Back to Drewguardo's Profile Drewguardo's Profile

I am dyslexic, therefore there may be one or two spelling and grammar errors but ill try my best to keep them to a minimum.

I watched season 1 of Beaststar's and found it very enjoyable, probably a 8/10 so I was looking forward to the 2nd season. I wanted to see the show explore a world in which predators and prey live together in a uneasy collaboration where the massive power imbalance between carnivores and herbivores stokes civil unrest in a way that mirrors the real world to a certain extent. Additionally the characters that were introduced and built up were appealing and I ... wanted to see more of them especially the very unusual love interest Haru.

So in what ways does season 2 of Beaststars fail? (since you can see I only gave this season a 3/10)
It fails in almost every respect, the characters I found interesting have been destroyed, the world has been watered down and is completely contradictory and there is essentially no interesting social commentary.

This will be the end of the spoiler free section, I have explained very vaguely my problems with season 2, from here on out im going to get a lot more specific.

*SPOILERS*
Ok im not sure exactly where to start here so ill just start with the characters.

Legoshi is an introverted and mostly kind hearted wolf who has some seriously problematic urges and viewpoints, some of those originating from his carnivores instincts like the desire to essentially own Haru as property (and in doing so protect her) or just straight up consume her. he's kind of a stand in for the quite nice guy exemplifying toxic usually masculine behaviors. He was defiantly a flawed character but this wasn't necessarily a bad thing as it gave us a complex character who was trying to better himself. By the end of season 2 Legoshi is a selfish, self-consumed, toxic, aggressive introvert who doesn't care about anyone but himself and maybe Haru if she happens to be on screen at the time. He works out the identity of the murder and instead of turning him into the police, as any reasonable and moral person would have done, he instead confronts the killer which gets a innocent bystander involved putting someone other than himself in serious danger, he then keeps the murders identity hidden for weeks or possibly MONTHS for some reason without telling the police putting everyone in the school in danger and then finally he challenges him to a 1v1 which if he had lost would have allowed the killer to get away with it. He turns the gruesome murder of his friend into a selfish personal vendetta making everything about him, he obviously didn't respect his friend otherwise he would have contacted the police immediately. Additionally Legoshi plays with Juno's feeling at multiple points for some reason, he isnt ignorant of her feeling for him but he refuses to address them and asks things of her which are simply unfair taking her feelings into account. This character has been ruined which is a real issue as we see the world mostly through his eyes, this only exemplified the problems present which I will go into later.

Haru was a very interesting love interest, most love interests are innocent virgins who dote after the main protagonist and have no regrets, so usually there not really fully fleshed out people. Haru is a sexually promiscuous "slut" who has zero interest in the main character till near the end of season 1 and has feelings for someone else while also being funny, confident and driven, she gets bullied by classmates and is defiantly at the bottom of the social hierarchy. She is a person and a genuinely likable one at that, being herself instead of who people would like her to be. By season 2 she has attained the powers of invisibility and is actually in every scene at least that's what i assume has happened because the only other explanation is that she is essentially not in season 2. she probably gets about 2min of run time and the time for which she is on screen she is a shell of her former self, not as bad as Legoshi tho. Her fear of Legoshi is gone, *poof* its nowhere to be seen which is very convenient, very shallow and unsatisfactory. Her love for Louis, gone apparently. Hows she coping with being kidnapped and almost eaten, very well almost as if it never happened. Like wtf this isn't how Haru would have acted, she has instead been shoehorned into more of a traditional love interest to suit the direction of the show and that really sucks.

