundam fans are the target audience, make no mistake.

Anyone familiar with a Yoshiyuki Tomino anime will feel at home--it's blatantly obvious Tomino never cared one bit about the current anime industry or fans of nowadays anime. Plenty of weird dialogue, plenty of obscure motives, plenty of that strange 80s charm, well-transcribed to 2010's style animation.

Very good animation, I must add. Colourful and vibrant, but not like a children's anime like Gundam AGE nor "mature" like Gundam 00. It hearkens back to Turn A Gundam without a doubt, as does the character design and the mecha design. The G-Self and its many backpacks may not be as blatantly quirky as the titular mecha of Turn A Gundam (more reminsicent of Eureka 7, if anything), but it certainly is reminiscent of Turn A Gundam in so many ways in that it's one of the most unique mecha bearing the name "Gundam" (well, a protagonist's Gundam). For the music, it's not quite as good as the incredible soundtracks of the previous Gundams (every Gundam show up to and including Turn A Gundam), but it has a wonderful quirky nature to it, with jazz-inspired energetic tracks. It fits perfectly with the nature of the show. The ending song is glorious, too ("Tsukame prido! Tsukame success", etc.) as is the first opening song (a fantastic modern J-pop opener).

But there's one issue with this that utterly kills my enjoyment of the show--it has no point! Tomino introduces tons of interesting plot threads, interesting characters, a very interesting setting that any Turn A Gundam fan would love, but it all fails to be tied together. I suspect at some point Tomino asked for a 50 (or so) episode show, but didn't get it. Instead of anything else, Tomino stuck up his middle finger and organised it as he would a standard-length Gundam show. No other explanation can be given for the time spent doing very little but fighting off random enemy raids (like in a typical Tomino show), the villains who clearly have something up their sleeve but never really show it, and just the general feeling you're only halfway through the show when it suddenly ends.

I was expecting the whole time for something like the "Black History" episode of Turn A Gundam to show up, for the motives of everyone to be explained and come to light. But none of that happened. I was even expecting as late as the second-to-last episode for there to be an announcement of "there is a second season, don't worry!". But there wasn't. Instead, everything ends as basically follows--main Gundam gets uberhax weapon (that makes no logical sense why is only used a few times), a major battle happens (an admittedly very good battle, but regardless), and then a completely nonsensical ending happens which sees many, many out of character moments and utterly odd decisions by the characters. It feels like somone involved just said "fuck it, here's your ending".

Which is an utter shame, since I grew invested in the many characters as well as the setting. Bellri Zenam, an energetic and positive Gundam protagonist who might otherwise rank among my favourite Tomino protagonists. Aida Surugan, who I was always waiting for her potential to be revealed even though it never was. Raraiya Monday, the utterly crazy girl with some real moe appeal as well as an interesting subplot ended all too soon. Klim Nick and his crew, from a rival faction but sympathetic and intriguing at the same time. And the villains, from the Char clone "Captain Mask" and the interesting ideological factors driving him to the various folks supporting the factions in space, many of whom are never really enumerated upon or masked in random dialogue that's just waiting for an explanation which never comes. Again, there is so much potential and I can't say I didn't enjoy watching this show until the very end of it.

Really, up until the second half of the final episode, I'd be willing to give this show a solid grade. It's got plenty of great elements, and much of the charm of Turn A Gundam with almost no real bad moments (until the ending). But when you cloak everything in obfuscating dialogue and never reveal any of what it actually means, you produce something that means nothing in the end. Every story has to have an ending--G-Reco doesn't, instead it skips from the middle of the show to an ending that makes no sense. Production issues or just an utter lack of care? I don't know. All I know as a person viewing the end product is that somebody left you hanging in the process out of sheer lack of care.

