Back to htsalt's Profile htsalt's Profile

I was expecting this manga to be a bit more of a serious version of Call of the Night. While there are some more intense scenes between the two main leads, I actually found it to be more comedic than Call of the Night. The artstyle is simple but detailed where it needs to be (i.e. not as much background work but a lot of detail in facial expressions). For some reason the art was giving off Uzumaki vibes even though this manga is far from a horror genre. I did feel a bit uncomfortable about the intimate scenes given the age range but that ... is fairly common in work like this (also you could argue that the vampires are much older).

There is also some nudity here and there but it's not in-your-face most of the time. The story is a bit hard to keep up with since not that much is explained about the history of the vampires in the manga until the very end. I would say that the first half of the manga is very typical will-they yuri romance and the second half becomes a bit more high stakes.

Ichido dake demo, Koukai Shitemasu (sorry, i am not going to use the cringe english title) is a short and sweet story between a landlord and bummy unemployed tenant. It's a bit similar to Monthly in the Garden with My Landlord but it's a bit spicier. The intimate scenes aren't too graphic though and are actually quite sweet. I really like how the relationship between the characters developed even though the premise is a bit silly (returning "favors" to pay for rent). I really like the more simplistic artsyle as well. It also is clear that the author was intending to do more with the ... side characters and backstory but unfortunately there isnt enough space to fit all that within 3 volumes.

Her Tale of Shim Chong takes the familiar cross-class romance formula and reinvents it through a captivating Korean historical setting and an intricate mystery plot. While it begins with a somewhat difficult-to-like protagonist in Chong, the story evolves into an expertly paced romance that keeps readers guessing with its surprising twists and turns, defying traditional narrative expectations at every step.

PROS:
Perfect pacing of the central romance
Unique historical Korean setting
Engaging mystery elements that enhance the plot
Strong character development, especially for Chong
Satisfying conclusion with well-crafted epilogue

CONS:
... Rough start may deter some readers
Basic premise feels familiar
Initial protagonist characterization can be off-putting

Rainbows After Storms refreshingly breaks from romance manga conventions by establishing its central relationship early and following it beyond the typical high school confession endpoint. The series shines through its grounded portrayal of young love, featuring characters who behave with realistic maturity rather than falling into common genre archetypes or exaggerated personality traits.

PROS:
Natural relationship progression beyond high school
Well-rounded, realistic characters
Consistent, appealing art style
Early relationship establishment allows for deeper development
Avoids common romance manga tropes

CONS:
... May feel too understated for those seeking high drama
Slower pacing due to realistic approach
Some might find the characters too reserved

Emma stands out through its meticulously researched Victorian London setting and authentic portrayal of period romance. While the story of a maid falling in love with a member of the upper class isn't new, the manga elevates this familiar premise through careful attention to historical detail, beautiful artwork, and remarkably believable character reactions to class differences. The series particularly shines in its depiction of Victorian society's rigid class structure and how it affects relationships, all rendered in expressive, detail-rich art that brings 19th century London vividly to life.

PROS:
Exceptionally well-researched Victorian setting
Beautiful, detailed art style
Realistic handling of family conflict
Convincing period-appropriate character behaviors
Strong side stories after main ... plot

CONS:
Familiar romantic plot structure
Main story concludes before final volumes
Pacing can feel slow for some readers

"Citrus+" is a direct sequel that requires reading the original Citrus series first, but rewards readers with a markedly different tone. Trading the original's toxic dynamics for healthier relationships, this continuation focuses on Mei's emotional growth and her deepening bond with Yuzu, while expanding the story's scope to develop its supporting cast. The refined art style and softer approach create a more wholesome experience.

PROS:
Healthier relationship dynamics
Strong character development, especially for Mei
Better integration of side characters
Polished art style
More balanced drama

CONS:
... Lower stakes might disappoint drama fans
Still carries some baggage from original series
Pacing can feel slow at times

Citrus brings a unique angle to the yuri genre by deeply exploring familial pressure and generational trauma, even though it starts with some common tropes. The art style effectively complements the narrative, particularly excelling at emotional expression and maintaining a good balance between serious and lighter moments. The main characters, especially Mei and Yuzu, show considerable depth and development, though their initial interactions can feel unrealistic. While character reactions become more authentic as the story progresses, early relationship dynamics often stretch credibility. The series will particularly appeal to readers who enjoy dramatic romance and character psychology, and who can look past the problematic early content ... to appreciate the larger story about healing and growth. However, it's definitely not for everyone - readers sensitive to non-consensual content or those seeking lighter romance should probably look elsewhere.

