If you liked
Shinseiki Evangelion
|
...then you might like
Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
|
In short, both these series take a staple genre of anime that many people grew up on and turn that genre on its head and inside-out in dark and convoluted ways.
If you liked
Yuru Yuri
|
...then you might like
Kiniro Mosaic
|
These series are both fundamentally school-centric slice-of-life anime with a primary selling point being cute girls being cute and amusing. Both series also have the distinction of having some themes of romantic interest between their core cute girls, but it is to be noted that Yuru Yuri is to the point of Shoujo Ai, whereas Kiniro Mosaic has not achieved that status.
If you liked
Campione! Matsurowanu Kamigami to Kamigoroshi no Maou
|
...then you might like
Strike the Blood
|
Both these series are built around a male MC with exceptional, if not godlike, fantasy powers fighting off various enemies in their respective story arcs. Furthermore, both MCs fight with the aid of a Battle Harem and both perform intimate, but not purely lewd, acts with their harem members to give themselves a tactical advantage.