The ultimate question G-Reco brings up is whether the journey or the ending is more important. I can't deny I utterly enjoyed this show as I was watching it, up until nearly the end. But when you have no real ending and leave an infinite amount of plot threads untouched, or, well, wrapped up in the most haphazard and pathetic way possible, you can't possibly leave the audience satisfied. I have no doubt G-Reco could have been a worthy successor to Turn-A Gundam if it had been 50 episodes long. But again, you simply piss off the audience if you write the show like that.

But it isn't, and that's the point. It fails as an anime, and watching it will do nothing but piss you off. If you like watching something with minimal to no overall plot, plenty of enjoyable anime exist for that. Not something with pretensions like this. G-Reco is to be viewed as a failure precisely for everything it doesn't do. This is a show for Tomino fanboys and Gundam completionists only, unless you have strong tolerance for being pissed off by the endings of the anime you watch. Not recommended for the sane among us.

Open

Gift

Dec 19, 2014

Kidou Senshi Gundam AGE (Anime) add

Not Recommended

*Due to the nature of the plot of this show, this review contains slight spoilers*

There's much to say about Gundam AGE--from the time it was first unveiled, the fanbase went crazy in anger thinking it was going to be some childish take on the franchise, things like how the Gundam wasn't even going to be piloted but controlled from afar by the AGE device, that they were going to remove any grimdark from the show, and so on. In any case, AGE is a significant departure in look from the grittyness of the previous Gundam, Gundam 00--00 had darker, mature-ish character and mecha designs, and ... AGE has a look more associated with children's anime (no surprise then that this show's writer and character designer also worked on projects like Inazuma Eleven). Despite all this, the show isn't really "childish" in any sense, and ends up being a typical Gundam show--or a sad attempt at being one.

Yes, Gundam AGE is no doubt the worst Gundam out there. Okay, I haven't seen fan disfavourite SEED Destiny outside of the first few episodes, but it'll have to be pretty bad to beat what writer Akihiro Hino and director Susumu Yamaguchi have presented us with here. They've presented us with a show that could have been a very solid show but instead refuses every attempt at being good.

Basically, Gundam AGE is a "multigenerational Gundam", which focuses on protagonist Flit Asuno, his son, and his grandson, all of which pilot three generations of the titular Gundam AGE. From that summary alone, I'd expect a very interesting plot involving intense familial themes, some romance, and perhaps some grand villainous threat that threatens the Asuno clan and their friends and their society over the decades. Instead this is merely a setup for infinite amounts of squandered opportunities at interesting plot threads. Take the expected romantic themes--relationships are reduced to little more than a casual mention at best, with pathetic attempts at creating love triangles that the concept art for the later characters made painfully obvious which girl "won", seeing how each son resembles their mother. "Won" belongs in quotes because little to no characterisation is given to any of the girls and love interests besides perhaps Yurin, who is a carbon copy of Lalah Sune from the original 0079 Gundam. Speaking of Yurin, we also get a scene so bizarre early on that it seems like a parody of the battle involving Lalah, Amuro, and Char from the original Gundam, involving a psychotic little kid as Char. Oh, that scene is also completely serious and sets up one of the major story threads, something so bad it puts all the borrowing of the original MSG plot Gundam SEED did to shame.

That's only a taste of the plot you'll find in this show. Gundam AGE effectively has three story arcs separated by timeskips, centering around Flit in the first, his son Asem in the second, and his grandson Kio in the third. It wouldn't be a stretch to say the first is "based on" Mobile Suit Gundam, the second on Zeta Gundam, and the third on ZZ Gundam. The first arc is pretty much junk--a shadowy faction with strange mobile suits are blowing up colonies, but it mostly ends up being a mixture of filler and dumb ripoffs of the original Gundam. The rest is better though, if only because it gets to answer the question of what Gundam protagonists and their comrades are doing decades after the events of their show, and Gundam AGE delivers for the second arc, which ends up being the only salvageable part of the show in the end. Here we see Flit's friend Woolf as a grizzled badass, Flit himself playing a role equivalent to the villainous Titans of Zeta Gundam, and that's sadly about it, because while the second arc presents an interesting story, it squanders its true potential by wasting about a third of its space with rather pointless high school filler arc that does little but set up the character of Gundam AGE's Char clone Zeheart. The arc also unceremoniously wastes an interesting plot point by killing off one of the most interesting characters of the first generation for no reason only a few minutes after he's reintroduced for the second arc. But at least we have a solid plot--angry humans on Mars want to take back the Earth, and start a total war with the Earth Sphere humans, which amounts to typical Gundam stuff. Oh, and look for a ripoff of one of the ending scenes of Gundam Wing (or Char's Counterattack, which Gundam Wing borrowed from) because Gundam AGE can't resist stealing famous Gundam scenes for its own use (although I admit this scene is pretty cool).

