- Last OnlineFeb 19, 11:30 AM
- GenderMale
- BirthdaySep 9, 1987
- LocationDenmark
- JoinedAug 27, 2024
No friend yet.
RSS Feeds
|
Feb 8, 2025
Pros:
- The historical, medical and mystery tags are the defining content feature, with drama, comedy and romance being the supporting content. This create a kinda unique combo, that allows the mangaka to avoid the fantasy and high school tropes, while still maintaining some romcom drama.
- The art is pretty well done, but the narrative is what makes this stand out. The character motivations, the interrelationships, the dramatic plots, twists and reveals, the foreshadowing and hints, the background knowledge. All these elements are implemented with a care and meticulousness, that makes the mangas narrative stand out as quite remarkable.
- The long chapters makes the story pacing
...
less predictable, which is great.
Cons:
- I have very little negative to say about this manga, so it will mostly be nitpicking.
- Our main character is written as, and consistently show, above average deduction skill and knowledge. She is wise in most regards, even fragile court intrigue that would humble the average manga protagonist. She does make mistake, but she is very good at using her insight to calculate peoples intentions. All this is good! But when it comes to romance directed at herself, she is as clueless as the weebs reading this. It is comedicly entertaining, but it does seem out of character for her.
- I considered mentioning that the romance is "Komi Can't Communicate" slow, but it didn't really annoy me at all, since the rest was great.
- Historical (and fantasy/isekai) genres are responsible for introducing the reader to the world's rules. This manga is good at that, but one (unspoiled) relationship with another you girl remains undefined for 30+ chapters before this is used to surprise the reader. In Inio Asano's Punpun, every earlier emitted detail hit me like a truck when revealed, due to the realistic nature of the setting. This punch is less severe in a historical manga, were the author chose not to define a relationship that we, the reader, couldn't predict.
Judgement:
- I loved every second, was glued to my seat and will reread it.
- I hope it finishes before 200 (long chapters), so it never becomes stale or repetitive.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 8, 2025
Pros:
- The mangaka Flowerchilds art is gorgous to look at.
- This is a yuri and evolves power dynamics in relationships, but it also have softness, space and acceptance, which most toxic yuri fails at.
- Wholesome, likeable characters, along with some bastards to keep the plot rolling.
- The plot starts out really basic, but with the establishing of relationship and introductions of further characters, the narrative becomes pretty intense.
Cons:
- I do not have much negative to say here. I believe the mangaka can make this story a classic if they get the right amount of volumes and chapters to work with.
- One character has connection
...
to the entertainment industry, which introduces elements common in idol mangas. So far this haven't been a bad thing, but I expect it to play a bigger impact later on, which might feel repetitive for the avid readers.
Judgement:
- I gave it a tentative 7/10 on the first 12 chapters, but this can easily end abrubtly or run dry down to a 5/10 or go to the moon and become finish with bravado on 9/10. I am positively optimistic at the moment.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 8, 2025
Pros:
- This is short, wholesome romance, without perverted content.
- It does not go deep into relationship issues, or even drag the romance out in much regard. Instead the story focuses primarily around Machida, the main protagonist. Machida is not on some quest to get a girlfriend, instead he is succeeding in staying true to kind nature and treat people around him with love, acknowledgement and an open heart.
Cons:
- This is short, wholesome romance, without perverted content...
- I adore the core belief of being kind without expecting anything in return, but I also find it naive and unrelateable. Kindness as an acknowledged trait is as far-fetched
...
to me as some fantastical shounen or even some dumb hentai plots. Still enjoyable though.
Judgement:
- I consider it slop, but in the high end of slop, that I might read again or even the first volume off. I recommend it.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 31, 2025
Judgement:
- This is pretty good!
- Im giving 6/10 for now (4 volumes - 21 chapters) but I can see it go to both 7/10 if it keeps pace and don't overstays its welcome.
- Recommended!
Pros:
- This is wholesome yuri, involving consensual BDSM between girls, that might be a little too young for my taste. It isn't erotic or hentai though, just ecchi, and the BDSM is (so far) of the lighter variety, which makes the questionable age a little easier to morally handle.