Louis is one of the only characters that remains mostly unchanged during season 2 but even then he gets completely destroyed in the final episode. Louis is one of the few herbivores in this school with a position of power, he gives off the illusion of physical strength but his real power is that of the pen which he himself realizes and hates about himself perceiving it as weakness. Louis has a need to feel superior to offset his perception of himself as a weak herbivore. He's a manipulator who is lacking strongly in morals. quite a interesting character to watch. by season 2 hes the same character, he become the head of a criminal syndicate (how this happens is really stupid and disappointing btw), manages to level the playing field between herbivores and carnivores by obtaining a gun, even goes so far as to consume meat to feel superior. this is the case till the final episode where the power of friendship triumphs, he sees the error of his ways, comes to Legoshi's aid... who he should hate. He took his love interest away and knocked him out in front of the school demonstrating his weakness to all of them humiliating him. his character collapses in the final episode but at least he lasted till then, additionally the whole arch where he was a mob boss amounted to nothing and was therefore a huge waste of time.

The final character I can be bothered to even mention is Juno who resembles the typical love interest much more then Haru but who Legoshi isn't interested in. She was a great addition in season 1 however is season 2 she also gained the power of invisibility because she is essentially not in season 2. shes in season 2 more then Haru but that's not saying much. Her character is mostly the same but her drive to become the beaststar has disappeared for some reason. Mehh on Juno shes kind of there but not really.

Any other character from the show is ether one dimensional or simply isn't a person and therefore isn't worth mentioning which btw is a lot of them. There's no excuse for this, other anime like "my hero academia" are able to flesh out a much larger cast in a much shorter span of time.

I feel as though i also have to make specific mention to all the lost potential of the show like the numerous different things that are introduced and then dropped never to be mentioned again:
- The Beaststar plotline, mentioned once at the start never mentioned again. Nor the fact that the person who catches the killer would be made the Beaststar. (which is stupid btw, a school would NEVER agree to this)
- The segregation of the school, mentioned a few times, everyone gives VERY basic one sided opinions on the fact they oppose it, never mentioned again. it would have been nice to hear from the opinion of someone supported it. (other then Juno who's reasoning is shallow also)
- Haru and Legoshi's relationship, dropped almost entirely, barely mentioned.
- cosmo the stripper, dropped never to be seen again.
- Jacks strained friendship towards Legoshi, dropped after 2min.

I also need to mention all the really stupid things that happen:
- Kai ripping of kibi's had coming to such a simple resolution. kibi doesn't have any fear of kai/ carnivores like he should to, herbivores are needlessly understanding considering that could have been them.
- Riz being the killer was insanely obvious.
- Bills inter species relationship with a herbivore called Els, mentioned but never expand on much like a whole bunch of hinted inter species relationships which go no where.
- Rokume is introduced and then never mentioned ever again, only used as quest giver for the protagonist and is therefore a stupid addition.
- pina is a stupid character, he isnt deep hes just dumb.
- The mob boss underling being in the exact right place at the exact right time for no conceivable reason other then plot convenience to shoot Agata saving Louis's life.
- Legoshi not being recognized and killed by the mob immediately, taken for dinner and then left alone with the mob's boss. How insanely stupid can a criminal organization be?

As you can see im very disappointed with this season, I felt a strong compulsion to write this review as I believe people are giving it way too much credit. But in summery this season destroyed everything the previous season built up, its messy, there were clearly too many chefs in the kitchen when this was being made, there are too many plot-lines and most get dropped minutes after being introduced, previous characters have been destroyed and turned into something else. Its really quite bad.

death note is a show that is often compared to a game of cat and mouse, except you never know who is the cat or mouse at any one time which leads to a rather gripping show and honestly would be worth scores of 9 or 10... however, there is on MASSIVE problem that many fans simply overlook or maybe they are just blinded by episodes 1-25 because after that the show, which is standing proudly on the peak of anime greatness, comes crashing down into the abyss. this is the problem i have with people giving this show 9 and 10 because episodes 26-37 ... are just torture, no spoilers but they really ruin things in episode 25. because of these 12 episodes iv awarded a score of 7/10 for the story because 1-25 is AMAZING but this review includes those cursed 12 episodes so.... tough.