The third arc and the finale are what ends up utterly killing the show. Everything comes together to produce a flat nothing, with a corny plot development leading to protagonist Kio Asuno turning into perhaps the whiniest Gundam protagonist ever. This plot development involving him going to the home colony of the Mars humans ends up being horribly, horribly done, even though the writers no doubt intended it to be one of the tearjerking moments of the show. This also shows Gundam AGE's love for killing off characters in dramatic death scenes when they barely have been given any character development. Not that that stops them from giving a full episode devoted to a minor character introduced only the previous episode which goes into detail about her life, only for her to be killed off at the end of it. Nice misplaced priorities there, eh?

The ending is as bad as you'd expect by this point. The main villain reveals his plans, which are so utterly, utterly stupid they don't make logical sense even by Gundam villain standards. The Char clone of the show--who like most Char clones, comes across as fairly sympathetic for most of the show--chooses to go along with such idiocy and redoubles his efforts. And for the finale, expect a complete anticlimax--some people die in pointless ways, and the final episode is solely about a fight against a character who makes his first appearance in that same episode and has almost no personality. Wonderful.

Discounting the horribly wasted plot, Gundam AGE isn't all bad. While the artstyle and fight scenes are nowhere near the visceral glory of Gundam 00, for what it's worth everything is smoothly animated and sufficient. The character designs aren't that bad once you get used to them--it could be Hisashi "sameface" Hirai of Gundam SEED after all! The mecha designs are also pretty great, although the majority of the enemy mobile suits look like they'd better fit in a non-Gundam mecha anime, what with the draconic design of many of them. And compared to other Gundam shows (looking at you, SEED), AGE limits the number of Gundams floating around--there's a grand total of four Gundams (plus "backpacks") in the show. Three are the protagonist Gundams, each with nice allusions to the original RX-78 Gundam, the Zeta Gundam, and the ZZ Gundam respectively. The fourth is the Gundam of one of the villains, featuring a wonderfully alien design.

The soundtrack for Gundam AGE is incredible, with some nice modern elements pervading it. It certainly continues the trend of the newer Gundams (Turn A and onward) having awesome soundtracks that REALLY stand out unlike the still-good but less unique soundtracks of the older Gundams. The opening and closing songs are mixed bunch, the first two openers being cheesy, harmless J-pop, the third being a nice upbeat J-rock song, the final being a stellar J-pop song. Endings are less unique, with only the first--an electronic J-pop ballad--being memorable. As for the voice-acting, there's nothing negative I can say--Kazuhiko Inoue does a great job as the coldhearted older Flit, Hiroshi Kamiya does the villainous Zeheart well, and Daisuke Ono as Woolf makes the most out of the character. Prolific seiyuu Takehito Koyasu (who's done several other noteworthy Gundam roles in his time) shows up here as well.

But that's merely the makings of a potentially great show. In the end, the writers chose to squander every bit of potential for this show, instead creating this trainwreck in its place. Gundam AGE had the chance to be one of the franchise's most memorable shows, but instead it's something to be looked down on, and will be remembered as one of the worst moments for Gundam. Avoid this, and avoid this well.

Open

Gift

Back to metalinvader665's Profile metalinvader665's Profile

All (0)Friends

Also Available at

RSS Feeds

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters