Total Recommendations: 3
If you liked
Shuffle!
|
...then you might like
True Tears
|
Both series belong to a small group of harem anime that are actually good. The drama and characters (all of them in True Tears, and a sufficient number in Shuffle) feel genuine and engaging. While I have low expectations of harem series by default, these two proved to be exceptions to the rule.
If you liked
Strawberry Panic
|
...then you might like
Shoujo Sect
|
While Shoujo Sect is hentai, and Strawberry Panic only... let us call it borderline hentai, they're both well-made yuri anime, and should appeal to roughly the same audience.
If you liked
Zero no Tsukaima
|
...then you might like
Toradora!
|
Taiga is Louise (Or Shana, if you will) with a different hair color. While I have only seen the first episode of Toradora so far, I suspect the plot will develop similarly.