- Last Online1 hour ago
- GenderMale
- BirthdayFeb 19, 2003
- LocationGeorgia Tbilisi
- JoinedApr 30, 2022
Also Available at
RSS Feeds
|
![]()
Apr 9, 2025
I was genuinely surprised to see that this manga has around 12 reviews — and all of them are overwhelmingly positive. So I guess I’ll be the first to break the trend with a negative take. I’ll keep it short too, because, honestly, there’s not much to say — and I’ve never understood people who write long essays about stories like this. To me, that’s just overanalyzing something that doesn’t need it.
Let’s start with the premise: sure, it exists and it’s… fine, I guess? But at the same time, it’s tiring. I’ve read many mangas with similar vibes, and they all start to blend together.
...
There’s nothing fresh or truly gripping here. Some scenes are presented in such a shallow or clumsy way that they almost feel random. The story tries really hard to seem deep and mysterious — but it just feels like it’s pretending, not earning it.
The characters? Meh. They’re okay, I guess, but totally forgettable. I’ll probably forget their names and faces in a few days. The ending did leave a slight emotional impact, sure — but that feeling fades fast. There’s just nothing in this manga that stuck with me, nothing that felt meaningful or worth remembering.
Maybe I’m being a bit harsh with my 3/10 rating, but that’s just how I rate things. Others might enjoy it more, or call it a "hidden gem" just to look deep or different — but to me, there’s nothing special here. I’d even say it’s like a story that wants to be wrapped in beautiful packaging — except here, even the wrapping paper is missing.
Final score: 3/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 3
What did you think of this review?
Nice
 0
Love it
 0
Funny
 0
Confusing
 0
Well-written
 0
Creative
 0Show all
![]()
Mar 30, 2025
After the first season, I couldn’t quite understand why this anime is so popular. And honestly, even after watching the second season, I still don’t get it. However, I did enjoy Season 2 more than the first.
I don’t think this will be a long review since there isn’t much to talk about. In short, Solo Leveling is all about epic fights, aura farming, and pure hype. If you enjoy well-animated action, then this anime is definitely for you. But personally, I prefer a deep storyline, well-developed characters, and engaging dialogues. Unfortunately, none of that is present here.
That being said, I still had a good time
...
watching it—I wasn’t bored. Sometimes, it’s nice to just turn off your brain and enjoy some well-animated fighting sequences.
I’d give this season a low 7/10 and will be waiting for the next one. Hopefully, in Season 3, the story will improve a bit alongside the action, making it a more engaging experience overall.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 13, 2025
Banquet of the Golden Witch is the part where Umineko truly expands, becoming more global in scope and, for many, more dynamic compared to the previous chapters. That said, if I’m being honest, I still like the first part more than the third.
If the biggest issue with the second part was its slow pacing and heavy repetition of the first chapter’s plot, then the third entry is a major improvement in that regard. It stands out significantly, introducing new details, new characters, and further developing the existing ones. For example one of the strengths is how it explores the relationships between the parents, though ironically,
...
this is also a weak point—but only in the manga version. I feel that the manga cut a lot of interesting and emotional moments from these interactions.
That being said, the manga does have its advantages. The way it depicts horror elements is fantastic—the grotesque expressions and eerie atmosphere come across much stronger visually. But overall, like the previous parts, the manga still falls short of the visual novel. Yes, it's faster-paced, but come on—Umineko was always meant to be long. Its length was part of its identity. Unlike something like One Piece, where the slow pacing sometimes feels like unnecessary filler, Umineko’s lengthy dialogues made the story feel alive and immersive. Unfortunately, the manga loses this effect, and even the climax of the third chapter felt far more emotional in the visual novel.
And here we return to the same issue that plagued the first two manga adaptations: some moments are too heavily cut, making them lose emotional weight. There’s also another problem, which is a bit tricky to explain, but I’ll try—this part of the manga somehow feels both slow-paced and rushed at the same time. By "rushed," I mean the excessive trimming of important scenes. But by "slow-paced," I mean that despite all these cuts, there’s still a lot of unnecessary fluff that drags on. It’s an odd balance—if they were going to cut down the VN’s slow, dialogues, then they should have gone all the way. Otherwise, it just feels uneven. For those who’ve already read the VN, the manga will still feel like a shortened version. And for those who started with the manga because they didn’t want to read the VN, leaving some moments long while cutting others doesn’t make much sense. Hopefully, you get what I mean.
That said, I still enjoyed this part—it was fun to reread and notice things I missed the first time. The story became even more engaging, the characters were further developed, and their relationships deepened. Even though the atmosphere suffered a little because of these changes, overall, it was still an incredible experience. Final rating: 9/10.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 6, 2025
I finally watched the anime that almost everyone seems to praise, and I have one question: Why? What exactly did people find so captivating about it? I even went through some positive reviews, hoping to understand the hype, but honestly... I still don’t get it.
