Back to jam112383's Profile jam112383's Profile

This is only my second review I don't write them often but I feel this one needs a review.

I enjoyed the story it was very cute and there was solid development to the love however it was to much to fast and they story should of been longer.

Now a breakdown of my scores.

*I gave the story an 8 because for being a one shot it had a great deal of story to it but this was also it's flaw it was a cute love story and had major potential but I feel the mangaka tried to put to much into one chapter.

*I ... gave the art an 8, the art was really good it had the shoujo feel too and the female lead was pretty but not over the top and the male lead was handsome but again not over the top. The side characters were not thrown to the side they had uniqueness to them.

*Characters get a 7. The down side to one shot manga is that there is no time to describe the characters to the fullest but this artist managed to get the basis down very well.

*Enjoyment was a 9. I really enjoyed the story but it had so much potential to go further then one chapter.

So overall I gave it a seven it was enjoyable but really should of had more chapters it was to much to fast.

This is my first review so be patient with me.

Story 9 - I give this story a nine because it was simply enjoyable. I started it and finished it all in the same night non stop I didn't get up once it kept me reading. I would have given it a ten but the ending was very disappointing.

Art 10 - The art is manwha has never disappointed me, but there were so many scenes where my breath was stolen at the beauty of the art. I was in awe the whole time.

Character 8 - The characters were all really well drawn personalities fit their looks. ... The teacher was beautiful even her brother who is "nerdy" was beautiful. Character got an 8 because some of the characters could have had more depth of more closure before they disappeared from the story.

Enjoyment 9 - Like I said previously I couldn't stop reading it. The story of student and teacher has been done so many times, but somehow this one seemed different. I was very disappointing and let down with the ending which is why I couldn't give this a 10.

Overall - Due to the two eights and two nines overall I give this story a 9. The only thing I can really say I wished was different was the ending. Other than that I wouldn't change a thing!

I recommend reading this if you like student X teacher, trauma, drama or just plain romance.