Back to Fabelisator's Profile Fabelisator's Profile

I do have to say upfront, if you come from Rent a girlfriend, this one is imho much better.
The MC at least isn't room temp IQ + Stalker and the girls aren't extremely oblivious.
The plot moves along each chapter and something actually happens on screen.

The girls are incredibly bland though. Like... trope to the max. Kuudere, Tsundere, Ara Aradere, Smartdere and Sportsdere.
And if you think of a specific character now, you know all there is to know of the 5 girls.
At least they have cute designs, are drawn decently well and actually have a meaningful changing wardrobe.

IF you want to read a ... very simple dumbed down Harem with cute Girls it's worth a read.
IF you want good writing, decent characters and a well put together drama it isn't.
It's on a level with Quintuplets, Oreimo and Girlfriend Girlfriend, which puts it above the likes of Rent a girlfriend... but far from Bunny girl senpai, Golden Time or Saekano.

Don't look at the rating, its one of the best P*rnhwa out there.
Art is 11/10 total waifus.
Bodies you will never see IRL but you can see them here.

MC is a Chad. More Chad than any Harem Protagonist in any Animanga you've ever seen. Even more than Domestic na Kanojo.
Plot isn't "he got isekaied into fantasy Haremland and gets laid 24/7"

No, he is just a guy that got Lucky in the best kind of educational System.
Finding the perfect Woman, and tripping into the even more perfect Woman afterwards.
It's funny, sad and romantic. It grows on you really quickly.
...
Comedy is a 8/10 very good at times, but no mouth open laughing in front of your Computer.
Fapability is 10/10, not too much so that it hurts your PP and you'll rip your skin off, but just enough to read Daily.
Readability is Peak. Art does not make the Dialogue go to waste, in fact the Dialogue is very good for a P*rnhwa and I really like it that way.
Characters are 8/10, Best Friend is hillarious, first side Chick is Great, both Sensei are top 10 Manhwa Waifu Material.

Best one I've read so far.
Keep it a secret from your Mother is the new recent Peace from Noah (The Artist and Author) and it's almost as good.
Go read both, you won't be disappointed.

Spoiler free on top, Spoiler stuff comes later.
This Anime has a certain Slice of Life appeal to it that Hajimete no Gal, Oreimo,Oregairu and Golden Time also try to create to appeal to the viewer.
This is not a Mind free Hentai adaptation for Television like Eromanga Sensei.
This appeals to a person that felt unrequited love on a deep emotional Level.
This Anime made me watch it through the night, and listen to Angel Beats songs. Didn't make me go all sad, but it made me go cry at least.

It made me think about a 19 yo Girl I talked to at a Party, she was crying ... cause of her low self esteem, and the fact that her best friend is very attractive, and gets run down by boys. But she always get's to be the 2nd choice.
You have a certain similarity here that instantly brought me back to that conversation.

Me personally, a boy that grew up with a lot of problematic relationships, can understand the problems that protagonist faces in here. The Rui stuff is relatable, the Momo stuff was Bold and Hina is just sad truth.
Incest is another thing, but that was an unneccesary writing mistake to make the situation easier to understand to the viewer, it wouldve taken 24 ep just to explain it otherwise.

Spoiler:
Rui really shows the most problematic Girl problem I've encountered in my life. Beeing Socially awkward, get a boy to sleep with you without feelings, fall for him later on because you can't get him out of your head.
I've seen that countless times, I felled victim to that a few times.
This isn't easy, this is hard. The Anime shows how she tries to stick to her feelings all the way through, that it is not a joke to feel this love, even though it wasn't needed, wasn't intended and wasn't wanted.

Momo beeing an abused depressive kid, that continues to be easy to stick to her sanity. Feeling love, feeling company and feeling Joy is easy if you pay for any of these with your Body if you happen to be an attractive Girl.
She show's how this works, after that has been shown she has been ignored too much, simple writing mistake. But the limitation of 12 episodes also made it impossible to give a side harem girl more then 2 episodes of attention. So they just cut everything afterwards, cant say no to that.

Hina... this is hard, she beeing the only adult in an dilemma caused by teenies. She really had it the hardest, trying to be responsible, trying to impress and trying to shoulder everything that occurs in her ''Family''.
Beeing into a Married guy... this is also a very problematic thing when you are beeing a grown up. I was into a few girls that had Boyfriends, or just simply had Kids already and were living in a happy marriage. And the biggest thing is that you get the kind of adoration back, cause you just meet someone you needed in your life, without knowing all along.
Having to shoulder disappointing her Sister, and the boy that shows her so much affection. Dndecisiveness caused by his youthfulness and his first time feeling something like this make this unrequited love even more painful.

I had a great time watching this, feeling Joy, whining like a spoiled 14 year old again, and thinking about the love of my youth.
Thinking about my Friends and what I would've done if one of my Love's would become my Sister by accident.
Writing mistakes make it impossible to let this be an Masterpiece, but Fullmetal Alchemist had 4 times the amount of time to create a story, so who is to blame? The Manga seems to be much longer, I guess I'll take a look at that ^^
(Sry for my English btw. and thank you for reading through <3 much love)