Report WhoCanPeliCan's Profile

I put a lot of value in enjoyment above all. This doesn't mean that Story, Characters, Art, etc. don't contribute to my score as those things will naturally effect my enjoyment. Objectivity is impossible so I will not pretend that it is.

Here is my tier list as to form a comprehensive idea of what is good and what is bad. In a shorter version, anything above a 5 is a positive review in some form, anything at or below is leaning on negative. The examples I list are just to give a general guidelines of what I think is a good example of that specific score. The first ones are anime and the second are manga.

10 – So called perfect anime or manga. It goes without saying that they don’t not have flaws, but they simply are great enough to not make me care. I 100% adored my time consuming these. (Hunter x Hunter (2011) + Grand Blue)

9 – Anything that reaches a 9/10 is great, no two ways about it. I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading or watching these and many of them could reach into my general favorites. What’s really holding them back is nothing specific, but simply something slightly more to push them over the edge of fantastic into “masterpiece” (Megalobox + Bakuman)

8 – Anything that has an 8/10 is probably a great piece of work. It’s nothing amazing, but it more than has enough positive aspects to make it a great anime or manga. (Penguin Highway + Tsurezure Children)

7 – While not an amazing score, works that get a 7/10 tend to be decent and pretty enjoyable. I enjoyed most of my time while reading or watching these, but not so much so that I’d call them amazing or great. (Made in Abyss + Saeki-san wa Nemutteru)

6 – This is the upper bland score. While this piece of media tends towards neutrally average and mediocre, what keeps it from falling lower is the fact that it had a few great scenes or aspects. (Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken + Gal Gohan)

5 – This is the lower bland score. While this piece of media tends towards neutral and mediocre, it’s general quality and traits lean slightly more negative. I typically don’t have many strong opinions on this kind of stuff and usually end up dropping it out of a lack of interest, rather than it being explicitly low quality. (Soul Eater + Nega-kun to Posi-chan)

4 – This is where we reach the lower rankings start to really begin. Anything here tends to be stuff that is very bland while actively being pretty bad in the process. Most of the anime here tend to be boring franchise films. (Joshiochi!: 2-kai kara Onnanoko ga... Futtekita!? + Midara na Ao-chan wa Benkyou ga Dekinai)

3 – This is where things start to get bad. Anything that reaches this point starts to veer from bland and unmemorable to reaching the point of having far too noticeable flaws. My experience begins to get actively negative. (Steins;Gate 0 + Ashigei Shoujo Komura-san)

2 – If anything reaches this point it’s more than likely beyond saving. I already kind of began to hate anything sitting at 3/10, so anything that scores even lower probably just drilled the nail in it’s coffin that much harder. (Fairy Tail The Second Movie: Dragon Cry + Momo no Musume!)

1 – There is a special place in hell for these offensive pieces of garbage. (Conception + PanSt.)

100th Completed Anime - My Hero Academia The Movie: Two Heroes
150th Completed Anime - Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion
200th Completed Anime - Dr. Stone: Stone Wars

50th Completed Manga - Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo
100th Completed Manga - Do Chokkyuu Kareshi x Kanojo
150th Completed Manga - Kamiya