Back to Marinari's Profile Marinari's Profile

This is a biased review.

10/10

Thicc tomboy TSF girl reuniting with a childhood friend (to lover perhaps??) thicc tomboy waifu

Strong premise, thicc tomboy waifu (husbando??)

Do you love thicc tomboy waifu who has a gender dysphoria? This may be it.

... Writing: I was also a bit surprised that the writing is actually pretty decent too, it's not as cheesy as most ecchi mangas. This may be ecchi but it has side plots that carry weight into the story which makes it feel grounded and often times realistic.

Characters: I especially love the characters, though not as complex it is a pretty well written more than just surface level personality you usually see so that's a bit surprising since we already got thicc tomboy waifu to compensate for all of that.

I don't know what made me in love with this manga (aside from the thicc tomboy waifu), if I have to say it it's probably the genre itself, TSF it's more than just turning into a really hot chick. It's getting to know you as a person, what you really are, the weight you have to carry now that you're hot and thicc and what they think of you now.

A universal concept that all men even Aristotle seem to ponder upon, the struggles of having to get used to it, the reality that others will have the wrong impression of you, the challenges, the awkward tension, upholding that new image, meeting expectations, the acceptance, it's a hero's journey. In a genre. Isn't that cracked?

But in the end, yeah it's gotta be the hot thicc tomboy. Forget compensation this is the whole cake. I would just read the whole thing even if the writing's gone to shite as long as she's still there I'm all in.

At the start I do believe one thing it lacks was the weight aspect of it, there is no consequence. When something happens we can just rely on the alien girl to solve it, but it quickly subverts it when it reveals that nothing and not everything can just be fixed. And so we are now forced into understanding that their actions do have consequences. I like that.

I am into girls. Humans love control, there's a sub genre in horror about controlling monsters and our inability to do so, we project our emotions to it despite understanding fully that we are not in control of ... it. We hope that we are, but the uncertainty is what makes it exciting; which makes us love it. Similar to the Stockholm syndrome, is it really love?

I think the whole control is kind of a theme here, I think. Class rep tries to control one thing from another, trying to make things normal again but every time he thinks he can fix something, something else happens. I think I like what the author is doing, clearly it isn't just absurd things thrown at you just because it's interesting, every plot device has its purpose and it connects back to the previous one.

I like this manga, The alien girl is a perfect character for this theme of "control", her whole character is uncertain and she has power to kill us off, we cling on the hope that she doesn't kill us because she's in love with us, until that belief is quickly shot down because our human values aren't aligned with her alien values and her concept of love is different from ours and death is nonexistent. Is it really love?

I also like the writing of emotions here, a lot of emotional roller coasters. Big fan.

In conclusion, you don't know what's going on but you're curios to see what's going to happen, also hot alien chick kitaa ikuyooo. I think it's very important that you need to have a thing for the alien chick here and occasionally a yandere girl. It what keeps it going for me personally.

Shiki and my willing suspension of disbelief.

The whole premise of Shiki was that Shikis and Humans can't coexist, I'd argue with. Yes, they can co exist, because we have 3 seperate characters who have found ways to make it possible, even the main character themself brought up the idea of having ways for them to co exist with each other.

The issue is, Shikis and humans CAN, co exist. They can live with each other. Noone needs to get killed aside from the first act of converting them into shikis but afterwards anything that you do is considered a crime. But other than that, they ... all can live in harmony. We have over, what? 100 people in the village, they can donate blood and shikis can just drink it from them.

The only true evil was that cat ear guy, he's the one that's forcing other shikis to abide by his commands, but after he's gone Shikis are just like any other human but they eat blood instead. They could literally co exist. Another thing, it's unreasonable especially for the doctor for his method of fixing the problem is by killing the shikis.

In my opinion I feel like the characters, their actions, everything feels forced. It's like everything from their deaths to their reasons feels forced for the plot. MCs use ridiculous method to solve a delicate problem, ignores obvious problem-solving steps, hurts story's believability, characters act dumb/ inhuman? in order to provide exposition, advance the plot, etc. (why are they all so heartless?), events feel staged and phony, and etc.

There's only two authors that I always remember whenever the words horny & thriller come to mind & it's these two. I just can't believe that they've managed to collab with each other to create this manga?! I'm honestly excited to see what's in for us in the future...

There's a reason why I often think that these two are the same people, I for one am a big fan of Prison School I came in expecting just your average basic ecchi series but my expectations were subverted & we dove into a more psychologically thrilling ride than we previously thought (the ending broke me), then ... coincidentally after I finished reading Prison School, I craved for another one of those ecchi+thriller genres in a manga, so I was looking for one, browsing the web; trying all sorts of manga but the only manga that stands out among the rest was Bokutachi ga Yarimashita.

So I read it, it started out light then it slowly got more complex, there's theme of hot babes & thrilling suspense. Honestly I never knew I wanted thriller & ecchi so much but after reading these two writers, but now I realized I WANT MORE! I never thought these two genres would work with each other! It's hilarious. But anyways... I love the feeling of being aroused by the possibility of the main character being able to lose his virginity while at the same time a suspension build up from trying to befriend a bully who's on the edge of wanting to kill himself; whilst being pursued by your kleptomaniac friend who's actually a psychopath.

In conclusion...

These two are a match made in heaven. I love Akira Hiramoto for being able to integrate thriller & ecchi but if there was anyone who can one up his game that would be Muneyuki Kaneshiro himself. Akira is more light hearted in his thriller genre but his art style is amazeballs, I love it. While Muneyuki Kaneshiro is a man who will dip his toes into the most degenerate questionable moral philosophies ever & still make you pop a boner, I love both of them.

I love Akira Hiramoto writing style...

The story itself takes on the popular trope of switching bodies, but the way Akira handles this trope (knowing his writing style) is unique through his own style of writing. The art style is boner popping & fits for a story that's made by the legend himself. As always, big fan of his ever semi-realistic art style.

Akira mostly writes his characters to subvert the audience expectations, but he's not doing it only because he could. A bad writer would subvert a trope for no reason at all, but a good writer knows his punchline & when to subvert it.

He's ... really good at combining horny & suspension. This manga might not appeal to the general audience but if you're a fan of Akira Hiramoto's writing style, you'd love this manga! I think it's very important to realize this but HE IS DAMN GOOD at STIMULATING you & making you ANXIOUS, it often even overlaps with one another. Akira is probably one of the few writers I love who I often adored not because of the plot, the characters, the setting, or anything like that. I like his stories only because of his ability to write them. His writing style is unique. In the end, it's not Fullmetal or Attack on Titan level for sure, but his writing style is to die for.

...

The beginning was a bit dry but I'd say be patient cuz you'd love what's in store. One scene you'd be popping a boner the next scene you'd be holding your breath, this is fun.

If you're looking for a manga that has a lot of boner popping & breath taking, any Akira's work will do.