Having had watched and kept up with the anime since the beginning; I enjoyed my brief time spent in the fandom. I was absorbed in it as a series, but it was more for its idea than anything else, and my own interest in the themes shown throughout it. However, the dark atmosphere mixed with mecha/sci-fi that I love above all other genres was, in part, what had me overlooking quite a few flaws. I'll go into detail, but before I begin, I'll just note that this is one of the first series I've ever been conflicted enough about to write a full review
...
for.
Story: 7/10
The concept overall was unique and quite interesting-- a species almost mirrored in looks to humans, yet drastically different in nature. When I read about what this anime's main focus would be, I found myself very interested to see it. The themes presented throughout the anime, and also the likelyhood of the viewer to side with the humans instead of the Martians through the simple observation of all the character's experiences was what stood out to me. At times, there was a few scenes where the viewer had to conclude their own findings and try to understand for themselves what just happened, this helps the viewer get pulled into the story. Even though this anime was thematically powerful, emotionally evoking and thought provoking, Aldnoah.Zero has a weakness, and that would be the writing behind the anime.
The main reason I'm giving the story a 7/10 is because it's mediocre at best. There are many questions left unanswered due to the sudden, disorganized and very rushed ending; however, I will talk about the ending further later in the review.
If asked to explain the plot of Aldnoah,Zero, how would I? A handful of Humans go to Mars, they discover a special force called Aldnoah, they turn into "superior beings" and are later called Martians. A war breaks out between Martians and Humans. There's a fake assassination thrown in there, then even more war breaks out. All ending with a real assassination. There's seriously a lack of natural flow from each of these events. It feels like each conflict is pulled out of nowhere and not thoughtfully put together to help develop the story or the characters. There is no driving force to propel the story forward, it's just one event after another - put together to make it exciting enough for people to keep watching it without knowing or understand exactly what they're seeing on the screen. It also doesn't help that many of the characters were overall very bland and unimportant.
Onto the topic of character development itself, there is little to none. There is no big event that changed any characters for the better or worst because the only big event that happened in this anime was in the last 5 minutes of the entire series. There was changes in characters from event to event but there was no overall character development. No one grew from these events-- their attitudes or their overall judgement. Through simple, skillful development and writing skills, there could have been amazing character development. We could have seen how Inaho feels about his comrades, instead we're left with this empty shell of a main character, that's almost too calm to be natural; Maybe we could've understood why Slaine was so attached to the Martians besides the lame one or two sentence explanations that don't really fit.
As for the ending of Aldnoah.Zero. The ending to this anime was what made me realize the amount of poor writing I'd been overlooking previously. In short, Inaho finally makes an emotional decision, and instead of using common sense he goes against Slaines order to stay away from the princess (who was just shot by Sazzbaum). Inaho instead started crawling towards the princess. When Slaine continued to say stay away from her, Inaho ignored him, instead turned over and pulled his gun on Slaine. That part of the scene ends with a gunshot and we're left not knowing whether Inaho is alive or dead but we're lead to believe the latter. This ending just overall felt very rushed and unpolished. We're left asking more questions than necessary. It's one of the most terrible endings I've seen in awhile. Only added to the unanswered questions and unresolved conflicts left throughout the latter half of the story-- each of these only added to how terrible the ended really was.
Art: 8/10
Moving on to more positive things, the art was actually something that I enjoyed. It was a bit clunky at times but they used various techniques to make the mechas blend into the background; such as camera angles, colors, smoke, lighting, etc. It was overall very visually appealing.
Character: 7/10
This category can be a tad foggy, the characters in and of themselves are not bad. However, they are poorly developed. Their base characters are interesting and are a bit realistic. Each of them is unique and designed around their own personal role and personality. If there was more character development throughout the anime I would have given a higher score.
Enjoyment: 7/10
As I have said earlier, I did overlook quite a few flaws throughout the story. Perhaps if the anime had been longer (the first season in and of itself), it may have redeemed itself by answering a few more questions and resolving a few plot conflicts. It came to a close too suddenly to be enjoyable. This series was easier to enjoy closer to the beginning rather than the end of it, which is odd enough to say. However, the overall concept and idea of the anime is keeping me from rating it below a 7.
Overall: 7/10
Aldnoah.Zero can be considered an example of what could have been amazing. If perhaps there had been more time or guidance it could have risen higher, and had a better chance to shine with such an interesting idea. However, due to the characters being hardly developed, their plot in general was left with holes towards the end, and the events left in disconnect; I feel lost. I probably wouldn't recommend someone to watch this.
Apr 14, 2015
Aldnoah.Zero
(Anime)
add
Having had watched and kept up with the anime since the beginning; I enjoyed my brief time spent in the fandom. I was absorbed in it as a series, but it was more for its idea than anything else, and my own interest in the themes shown throughout it. However, the dark atmosphere mixed with mecha/sci-fi that I love above all other genres was, in part, what had me overlooking quite a few flaws. I'll go into detail, but before I begin, I'll just note that this is one of the first series I've ever been conflicted enough about to write a full review
...
Nov 16, 2012
Naruto: Shippuuden
(Anime)
add
Love gives birth to sacrifice.
It's one of the trinity of most popular animes, which includes Naruto, Bleach, and One Piece. All far into the hundreds and hundreds of episodes. I finished the first Naruto series, and I'm close to catching up in Naruto: Shippuuden. So, Let's just jump right into my review, may turn out to be a long one. Story: 6/10 I loved this story, at first. The reason it didn't get a 10/10 is the fact that it's not necessarily an original story, the concept of a ninja based anime is not at all an original concept anymore. Also, there's been reoccurring issues with the ... Nov 16, 2012
Shinsekai yori
(Anime)
add
"To succeed in deception, you must mold your own mind, into believing your lies are true, subsequently if you believe your own lies, then in some form you are not a liar, but a speaker of what you believe is true. Ultimately it is the perfect deception, for you get to deceive without lying, and thus there is no guilt. That is, if you’re a deceiver with a conscience." -Anonymous
Deceit. Lies. Love. Lost. Gods. Power. Shinsekai yori is the type of anime that makes you confused, fall in love with it and then stabs you in the back as soon as you think you ... |