Back to Steamwood's Profile Steamwood's Profile

Naruto ran so this could also run, then trip and have a three paragraph explanation about how crazy it is they tripped. 
I cannot but help comparing this series with others, namely Naruto and Chainsaw Man, the former this borrows from, and the latter borrows from it. 

Cursed spirits are uninspired compared to Devils. I started both around the same time, and Chainsaw Man has much better explanations for Devil power levels compared to JJK. Why are there only a handful of cursed spirits based on primal fears in JJK? Why bother using such a cool idea if you ignore it after the first two arcs? 

From Naruto, ... you have a half-face-obscured, white-haired teacher with incredible power teaching a goofy dude with an incalculably destructive demon inside, an emo dude with family issues, and a girl who will never get any real fights after chapter 20.
I just don't think the series has good enough characters to drag out arcs like other strong Shonen series of old did, as the introduced characters just don't have much going on and are often one-note or change desires on a dime. It wants to be a funny series to break up the seriousness of the setting at times but isn't funny and isn't good enough at laying the scene for why something is serious either. The antagonists are one of: brainless monsters, unkillable curses that take 8 lethal blows but continue on as if nothing happened, or Aizen but less charismatic. The internal sorcery politics are something new but then the plot says "everyone hates the protagonists now" and all sides become black and white. 

I think the writer knew things were getting out of control because he abruptly stopped the culling game the second Gojo got out and then fights became even more wordy exposition dumps about why a move was so cool instead of just showing us a cool move. There's too much inconsequential garbage in each fight, and as a result there have only been about 5 main arcs in 270 chapters. (JJK High, Kyoto Games, Gojo Flashback, Shibuya, Culling Game) All of Naruto's first series can fit into that space!

The power system is so wildly exponential. Nobara is literally useless after 50 chapters against the threats that appear so it's just Pink Man and Not Sasuke doing anything in the main trio, leading to a never ending parade of new characters that are flat or confusing. Setting up the graded sorcery conceit made no sense once everything interesting immediately became special grade, and anyone under that mark became chum.

Gojo is the most interesting main character and he was in a box for over 1000 real-life days. But he's also way, way too strong and the story can't justify anyone else doing things he can't while he's alive, so he got double-killed. Neat. And he even gets the afterlife sidebar JUST LIKE KAKASHI DID AGAINST PAIN!

But I don't want to deny it - this series was fun at first, then it became a frustrating slog during Shibuya and especially during the Culling Game. The best chunk of JJK is JJK Zero, which is short, sweet, and not overstuffed with half baked characters and concepts. If I read one more thing about a can't-miss domain attack that doesn't mean jack shit as fighters 'recharge their burnt-out reverse cursed technique', my eyes will roll through my skull.

It's always good when you have to spend the third to last chapter having all of your characters question why they did use certain techniques in the final battle. I cannot believe it just ends with Itadori, the guy who barely survived Shibuya, killing the final boss a month in-story later by punching him a lot. Borrowing Bleach's power scaling is not a particularly good idea!

It's a shame that this wasn't as good as the hype would lead you to believe, but sometimes you have too many ideas to co-exist in one weekly series. A solid start, a pretty weak finish.

A stirring piece of life in a high school concert band and the growth of a shy student, concluding with this season. It's a slice of life series with serious scenes of contemplation as various forces in life pull you apart from the things you care about, and what you will do if they're strong enough to stop you. Will you bow to family pressures or stay true to the goals you have? Will your friends stick with you even if you aren't the best person to lead?

There's a lot of things to appreciate in this series, from the great roster of characters, the gorgeous ... Kyoto scenery, the music (obviously), and the questions about self and goals. It comes together for a great total package all within about 13 episodes per season that I highly recommend!

The final season in particular deals with fierce competition against someone who acts like they don't want to be a part of it, which you really don't see in anime or any media too much! I won't spoil anything but the resolution to it all left me thinking about it for a couple days after.

Absolutely worth a watch and a necessity if you cared about high school band, but it's a little sad that the extremely queer-coded interactions between Kumiko and Reina in the end came to nothing and she got stealth paired with a dude she barely seemed interested in. OH WELL.

I don't think I've seen a series get cancelled before 20 chapters before, this thing must've been completely ignored by readers everywhere! It's got some charming aspects, it's a superpowered slice of life story that has the main character live with a found family of other superpowered goofballs. If you like that premise, then I'd recommend this as it will take you all of 45 minutes max to read the entire series!

The art is fine, but the design of everyone is just not quite to the level it needed to be to stick around and attract an audience. The secondary protagonist in particular wears a ... plain bucket and a size XXXL shirt and it's just not visually interesting. A shame to end so fast, but honestly it worked out plot-wise since every chapter except the last two was a pretty simple story.

The fun core of the show is still here with the goofballs that orbit Mash and Mash's own insane antics, but it loses some steam in the last few episodes this season. There are a few amazingly animated pieces throughout, but also some really, really cheap looking stuff as the final fight arc drags on a bit too long.

