Back to Huntermynameuf's Profile Huntermynameuf's Profile

SPOILERS ALERT
(Contain spoilers for some of the arc that would've been in the anime adaptation or OVA)



Anime adaptation hate bcs it skip tons of Manga chapters my opinion:

I've been following horimiya manga for two year's already, and I think, there's no point for this anime to adapted all of the Manga story, since hori & miyamura story itself already finished a long time ago.

Because, the rest of the Manga story mostly focused on the slice of life comedy, that didn't have any sort of heavy drama and such things, so yeah that's pretty much it.
...
Even the sport festival arc that I wanted to get animated, is also some of the slice of life comedy arc, Which I think it won't fit to the Horimiya Anime adaptation vibe, that gave us some of manly, drama & adult vibes throughout the anime.
I mean, it has some of the comedy vibe in it, but, if we look back to it, is this anime supposed to be a comedy anime??

The first couple of arc do have a lot of drama vibes that mainly focused on building the story around the main character itself, that of course miyamura story, which I think it's great.

I think if they decided to adapt all of the Manga and make it have a lot of season in it, then, where is the HoriMiya story??, I mean, they already have a happy end(dating), so what was the point to adapt the rest of it??

Like for example, we wanted to see some of the lovely dovey cuty scenes between hori and miyamura, but, it doesn't have any effect to the main story itself. Like, there's no such drama or obstacle that's left for HoriMiya story, it's already done in a happy way, and the rest was supposed to be just a normal slice of life comedy story that's just doesn't have any effect to Hori & Miyamura itself.

Like, the rest of the story is only they're highschool life with some comedy in it, and it didn't even focused on HoriMiya itself, so I think IF, they adapted all of the Manga into an anime and have a lot of season, I'm pretty much sure, u guys will hate the rest of the season after HoriMiya story itself is not focused in hori and miyamura story (after Hori and Miyamura dating).
So yeah that's my opinion about Horimiya anime adaptation that's getting a lot of hate for skipping the Manga chapter's, now move on to the review.

Story 8, I like the way they decide to adapt the story and skipped some of unnecessary part in the manga, and also I like the way they decided to mostly focused on Hori and Miyamura story rather than the other character, even though they still animated some of the lest important scene in some of the episodes in it.

Art 9, I like it, there's not much, just I like it.

Sound 7, not that amazing but not bad either.

Character 8, lot of Chara development in it, and I like it.

Enjoyment 8, I do enjoy this anime as an anime watcher and also Manga readers too, so yeah that's it.

Overall 8, it could've been a 9/10, but there's some of the scene that's just unnecessary but they still added into this anime which is make me give it a 8/10.

I will review it.


It so fuckin GOOD, the pace is solid, the story is solid, the jokes is funny, the fighting is amazing, definitely recommended :D

story 10, It's just satisfaction, it has a good pace, a great buildup for some shit that's bouta be fire af.

art 9, not gonna lie it do has some great art bruh, especially the fight.

sound 9, it was on point bruh.
...
character 10, i do love a lot of gintama character, and there's a lot of thing's that made me love gintama chara more in this season.

enjoyment 10, i do enjoy this anime ngl.

overall 10, totally recommended :D

i do enjoy read this manga, i mean i like the way that this manga turns out from an mc being a simp, but he's also a genius in another way, i do find this manga satisfying to read and also quietly emotional at some part because since i was a child my family always went to the hospital a lot of time even until now for some private reason, and also i kinda like the way that they decided to tell us as a reader a lot of complicated things in medical way that of course i dont understand a lot of it, but ... i still like it...

Story 8, a solid emotional ride when it comes to taking care of patients, but in another part also some kind of romcom vibes was there.

art 8, of course man, if u managed to get a manga adaptation of ur own stories then it should be a good art style right?, well there's a lot fan service in this manga that wasn't necessary, but nvm it's good.

character 8, i like the mc that in another way he's a simp, but in another way he's a fuckin genius dude, i do like the main heroine chara too, she has the vibe that tells me that she won't give up, and i kinda like that.

enjoyment 9, i don't know why but i do have some satisfying feels when reading this manga, and that's just great.

overall 8, i do like this manga, i hope it will get anime adaptation later :D

Well how do i start it, first thing first, no spoilers, this is my first idol anime and i didn't expected to be like this, it has a pretty much decent story that is predictable and yet even though it was predictable i was never expecting that this anime will be that great...

for the story i give it 8, because like i said before this anime has a predictable storyline but still executed perfectly that makes me feel like an idiot for thinking that this will be a boring anime.

the art i give it 8, i do like the art, but not that much.

the sound ... i give it a solid 8, well i do like the sfx tho, nothing that special but still satisfying to hear.

the character i give it a 7, i do like some of the chara like the manager boy and mana-san, but for some reason i couldn't get attached to any of the idol member chara here (maybe bcs i don't really like idol in generals) but yeah that's it.

the enjoyment i give it a 8.5, i do really enjoy this anime from the first episode, the only think that i didn't enjoy prolly the part where the idol thing is started, but beside that i do really enjoy this anime.

overall i give it a solid 8, because i did enjoy the story the drama thats just great and makes me a lil bit sad :D