the animation is nothing spectacular, it what i would call average honestly however this show dose not require impressive visuals so this isn't really important. no complaints from me really so i give it a score of 7/10

the sound is one of the high points of the anime, i LOVE the first into. its amazing, there are some other tracks scattered throughout the anime which were not bad ether. id recommend dub over sub however be ready to pull your hair out whenever misa misa is around. 8/10

oh the characters... how i am torn on this one. we will start with the good: L is one of my favorite characters of all time, he's on my top 10 list on my profile, he is amazing ... saying anymore will release a bubble of rage from inside me for spoiler filled reasons so we wont go into that here.
Ryuk is an awesome addition and helps make light bearable for a while and even manages to make him a good interesting character at the start till he lost it.
rem is kind of interesting however NOTHING can make misa bearable, trust me.
ok now we are going to start with the bad:
light is one of the most unlikable, psychotic and delusional main protagonists iv ever seen. he has the ability to make some situation dull with his constantly frowning face and average appearance. his personality is non existent all that left is a unlikable psychopath with genius level intelligence which is his only saving grace. i think my opinion is a very rare one so you may want to judge him for yourself.
misa is unbearable, dumb, blind and infuriating she is probably in my top 5 most hated characters of all time list. cant stand her.
nate and mihael are trying to fill a gap they couldn't hope to fill in a million years and nate only really does anything HUGE via luck!!! they are just bad.
with all this in mind i give it a 6/10 because there are a lot of character i didn't mention and they were all ether good or ok.

like i said at the start episodes 1-25 were superb!!! light was a good interesting protagonist until episode 26 were he becomes unbearable as well as the introductions of nate and mihael who are just bad. but episodes 1-25 are so good that i grant it an overall score of 7/10 and a recommendation to ONLY watch episodes 1-25 otherwise you will be cursed with the same anger as i am cursed with.

I cant help but feel perplexed about the things people are saying about this anime and its relatively low scores. i understand that some anime aren't for everyone however its usually for understandable reasons that lovers of the series overlook or it might be down to personal preference.
However in this case its for reasons like terrible characters which is simply not true at all and i have to seriously question what there meaning of the word "terrible" is, as it isn't the same meaning that the rest of the world uses.

the story and premise is summed up in one word... Excellent, seriously i may ... compare this anime to Gurren Lagann a lot because they are similar in a lot of ways. the premise is fresh and new. its based in an extremely interesting world filled with corruption, slightly similar to Fullmetal Alchemist. the introduction of imperial arms really intrigues me and adds so much to the combat as there is lots of strategy behind almost all the battles, its like watching a extremely interesting game of chess where you don't know who will win as the enemy will die but so will our main and supporting characters. no one is safe, this show has guts to kill of some extremely important characters and keep them dead. (like gurren lagann) the story in the manga and the anime deviates however the story in the anime is still awesome and i wouldn't have known if some hadn't of told me. 8/10

there isn't much to say about the art except the fighting scenes are beautifully done and almost a 10 however i decided to give it a 9 when compared to shows like attack on titan and hellsing ultimate.

the music was pretty good however there wasn't any stand out tracks like blumenkranz from kill la kill so i gave it an 7/10

the characters are, with out a doubt, the BEST part of this anime. all the character are extremely well developed with interesting back story's apart for a couple of exceptions like Lubbock and Chelsea who you don't really care for. the main protagonist is awesome and has a lot of development (like gurren lagann) the romance is ether a hit or a miss however it has grown on me greatly and i ended up enjoying it.
characters like Akame, Tutsumi, Leone, Bulat. Esdeath (omg i wanted to put down so many more names) really make this show awsome, 3 of the characters from this show are on my favorite characters list. 10/10 don't listen to the haters, the speak lies.

this is one of them shows that you have to switch your brain off to enjoy (like gurren lagann) its all out insanity and amazing characters are the main selling points of this anime. i wasn't expecting much when i decided to watch this anime and omg was i surprised. 8/10

i highly recommend this anime. 8/10