- The manga introduces the BDSM elements in a deliberate slow and descriptive way, so even a complete BDSM noob like myself can
...
differentiate between the BD, DS and SM plays and learn a little a long the way.
- I can appreciate a wholesome lovestory with consent between the involved girls, as it breaks from the stereotype of toxic yuri. I love me some toxic yuri, but the alternative is also quite nice. The BDSM elements in the story so far, has reflected this, by being less extreme than what we usually read. Less extreme doesn't mean more boring in this examble, but far more believeable as to how school aged girls would get into it.
- Every manga having the incest tag will forever be fighting the yikes vibes. Luckily, this manga doesn't have the loli tag or sexual violence tag and is only ecchi, so it feels less like pdf bait than incest tags normally do. Without spoiling the story, I would even argue that the incest tag on this manga so far is pretty innocent, as it appears to only cover rather light BDSM plays and not actual sexual acts.
- The humor is decent and the characters likable. Even the adults in the serie is pretty funny.
Cons:
- See that incest tag? Yeah... The incest depicted might only cover rather light BDSM plays and not actual sexual acts, but no matter how you slice it, this particular BDSM has sexual undertones and involves a character descriped as underage. I know lines on a paper isn't actual people and I know no kids suffered during this creation, but you should know that the manga depicts BDSM with sexual undertones, involving a drawn minors.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 29, 2025
Pros
- The characters are pleasant to look at, without being too ecchi or loli.
- The topic of a split personality illness is interesting.
- I found the maid character funny.
- The story is short and doesn't get dragged out.
Cons
- This manga takes the easy solution to the very serious topic of a split personality mental illness: It makes it fun, cute and troublesome. That is okay! In reality, it is life shattering to deal with such a situation, but it can help breaks taboos and start a conversation to make a little fun of it in a light way. In the later half of the story,
...
the narrative changes and try to make and emotional impact around the mental illness, which forces the reader to take the problem serious, something the manga itself hasn't done, only to do a 180 turn at the very abrudt ending, making the potentially emotional impact fall completely flat. I am left confused as to what the mangaka's intention was.
- The maid had a very curve ball finale, that I didn't see coming or like, due to a lack of foreshadowing and reason.
- The backgrounds were pretty lacking overall.
Judgement
- I gave it 4/10, but might lower it to 3/10 later. The manga can service some romcom slop starved weeb out there, but I honestly won't recommend this, as even the slop romcoms have better to offer than this.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 21, 2025
Pros:
- The twists and turns in the plot was engaging and kept the story fresh. Every time I thought I had everything figured out and could predict where the story was heading, it found a way to surprise me.
- The characters are well drawn and the backgrounds are not bad.
- The story resolves around character motivations and development, which is a great storytelling device.
- Two of the characters are delightfully broken people, who has chosen ridiculus coping strategies. These characters hard carries this manga, with the MC as an enabler and supporter, caught in the crosshairs.
Cons:
- The main character is not unlikeable, but she is...
...
being dramatic about her live? The 2 important sidecharacters have very real issues for their behavior and overshadow the MC in every regard. And I must reiterate, that Yuki/Yoshiki isn't a badly designed character, she just pales in comparison to Kaito and Mikaka.
- This story was flirting with the traumatic tag at points, but shied away from making it more central. Instead we got more drama, which is also fine, but I wonder how hard the author could have gone on the trauma.
- Sometimes, the twists and turns in the plot made some character motivations appear very obscure. That is realistic, but not always as engaging to follow.
- The ending deserved more closure for one character, that was left unresolved.
Summary:
I was engaged and liked plenty of elements, but I will never reread this. It is good enough to be apart of the slob tier mangas (4/10 - 6/10) so someone will like this a lot more than me and others will be completely uninterested. I am giving it a mixed recommendation. It isn't high art, but it is still engaging. Try it for 5-8 chapters. If you don't like that, then this isn't for you.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 15, 2025
This review will not address the concept of lolicon culture.