It loses a little focus on what makes Mashle really pop when it drags too much without a good joke to punctuate the heavier stuff, which is unfortunate. Still, I'll be watching the next season and it is still very enjoyable for the first few episodes, and ... if you aren't put off by the weird rap I'd say this OP is one of the best in a decade, it's so lively and fun!

Konosuba - A World Without Bras!

It's a lighthearted adventure with a bunch of weirdos in a goofy isekai, with a few absolutely head-scratching moments of mean-spirited perversion from the main character. If you know you're getting a mostly fun story about someone reincarnated with a maxed out luck stat with a heaping side portion of fan service that veers into some wild territory, then I think you'd enjoy it. I was not expecting quite so much degeneracy from Kazuma but now I know!

Animation is fine, no mind-blowing stuff there (except for boobs, they really like animating boobs), story is pretty much just a fun ... string of misadventures around their town, and the dub is very solid. If you're a fan of fanservice, go for it. Otherwise, I'm not going to recommend it in polite company.

An excellent story about being hard-headedly competitive, opening up, and fighting for what you want in life. Also a story about being so bad at singing that you ruin your reputation among friends, eating a lot of ramen, and becoming a Youtuber. It's really interesting to see what odd adventures show up in this series to lighten the tension of the main story, though I will say it likes to hit the same jokes often... but does it matter if it's got enough of a tweak to keep it fresh?

Regardless - how much you like this series hinges on how much you like Kaguya and ... Shirogane. If you like their stupid battles of wits, you'll probably enjoy how their relationship evolves and be invested enough to like the side characters as well, who are given pretty thorough backstories as the run continues.

Art is solid and evolves into a more cutesy style as their relationship grows more friendly and less combative, though almost all adult characters have something weird with their mouths, IMO.

Can now be entirely read on the Shonen Jump app!

They gave a 60 year old man magenta hair, a terrible Southern accent, and Doflamingo's glasses and expect me to take him seriously?

I checked this out after hearing that it was one of the best One Piece movies, and I am leaving completely unimpressed. The plot is "bad guy wants to destroy everyone" in service of the same boring backstory you use when you have no ideas for why someone can justify their extreme means. The animation is good for about 3 minutes total. It's uncomfortable in the fanservice department given the messed up ages of the female crew. Barely any of the crew ... get to do anything fun except at the very end!

I wanted to check this out in the hopes that I'd been unfairly avoiding the anime and movies. Having seen what constitutes good for the adaptations of the series, I will continue to avoid them and stick to the manga!

A quick story that would've benefitted from a little more time to tell it!

Definitely more meaningful from having seen Alternative before it - it's a direct sequel series that reflects on the question "What do you do when you can't live up to other's expectations?" For the new characters, it asks "What would you do to shake up the world you don't belong in?"

Both are interesting questions to ponder! It gets through them to some extent but would've benefitted from a little more fleshing out - though, it is fun to try and put the pieces together from the juuuuuust enough detail you get in ... about 60 minutes of story.

Harumi is a fun character that I hope other people enjoyed, as they were an unexpected source of conflict! I liked them as the chaos-redhead much more in this story than I would've seeing Haruko crowbarred in when she doesn't really have enough humanity to tell this type of story. Also uhhhh man their backstory is harsh!

Definitely worth a watch if you enjoyed Alternative, and I'd say it's great at being its own little niche of coming of age FLCL (though what that means to you may vary).

Solid series of one-shots (typically) starring the most stuck-up dude in Diamond is Unbreakable as he discovers some insane stuff going on in the world!

I typically have issues with the coherence of art in Jojos - it can be hard to tell if someone 1) has correct anatomy and 2) is supposed to HAVE correct anatomy in the first place. Not the case here, everything is clean and easy to read. Rohan Kishibe is a fun character in a world where he has a stable job amid the insanity of the Jojo setting, and is just powerful enough and smart enough to make him very ... capable and fun. I'm a fan of one-shots so I am definitely enjoying this series so far (if they ever make more), and would absolutely recommend it to anyone who likes Jojo overall!

Interesting setting, fun main character dynamic, great art, better ending than most cancelled series.

I recommend this, even though it barely sticks a landing within the last 4/5 chapters after it becomes clear that it's not being continued. It's a cool relationship to have for a series to have the #1 strongest enemy in the enemy's group as your main companion! It led to some thoughtful dynamics - 100 will defend Ashibi at almost any cost, but she doesn't want to destroy the only Fabricant that can fix her. How do you proceed when you can't rely on your partner to end the danger your society ... is in?

They don't cover that in much detail after the fact, however, in a rush to get a power system in play and a new arc started to keep readers interested. Still, I loved the art and the characters were interesting enough to keep me going. A shame it's gone, but it's much better than most cancelled series of a similar length.