Back to Karffebon's Profile Karffebon's Profile

This manga is a nice little story, due to the lack of chapters the characters don't get a lot of development, it was going in a very nice direction but I believe the author opted for an unexpected ending. The ending in my opinion kills the series due to the lack of development that path received, so he should have kept the expected route. Even having an ending I didn't like a lot, this is not a bad manga, nice little romance to read in your free time.

I can give this manga a 7, a good romance manga by Adachi.

This manga is dated, so it's not for everyone, romance mangas get dated easily, so it's something to consider before reading.

Story - 5 - This manga drags a little more than it should have, and lacks a real story, it's all about the characters relations, i like this style of manga but some people may not. It has a conclusive and good ending that will no disapoint any reader.

Art - 7 - I can't call it dated since Adachis recent mangas have the same art he had in 1980, the backgrounds are beautiful ... as always, the caracters are simple designed and easy to read, not an ugly style but not really beautiful characters.

Characters - 8 - This manga is all about the characters, they are fun to see, they make this manga fun to read, but you will get tired from the side characters after some time and it is when you feel the manga has started to drag, but you have to finish it for the ending.

Enjoyment -8 - It was a nice read, 95 chapters is more than enough for this story, it has some unessary chapters but i would recommend this manga.

Overall it's a solid 7, fun read, not a great manga, the average romance comedy that is hard to find today. I recommend it if you are out of better options in the romance comedy area.

Out of Adachi's 3 big baseball mangas, H2 is the worst.

The flaws include bad pacing, and an unrewarding ending after beign dragged over 300 chapters. This is a tricky read, like some of Adachi's other works it has a drop of quallity near the end, and obviously some very bad humor and filler pages.

The pros are that the side characters are nice and had some nice back story, even if they are forgetten after their respective arcs.

But the biggest flaw is that you feel like Hiro and Hideo don't evolve a lot during the manga, you don't see a real development, Hikari and Haruka you ... can see some development, but Hikari is just near the end.

So the final judgement is 6, by no means this is a bad manga, but when you have Cross Game this is not a read i would recommend.

I will detail every aspect of the review and then make a brief conclusion.

Story 8/10 - It was pretty decent, original concept, it was a perfect romance manga till half of the series, where it started to be too much rushed, the author decided to cancel this work, I don't know why, but it was just a shame.

Art 9/10 - Beautiful art, the characters are very well drawn, the scenary is great, no complaints about the art, it is really great, sometimes it is not very well detailed but it is great.

Character 8/10 - The fact that the manga was so short and got ... cancelled, it could at least have 10 chapters more to finish this propelly, it was a waste to not use the full potential these characters and story had.

Enjoyment 8/10 - This manga has funny parts, good romance parts, it is a great read till the last chapters.

Conclusion - The manga was left with an unsatisfying ending but it is still above average and worth reading, the final 5 chapters or so are badly made, but at least it has an ending, it sure is a open and rushing ending but whatever, it is a bad ending because we feel like one character is totally left aside in the end, even tough the main character appeared to have very strong feelings for that character, but it can't be helped since the manga was cancelled.

This is a great ending, to one of the most enjoyable anime out there, the story is not the most complex, but it is simple and different, and it follows the previous seasons very well. This season had a lot of romance too, and some nice action scenes
Zero no tsukaima F concludes the story in a great way and like I said it may not have the best plot or characters, but it is very enjoyable and fun to watch, the mix of comedy romance action and fan service is very good, if you don't like ecchi it might annoy you, but if you got ... over to the last season then it won't be a problem.
Story(9/10) - Great, has a good ammount of romance, it has a great ending and yu get to see character development.
Art (9/10) - pretty good, beautiful characters, good animation but not perfect, some details on animation make it a 9 instead of a 10.
Sound (8/10) - Great voice acting, the music is good but not great.
Character (9/10) - Even though they are cliche, they feel unique in some way or another, and each character gets some development even though it focuses on the two main characters, we get to see more about the princess and other characters, wich is pretty nice. Even tough louise may get boring at sometimes, she is still very enjoyable.
Overall (9/10) - One of the most enjoyable anime to watch ever, even tough it may be cliche at some times, it will be enjoyable and fun to watch till the very end, and the beautiful romance between the two main characters is a plus.