Pros:
- The characters all have funny and serious sides to them.
- I won't say the art is good, but it is definitely passable.
- The mangaka is willing to take a detour off on some tangent for a chapter or two, which could have led to a varied experience had it been executed a more humoristicly.
Cons:
- Some of the character traits becomes repetitive fast.
- The plot twists often fall flat.
...
- The story relies on continuesly introducing new cute lolis, thus somewhat resembling a half-assed harem in terms of story flow and progression pacing.
Judgement:
- 4/10. Not as funny as I had hoped it would be. Still room to improve since I dropped it on chapter 39 (the current translation limit). I was pretty bored and unengaged for most of the story, so I cannot recommend it, even for loli-slob.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 14, 2025
Pros:
- The characters are drawn well and expressive.
- The characters struggling with being upfront about their feelings and making bad choices are realistic, which creates relatability for the reader.
- The manga avoids some of the most repetitive rom-com tropes, which is refreshing.
- The double chapters (40+ pages) mean that the chapters content aren't predictable most of the time.
Cons:
- The backgrounds are lacking in quality or simply just not drawn.
- The characters are pretty unlikeable, probably due to how relatable they are. This affects the story in broad strokes, making progress in relationships lack meaning, as the characters continuesly sabotages their own interests. This in turn,
...
makes the pacing really weird, as no neither readers nor characters really have a clear understanding of why nothing is happening.
- This is a non-ecchi, wholesome romance/drama, which is fine. But it avoids getting the relationships going, so the story is a constant state of "Who will get together with who" instead of showing the good times and the struggles of being young, in love and in a relationship. This feels cheap, since the story is pretty weak overall.
Judgement:
- 4/10 & not recommended. If you want wholesome romance or drama, there are better choices, even amongst the slob.
- This is only 49 chapters, but it felt slow and boring. I struggled to not drop this and wont remember it fondly or revisit it again later.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 1, 2025
This is in the non-toxic yuri department, which I can live with from time to time.
The title is atrociously bad, but the manga itself is fine.
Its a short one, so side characters take a backseat to the two leading girls.
We see some teasing, some homo culture introductions and then we have, get this: "A character, who is clearly a dom, who openly have a history of fucking minors, but she is only portrayed positively, funny and little bit scary." Good ol' Japan strikes again. What ever, it's drawings who cares.
I would put this in the slob category.
It is recommended, and
...
acceptable, but in no way, shape or form rememrable.
Fine little read.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Dec 30, 2024
Yes this is the much memed manga about revenge porn, that got an anime instead of a hentai, to everyone's confusion.
I am not appalled by the visuals, character motivations or content. I am not appalled about the loli girls getting raped and have their mind broken. I am however appalled, about how boring it all is.
This might be an isekai thing, but fantasy requires a cool world the reader can be immersed into. This manga has everything it needs to succeed, except that. The background art is fine or even good at places. The characters are drawn fine, despite some issues with distinguishing the
...
girls from each other and the male lead having a punchable face. Hell in some of the sex scenes I would even call the art good! But the storylines, the world building, the plot progression and the story's pacing feels like the mangaka would rather eat glue than waste his life on this.
Around chapter 49 I saw some impressive battle scenes, with excellent paneling and good movement. This should impact me, the reader, more. Some of the plot points and twist are cool enough, but overall it just feels like someone wanted to get paid and knew that weebs would swallow a horny harem fantasy isekai with shitty world building. I can’t say for sure, what it is that makes Redo of Healer feel flat. Maybe it would have helped, if we got introduced to the male lead and his promising qualities, before he became a revenge driven prick? He is going through a lot of character growth and he certainly has reasons to seek revenge, but he is still just extremely unlikeable. I don’t know man… I have rated this a 3/10, but I have NOT dropped it, because I want to understand how a horny fantasy manga with good drawings can be this uninspired.
I do not recommend this. Not because of the revenge porn and sex crimes depicted, but because it is all soooo boooooring.
Reviewer’s Rating: 3
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|