Let’s break it down.
Story & Plot:
Mediocre at best. Sure, there are some mystery elements, but they’re executed in such a dull and uninspired way that I couldn’t bring myself to care. If you’re watching this anime for the "mysteries," trust me—there are far better options out there. The pacing is also sluggish. Maybe some people enjoy slow-burn storytelling, but for me,
...
those 24 episodes felt like they dragged on forever. At times, it was just outright boring.
Characters:
Meh. Mao Mao is somewhat interesting, but nothing exceptional. Jinshi? Same thing. And the rest of the supporting cast? Generic, nothing you haven’t seen in a hundred other shows.
The Good Stuff:
Visually, it’s quite nice—pleasant art, solid direction. Some dialogues were engaging and even emotional. There were a few episodes that genuinely drew me in… but in the end, the whole anime felt like one massive filler arc. That’s the best way I can describe my experience.
I know fans will probably just laugh this review off. Whatever. If someone can actually explain to me what makes this anime so great, I’m all ears. But as it stands, it’s just an average, forgettable series. Will I watch Season 2? Probably.
My final rating for season one 5/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 28, 2025
The Gods Lie is a beautiful story for a single-volume manga. I won’t go into too much detail—after all, why read a long review for such a short manga?
This story touches on themes of lies, understanding, and love. It has a wonderfully immersive atmosphere that makes you feel warm inside while reading. The characters are likable, the artwork is great, and it flows effortlessly.
The only downside is that it’s too short. I would have gladly read a few more vols with these characters. But perhaps its brevity is what makes it so special. (oh and boobie roobing panel like WTF was that)
My final rating: a
...
high 7/10 (keep in mind that for short stories, a 7 is a very high rating from me).
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Feb 22, 2025
4 AM. I just finished watching the movie, and without much thought, I immediately want to write down my impressions. I've been wanting to watch this film for a long time—since last year, actually—since everyone praised it so much. And today, I finally decided to do it. Why? I'm not sure. Maybe it was a certain special vibe—after all, it started snowing in my city today, and believe me, in Tbilisi, that’s a rare occurrence. But let’s get to the point.
I'll start with my expectations. I thought, "Yeah, I’m about to watch a good anime movie. I’ll probably like it, but it won’t be anything
...
special." After all, I’m usually skeptical about anime films and haven’t watched many of them. But let me say this—A Silent Voice exceeded all my expectations. While watching, I felt something warm and familiar, like I was experiencing something close and dear to me. In some ways, it even reminded me of Your Lie in April (one of my all-time favorite anime, and not just anime). The vibe was similar. Throughout the film, I went through a range of emotions—anger, joy, sorrow—all packed into just two hours. And yes, a good film should make you feel different emotions, but this one felt more real. It was as if I had fully immersed myself in the story and become a part of it, feeling exactly what Ishida felt.
Returning to the film, I also really liked the themes of friendship, understanding, and self-worth—especially the moment when Ishida asks himself, Did i deserve this happines? But perhaps the main theme is redemption, and again, it was done beautifully. As I write this review, I realize how well everything in this anime fits together. Every theme, every moment complements the others, creating such a wonderful story.
Now, about the characters.
Let’s start with Ishida—he is incredibly well-written, and most importantly, he feels alive. As I mentioned earlier, I truly felt his emotions. One scene I want to highlight is the bridge scene (where he was right, by the way). I understood and felt every single word he said in that moment. His redemption, his conclusion, his interactions with other characters—all of it was well-crafted and logical.
As for Nishimiya, I think her pain and emotions were portrayed well. However, she struck me as the kind of character who serves mainly as a supporting role for the protagonist. And that’s not necessarily a bad thing. (I hope you understand what I mean—if not, we can discuss this point.)
I liked Nishimiya, she was enjoyble character, she had some vibe.
I also liked the friendship theme with Nagatsuka, but as a character, he was just fine. Nothing particularly outstanding. And finally, I want to sum up my thoughts on Kawai in one sentence: Indifference is a greater sin than hatred.
Now, let’s talk about Ueno Naoka.
Can someone please explain to me why she has 700+ favorites on MAL?! I know, I know—everything is subjective, but how can anyone like her? (And don’t come at me with "She’s actually a deep character, you just didn’t understand her.") She’s just a dumb brat, that’s all.
This words would much her perfectly "I hate the way that you walk, the way that you talk, I hate the way that you dress."
Every time she appeared on screen, I just felt anger. And yes, there are perfectly horrible characters (like Furudo Erika from Umineko, if you know what I mean), but Ueno? She’s just Trash.
Now, about the ending.
