Back to ShmellLuvsManga's Profile ShmellLuvsManga's Profile

Magical girl project raising is pretty cool I like the different powers of the individual characters. I like that each one had powers that weren’t that overpowered but were used in a very savage and desperate way to either save or kill. This story for me isn’t nothing to write home about but was able to keep my attention which is hard for me do with a series that I deem mediocre so it’s probably high mid for me. I also have a soft spot for stories that don’t let that feeling of suspense that no one is safe from death and plot armor even ... though it is there, is seems to be invisible to me the reader and gives me the belief that anyone even the main character can die just like anyone else. 6/10 What I don’t like is that I feel as though it was super short and there was very little substance to the characters so I felt little connection to them. The only reason this series got a 6 was this series ability to keep me wondering what gonna happen next in terms of who will die next in the tournament but if it wasn’t for the deaths to pull on the emotional heart strings then I could care less about this series.

Although the concept of it was cool and some of the story telling aspects of the series and the trials and tribulations that the main character and the main supporting character go through are interesting and can emotional catch your attention and draw you in quickly become boring and repetitive and eventually lacks any kind of substance and it eventually is just sad for the sake of being sad. Even the what was intended heart wrenching ending lacked any kind substance because of the amount of similar feeling the author kept making you feel. Pretty bad 4/10. It’s a pizza with no toppings and the ... dough tastes bad. A topless tasteless pizza.

This was my first romance manwha/manga ever and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I’m glad that I gave yumis cells a shot because I didn’t know if it was going to be good or not based on how low this series was ranked on the manga list. Honestly I’m going to change my ranking from a 5 to a 8 because outside the quality of this series it has done a lot for me in terms of taking me out of my comfort zone and trying something new. My gripe is that it can be boring sometimes when some of the chapters are about slice of ... life and it can drag on. Also it give you incite that other peoples minds work the same yet different at the same time.

It’s was okay nothing to write home about in my opinion. Something to read but I didn’t love it. Although I did like the aesthetic of the flowers and that one guy with the white hair he looked pretty cool. The ending made me feel like there was gonna be room for possibly a sequel but the cast solved the problem at the end of the day which was like eh because they could of possibly saved it their if they left room for more world building. That’s another one of my gripes about this series is that the world building was actually pretty decent ... and could of been explored on but the author did nothing with it we just got this short story and it was done could of been goated.