Sweat and Soap" stands out in the romance manga landscape by focusing on working adults rather than high school students, delivering a refreshingly mature take on relationships. Despite its quirky premise of a perfumer with a supernatural sense of smell falling for a woman insecure about her body odor, the series evolves into a thoughtful exploration of adult romance, self-acceptance, and personal growth.

PROS:
- Mature handling of adult relationships
- Strong character development, especially for Asako
- Realistic portrayal of relationship challenges
- Tasteful approach to intimate scenes
- Natural progression of romance

CONS:
... - Initially odd premise might deter some readers
- Some early awkward moments in the setup
- Supporting cast could be more developed

"The Quintessential Quintuplets" begins deceptively, presenting itself as a standard harem manga complete with all the expected tropes from the initial hostile relationship between the tutor and students to the classic misunderstandings and comedic situations. However, the series proves to be far more nuanced than its familiar opening suggests.

What starts as a straightforward comedic series about a stern tutor attempting to educate five identical sisters gradually transforms into a thoughtful exploration of relationships and personal growth. The early chapters excel at establishing the dynamics between Fuutaro and the quintuplets through genuinely funny situations that arise from their clashing personalities.

The series shines in how it develops ... each of the quintuplets as distinct individuals despite their identical appearance. Their growing feelings for Fuutaro feel organic and well-earned, emerging from meaningful interactions and shared experiences rather than convenient plot devices. Fuutaro himself shows significant growth, developing from a purely academically-focused student into someone who learns to understand and appreciate the emotional complexities of those around him.

The series' ending and the ultimate choice of which quintuplet Fuutaro ends up with has been a point of contention in the community. However, the conclusion feels authentic to the story's themes of growth and understanding. While not every reader will be satisfied with the final pairing, the journey to that point is crafted with care and attention to emotional authenticity.

What elevates "The Quintessential Quintuplets" above typical harem manga is its commitment to character development and emotional honesty. While it plays with familiar tropes, it uses them as a foundation to build something more meaningful rather than relying on them as crutches.

Oshi no Ko stands as a striking exploration of the entertainment industry's dark underbelly, masterfully weaving together elements of psychological drama, mystery, and social commentary. The series immediately captivates with its shocking opening arc, setting a tone that perfectly balances intrigue with emotional depth.

The series' greatest strength lies in its character writing, particularly with Akane and Kana. Akane's struggles with mental health and the pressures of stardom create some of the most compelling character development in recent manga. Her arc demonstrates how the entertainment industry can simultaneously build and break a person. Kana, meanwhile, serves as a fascinating counterpoint, representing the resilience and determination required ... to survive in show business.

While Ruby and Aqua serve as our primary window into this world, their characters, though interesting, don't quite reach the same emotional heights as Akane and Kana. Nevertheless, their unique perspective as reincarnated individuals adds an intriguing layer to their interactions with the entertainment industry.

What sets Oshi no Ko apart is its willingness to tackle heavy themes head-on. The series doesn't shy away from addressing mental health, suicide, exploitation, and the toxic aspects of idol culture. These elements are handled with appropriate gravity while remaining integral to the story rather than feeling sensationalized.

The mystery elements woven throughout the narrative serve not just as plot devices but as vehicles to explore deeper themes about identity, revenge, and the price of fame. The shocking revelations throughout the story keep readers engaged while contributing to the larger narrative about the entertainment industry's hidden darkness.

The series' ending, while potentially divisive, stays true to its tragic roots. Rather than offering a neat resolution, it reflects the messy reality of the world it portrays. While some readers might find this unsatisfying, it feels thematically appropriate for a story that has consistently challenged conventional narratives about fame and success.

Overall, Oshi no Ko succeeds as both a compelling drama and a critical examination of modern entertainment culture. Despite some character development being stronger than others, the series maintains its grip through strong writing, effective visual storytelling, and unflinching exploration of its themes.