Before writing this part, I read some reviews, and I saw that many people didn’t like it. Some even consider it open-ended. Personally, I think it was somewhat predictable, but that doesn’t make it bad. It’s logical, fitting, and well-executed for this kind of story. I’m more than satisfied with how it wrapped up.
To balance things out, I’ll mention a few flaws—some moments felt overly exaggerated, and in certain parts, there was unnecessary drama. But overall, I didn’t notice any major weaknesses. Sure, maybe not everything was executed at the highest level, but I didn’t see any serious downsides either.
One last thing I want to praise is the beautiful animation, the amount of symbolism, and the music, which was also great. Basically, all the key aspects were done well.
Final thoughts
I really enjoyed A Silent Voice. It exceeded my expectations, and I didn’t think it would resonate with me so much. If I compare it only to movies (not just anime films, but movies in general), it would rank pretty high for me.
As for my final rating—if I’m giving it only as a film (since in general, the film format appeals to me less than other media forms), my rating is 8/10.
So, if you’ve read my review (I doubt anyone will : ) ) and still haven’t decided whether to watch A Silent Voice or not—I highly recommend it. In exchange for two hours of your time, you’ll get a warm and heartfelt story. That’s how I’d sum up this anime.
Thanks for reading! <3
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Feb 20, 2025
Just a Horror Story or Something More?
I started reading Pigpen because it came highly recommended, and I expected something more than just a typical horror story. And honestly? It delivered. This isn’t just about scares—it’s a deep psychological story that keeps you hooked until the very end.
Right from the first chapters, you’re thrown into the story and introduced to the main setting. It seems like you have a general idea of where things are going, but trust me—you don’t.
What Stood Out the Most?
First off, the storytelling. The plot never lets you get too comfortable—every few chapters, you get new clues that make you rethink everything,
...
while at the same time, things only get more confusing. It keeps you engaged, making you want to piece everything together.
Also the athmosphere, The eerie, unsettling vibe is enhanced by a good art style that perfectly captures the madness unfolding around the protagonist. The sense of isolation, paranoia, and growing unease is done so well—it really pulls you into the story.
The Protagonist
Without spoiling anything, I’d say the main character is interesting and keeps you invested. However, I feel like he could have been explored on a deeper emotional level. More internal monologues and raw emotions would’ve made him more interesting.
The Side Cast
Even though the side characters aren’t incredibly deep, they’re still fascinating to observe. Their interactions with the protagonist keep you guessing—who they are, what they want, and what role they play in the bigger picture. They are normal for those type of story.
The Mystery – The Best Part
The strongest aspect of Pigpen is definitely its mystery. Every chapter drops new details, making you constantly rethink everything. And the best part? It all makes sense. The reveals are logical yet unexpected, and the way everything unfolds is really well done.
The ending, in particular, surprised me. It was handled in a way that felt satisfying and well thought out—no frustrating loose ends or disappointments.
Final Thoughts
I really enjoyed Pigpen, and I’d definitely recommend it. If you love psychological and horror storys, you’ll love this. Even if you’re more neutral towards this genre (like me), it’s still worth checking out—it keeps you engaged and thinking the whole way through.
That said, I wouldn’t rate it an 8/10. The first half pulled me in more than the second, even though the second half was crucial for the story’s resolution. I think it came down to pacing—some parts felt a bit stretched out, while others felt rushed. But despite that, it’s definitely worth reading.
Final Score: A Strong 7/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Feb 13, 2025
It has become somewhat of a tradition for me to start reviews by explaining how I came across this manga. A few months ago, I was buying some manga from an online store, and I came across this one. My brother also mentioned it, saying it’s probably nothing special, but it has good ratings and could be interesting since it’s short. So, we bought it, I started reading, and it turned out to be exactly what I expected — neither more nor less. It reminded me a bit of Horizon, but it was weaker in comparison.
The story follows two girls traveling through a post-apocalyptic world.
...
They encounter new things and move to new locations, often having conversations with each other. These dialogues are simple at first glance, but they’re actually really thought-provoking. The dialogues, and the story in general, seem pretty simple at first — just a regular adventure story — but as you move toward the end, you realize it’s much deeper than it seemed at first. I don’t want to spoil too much, but the final chapters really made me think and left a strong impact on me. The ending, in my opinion, is the most memorable and significant part of the story.
Yes, the story is deep and thought-provoking, but that’s why I’m rating it like this. I often encounter the same issues when reading classic literature. Sometimes, a work might excel in one or two aspects, such as the depth of the story or atmosphere, but lack in everything else. (I get that this could be the intended style or approach, but I’m not a fan of it.) That’s why when I read classics, I pick works like Dostoevsky’s, which can dive deep into human nature, reveal characters' complexities, and still keep the story, characters, and atmosphere at a high level. I’ve probably drifted from the topic, but I hope you get what I mean. In this manga, there were indeed some thought-provoking moments, and it made me reflect even after finishing it, but aside from that, it didn’t draw me in. The story and characters were okay — I understand that they had to be like that for this kind of story, but couldn’t the story and characters have been different, while keeping the same message?
