- Last OnlineJun 30, 2024 11:22 AM
- BirthdayMar 9, 1990
- LocationFrance
- JoinedAug 21, 2008
No friend yet.
RSS Feeds
|
![]()
May 18, 2020
As a big fan of JRPGs, Star Ocean: the Second Story (PS1) was one of my personal favorites back in my younger days, and still remains, as of today, a game I very much like. So, when I found out, in 2005 or 2006, that an anime adaptation had been made, I was excited to watch it. So, yeah, here's a confession: my judgment will probably be biased by sheer nostalgia, as I feel towards those characters, this world and this story, an affection that probably goes deeper than it should – if I were to watch it for the first time today.
Still, I
...
will try to be fair.
When the original game had us choose between two slightly different points of views, of the two main protagonists, Rena or Claude, the anime clearly opts for the latter. As a young ensign of the space Federation fleet, assigned to the Calnus spaceship, whose admiral is none other than his dad, Claude C. Kenny, while exploring a devastated planet, finds himself shot off by a mysterious device to the faraway world of Expel. There, he'll meet Rena Lanford, a local girl, and save her from a dire monster with a single bursting shot of his laser-gun. But such technology exceeds what's known on those underdeveloped lands; and the prodigious laser-beam will quickly be seen as the "sword of light" of a hero whose coming was foretold by the church...
I find such premise to be rather interesting, although it’s not really original. A lost boy tries to make his way through an unknown world, with the help of a young girl he met; it’s basically that. The main purpose of such narrative doesn’t lie into complex connections between religious beliefs and advanced technology – for example. It’s an adventure; a pretty standard one, where a bunch of characters unite to fight evil monsters and save the world from its demise, with sword techniques, constant traveling, slight romance and comic relief – really, basic stuff. Still, it’s not so bad; pace feels overall pretty decent, some characters are funny, like Ashton and his barrel fetish, and the story remains faithful to the original…
Well, at least, for the most part. Despite all the affection I still get for this anime series, the six/seven last episodes still are a slight source of disappointment. Not because it drifts apart from the initial game story, but because the pace slows down quite a bit, because characters are really just too many, but most of all, because it ends on a cliffhanger, which is even more frustrating that no sequel was ever produced – all 26 episodes of this show only cover the events taking place during the first segment of the game, its first disk out of two. There’s still a way to get next part by playing the original game, sure, but still… that’s a bummer.
In this regard, it would be hard recommending this to people who’d want to engage in a full, finished story. But if you enjoyed the original product, or if you like anime adaptations of videogames, or even the adventure genre in its whole, you may have a fairly good time watching Star Ocean EX, as I still think it’s good enough of its own to deserve some attention.
Also, it’s old, but, you know, nostalgia…
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
 0
Love it
 0
Funny
 0
Confusing
 0
Well-written
 0
Creative
 0Show all
![]()
Oct 18, 2017
* Preliminary note : this is a "not-used-to-write-in-english" review.
ERASED's synopsis reading gave me a lot of expectations, so naturally, I started watching with extreme caution so that it would spare me another disappointment. It kind of did, because I feel like this was an interesting watch. Though, it may not be for good reasons.
I don't consider the writing to be good; in fact, there are many flaws that drew me away from the characters and story. First of all, the main character is kind of dumb, always taking weird decisions like saving someone from a serial-killer but not really trying to catch him or investigate
...
the case with its time-traveler advantage - which I hoped he would do, for it may have been a slightly better use of the time-traveling mechanic (IMHO, of course). I don't really understand his logic, he's like "if I manage to prevent this girl to be killed, I win !" but kind of overlooks the fact that the murderer could still just kill another one as long as he remains free. That bugged me.
Second of all, the mystery about the killer's identity felt a little dull. There are many false leads that demonstrate a desire to confuse the issue, but these end up being clumsy and not really convincing. In one instance, near the end, it even accentuates the unlikely naivety of the main character, and discredits the villain by making him pass for an amateur while we're being said he's bright, meticulous and calculating.
Finally, it's full of good intentions, which of course is not a problem in itself. But by desperately trying to generate suspense and care for the characters, not to forget all the vertuous morale to dispense, the author leaves it up to cliches and convenient plot-tools, which ends up into an overall bland and predictable story about friendship and loneliness. It may be inspiring in some way, of course, as giving a hand to isolated people can hardly be perceived as something to be condemned, although I still found it to be waaaay too idealistic to be plausible.
Anyway, it was fine to watch as a flawed anime experience. I read here and there that the ending was kind of disappointing, but actually, I'm really more frustrated about the beginning of it. Because the first episode was promising, along with the basic time-traveling mechanics, and, what do you know ?, even the main character seemed rather sympathetic to me.
Such a waste.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|
