Back to beatingheartx's Profile beatingheartx's Profile

The story plot and setting for Sukisho is, to me, very fresh. I would say that it is one of a kind. However, despite having such a interesting plot, it is not being built on. I feel that there are some parts of the story where it could still be elaborated on, so as to create a better story.

The art for Sukisho is excellent, and the characters are all very intriguing. Character developments for the main leads are done in a very smooth way, even when there are a few filter episodes. One can clearly see the process in which the main characters changed, ... in which the psychological changes are more emphasised.

The only complaint i have is that there are not enough man x man scenes in the anime. It is very shounen-ai, but not yaoi enough.

Overall, in my opinion, this is a extremely enjoyable anime, even though i had thought of dropping Sukisho a couple of times. There are a lot of suspense, comedy and, of course, love. Sukisho is the anime that has something (specifically the story plot) that i would really want every anime to have, in order to enjoy myself to the maximum...

Haibane Renmei..
Not trying to spoil the anime but when i first saw that these angels could not fly (meaning the wings are for show?), i predicted that at the near end of the anime, the main character would be able to fly, fly across the tall wall that separates the town from the outside world since that she is always pondering about things such as what is the outside world like, where she is from and stuff. And thus, the mysteries of the town and the wall would be solved. A classic ending. Unfortunately, it did not happen and these mysteries are not solved ... when the anime ended. I mean it is like the main lead suddenly loses her curiosity, and oh, it is happily and ever after. Sure, i get that. But hello, is that even possible? Not only that, even at the very end, new mysteries are introduced that are left unanswered.

The story is unique enough that it intrigues and lures people in. Born in a cocoon and irregardless of age? The mystery of the wall? The custom of Haibane's? But most importantly, the dreams... I thought that Haibane Renmei was a masterpiece...until i think back and carefully run through the whole anime. I had to admit that after that, i had to ask myself over and over again what i liked about this anime. Having so many unanswered questions is a pain in the neck. Also, when the solution seemed to be reached, a new problem popped out.

I really like the psychological aspect of this anime though. Although most of the questions asked are typical questions like what they are, some really make me think.

The art is okay. The OP, ED and the insert songs are amazing. However, i feel that there is no character development at all. Not much of unique personalities too.

Overall, i guess it is okay. A word of advice: Don't think too much and you would be able to enjoy this anime a lot.

Story:
The drama ''Tantei Gakuen Q'' is one of my favourites, and I watched it long before i decided to watch the anime. Since dramas follow (but always not too closely) the original manga/anime, i had expected to see some similar cases the characters faced in the drama, in the anime. I can't say that i am disappointed, when i discovered that it was true. All the cases are just as appalling, and even though i knew what is going to happen next (for some), i find myself hoping and waiting for whatsoever to happen.

Art:
The art is not my cup of tea, and because i usually ... look at the art before watching any anime, i was put off by it. It is okay when i watch it for a long period of time.

Sound:
When watching anime, i would not really notice the sound. The OP and ED themes are considerably good, so i guess it was fine.

Character:
I really like the characters. All the various characters have their own unique personalities, and for the characters in the Q and A class, that plays a huge role. Their personalities affect the way they think, observe the case and deduce, after all. To add on, the one thing i like about Tantei Gakuen Q is that the main lead is not the only ''intelligent'' one in the Q class. He and this other (mysterious and seemingly dark) guy work together exceptionally well, to the point where i think that they can communicate through telepathy.

Enjoyment:
I enjoyed the anime a lot, but there are also quite a number of unsatisfactory areas. Aside from the fact that the plot remains hanging at the end, i also dislike the fact that Tantei Gakuen Q does not give a serious feel. Perhaps it is because it is targeted more towards a younger audience, that is why the plot remains light.

Overall:
As a mystery fan, i would consider Tantei Gakuen Q a must watch. I would put it as that this is what i believe a true detective story is like, despite the unsatisfactory points. Last but not least, i definitely hope for a second season to come out so as to solve all the unsolved mysteries.