If you liked
Natsume Yuujinchou
|
...then you might like
Chihayafuru
|
as a guy, its another shoujo that isnt too heavy on its "shoujo-esc" aspects and has more of a sports shounen with a hint of that shoujo calm, and subtleness. While one is more sport and another supernatural, they both give the same vibe.
If you liked
Shakugan no Shana
|
...then you might like
Noragami
|
Both have supernatural creatures and another invisible "world" that cannot be seen by normal humans. Both have normal people forgetting the presence of people that were affected by the "other world." Both MCs have long "katana like" swords. The flame hazes can be the gods of Noragami. Both have a girl that doesn't fight but gets involved with the "other world." Both have antagonists that have many "pawns/weapons."
If you liked
Pandora Hearts
|
...then you might like
Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta
|
Both shows have almost identical 15-year-old, golden-haired MCs who keep their sad feelings of their past to themselves. They act happy-go-lucky and try not to think too hard about troubles. Both were sort of nobles and want to protect a black-haired girl they just met.