I’ve already touched on the cons in the previous paragraph and the pros in the first one, but there’s one more positive I want to highlight: the atmosphere. The world was beautifully and interestingly drawn, and it really reflected the essence of the story.
At first, I was torn between saying I had “mixed feelings” or “recommending” it, but after thinking it through, I’ve decided to give it a Mixed Feelings. The story is short and simple, but it carries a unique charm. It’s the type of manga that doesn’t demand too much from you but still offers something meaningful. It’s a story that lingers in your thoughts, and while it may not leave a huge impact, it’s still worth the read if you're in the mood for something reflective and pleasant.
So, considering the pros and cons, I think my rating is pretty fair.
My final score for this work is 6/10.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Feb 10, 2025
I’ve finished reading the second part of the Umineko manga and will try to express my thoughts on it. As before, I’ll focus primarily on the manga itself—after all, this review is about the manga, not the visual novel. I'll briefly mention, though, that I consider the second arc (Turn of the Golden Witch) to be the weakest in the entire story and my least favorite.
Now, let’s talk about the manga. While reading this part, I didn’t encounter the same issues I had with the first volume. Some moments were improved, but overall, the adaptation didn’t impress me. There were many scenes that could have
...
been executed better. Emotional moments often felt too rushed, making it difficult to fully immerse myself in them.
The biggest disappointment was Maria’s Halloween scene—one of the most memorable moments of this arc. It could have been extended and made more emotional, but it felt too short. The banquet scene also didn’t leave much of an impact; it was too fast-paced, making it hard to fully appreciate. Additionally, I enjoyed the second game’s setup and mystery less than the first.
The reasons I believe the first part is far superior to the second are that the intrigue and mystery in the first arc were much stronger. Despite everything I’ve mentioned so far, the first part still carried more emotional depth. The atmosphere of uncertainty, the sense of not knowing anything, and the haunting environment created in the first part all added unforgettable emotional weight. Also, the characters and their relationships felt deeper. I especially liked the interactions and the emotional depth of the family members, particularly Kinzo’s children. The tension was higher, too, in the first part—it had a much more intense atmosphere, and I found it more gripping overall.
Now, moving on to what I liked. The beginning of the arc was engaging, and the backstories of the characters were well-presented. Unlike the novel, where reading 3–4 hours of backstory right after the intense first episode could feel a bit tedious, here it didn’t drag as much. Another strong point was the foreshadowing—there are many subtle hints that will pay off later in the story. The reveal of Beatrice was also well-executed; she now takes center stage, and her presence feels much stronger.
It might be a short review, but I’m too lazy to write a lot. I’ll write more in detail about the other parts in the next reviews.
Final Thoughts
The second part of Umineko is weaker than the first and often considered the weakest in the series. Many readers drop the story at this point, but I wouldn’t recommend that—because from the third arc onward, you won’t be able to take your eyes off this incredible story.
Even though this arc (especially in the manga adaptation) isn’t my favorite, I still appreciate it. Re-reading it was interesting, and I noticed many small details that I overlooked the first time. An objective rating for this part of the manga would probably be a bit lower, but personally, I’d give it:
8/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Feb 4, 2025
I’ll start by saying that this manga had been sitting on my bookshelf for a long time. I always thought it would be just another typical story. However, it actually exceeded my expectations—I was expecting something far less engaging.
Now, it might seem strange that I’m giving it a relatively low score while still praising and recommending it, so let me explain. Since this is a short manga, I’ll try to keep my review just as concise.
The main reason for my score is simply the length—only two volumes. Personally, I’m not a big fan of short stories, so for me, a 6/10 for a short manga
...
is actually a very good rating. The concept was interesting, and even though some moments were quite predictable, I still found myself completely engaged and unable to stop reading.
The protagonist wasn’t particularly unique, and I’d say the same about Rita. Her backstory was fairly standard, yet somehow, she remained compelling. The dynamic between Rita and Keiji was well portrayed—warm and emotional—despite the limited time spent on their relationship. It still managed to leave an emotional impact on me. The ending also stood out; it was unexpected in some ways and carried real emotional weight.
I also want to highlight how easy it was to read—the pacing was smooth, and the art style was great. That said, I did find some of the fight scenes a bit hard to follow, as it wasn’t always clear what was happening.
In short, if you’re looking for a well-crafted story that you can finish in one night, this manga is a perfect choice.
Final rating: 6/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|
