This is an animanga that was so close to perfection due it being nearly flawless and one that makes me watch or read others just to keep chasing that same high. This score is for those particular animanga that I consider to be the best the medium has to offer.
There are very few animanga that receive this score.
9/10 Close to a masterpiece
This is an animanga that was so nearly there but did not blow me away like a 10/10 would, when an animanga receives a 9 it means I consider it to be one of my favourites.
8/10 Great
This is an animanga that I really enjoyed but does not quite reach the highs of a 9/10 whether that be very minor flaws or just personal enjoyment. Some 8/10s are favourites of mine such as in the case of Kaiji.
7/10 Very Good
This is an animanga that was very enjoyable and was a worth while experience but had too many issues (flaws or personal enjoyment) for it to be an 8/10.
6/10 Good
This is an animanga that I would consider to be a solid decent experience, it had a lot of flaws but these are still outweighed by the positives.
5/10 Average
This is an animanga that I felt was 'mid', some parts were enjoyable but its flaws were prevalent.
4/10 Subpar
This is an animanga that had too many flaws for it to be considered average however what was presented was not an entirely bad experience.
3/10 Bad
This is an animanga that I suffered to sit through due to its execution and many flaws, there are a very few moments that are enjoyable.
2/10 Awful
This is an animanga that had at a push one or maybe even two redeeming qualities, these are truly hard to sit through and are near as bad as it gets when it comes to the medium.
1/10 Bottom of the barrel
This is an animanga that was truly tragic to sit through, no redeeming qualities and can be at times unforgettable in the worst ways imaginable.
Welcome to Critics and Connoisseurs. As the club went through some rather big changes just a few hours ago we don't yet have an updated FAQ, while you will find a lot of explanations in the threads themselves please feel free to ask me anything that is unclear. We encourage all our members to be active in our You Decide, Spotlight Forums and other activities. Here is a link to our Old Spotlights to help you familiarize yourself with titles that have been nominated in the past. Again Welcome!
All Comments (3) Comments