Back to Noir_Alchemist's Profile Noir_Alchemist's Profile

I'm so dissapointed i had to write a review. Just to say this as short as possible, karekano this is plot better.

Story: i never thought i would find so a hardcore soap opera from a shoujo, i seen drama, i love drama but good written drama this bordeline with just soap , every single chapter had sutil mistakes i could not everlooked

Characters: so even in mangas females leads dont deverse to have a great characte develpoment right ? Being sucessful and fufilled, if they are married and give free therapy to a broken guy is enought right ? Dont get me wrong, rei was ... a victim from circunstances and everything that happen to him make sense, but he was so selfish and volume 8 and 9 he did horrible things, yes he make a huge change but i dont like how they hanlde their heroine arc .... she was a painter i wishnthey could use that and show how many pictures she draws and how succesull she becamewith the correct help, and how herr paintings toouch so many hearts, idk,k think i was waiting too much for a shoujo manga from the 90s..... she end with the rich hot guy, isnt that the best.

For real so much wasted potential, this cpuld have been a masterpiece, but was average at best, i enjoyed it tho.... full into it, i guess is cuz i like kdramas and they likefull soap opera , but this is a manga so i was waiting for something else, even ore with that make 10s

Story: this has no pay off, as simple as that, not building, no mystery no nothing ... is void, is a souless attemp as to portray greek tragedies in manga but without impact

Why this has so many good reviews ???? I keep reading cuz i thouth that i would get a huge plot twist at the end that would make this soup opera worth

Characters: oh men here is the biggest issue, they are so 1D that hurts, not even the main character is worth wasting the time i spend reading

Art: mediocre, same face for all the "beautiful woman" and over the top ugly ... faces for the rest, so you could tell who was beautiful and who was not , they didnt even show the whole fsce of the monster ... lame.

Overall:this manga is like bad fanfiction, they dont show they tell you HOW TO FEEL
Example : they dont show the whole acting yet you see characters saying "this is intense, this is the best adting i even feel" .... nah it doesnt WORK THAT WAY, yoh have to show us why is impactfull, but sisnce mangaka can not show us thorth her lame art she has to write it

I seen shonens with better delivery of emotions , and that says a lot !!!!

Overall; dont waste your time, this is not a tragedy, this is not a good drama and finally this has barely any psychological aspect besides bullying someone looks, this story could be told in 50 chapters maximum, the way this story was unncesary streatch is annoying.

I end it and not drop it cuz of the good reviews, i still believed this would give me a great plot twist at tye end or good motives , nah .. all plain and boring.

Avoid this