Back to Cinnayanny's Profile Cinnayanny's Profile

School Kill is a very strange manga that lasts 9 pages and it is a trip. It's hard to understand what's happening, but I'll sum it up as best as I can. Warning: there will be 'spoilers' in this review, if you really want to read 9 pages.

Story: 3
It's a love story about a nerd band boy who's in love with a popular girl, but she's dating a handsome guy. During a performance, the band protagonist (who is wearing nothing but what looks to be saggy underwear and a headband where it's words change) sees this girl's boyfriend, so he proceeds to run at him, ... guitar in hand, and swing a blow. Before it hits, this guy roundhouse kicks him in the face. Then we get a panty shot. It sounds strange and rushed because you can't explain a story in 9 pages goddamnit. Sorry, I mean "because it is".

Art: 4
The art is pleasant to look at, and the panty shot was detailed. I didn't want to see it but hey at least I didn't think "this is amateur".

Character: 1
It's a silent film without the sound, designs without names, nothing to make any of the characters worth a shred of your memory. You'll forget them in a second.

Enjoyment: 3
It got ridiculous, and I was hoping for an actual kill, but it was mostly a waste of my time.

Overall: 3
It's boring, only read it if you want a nice panty shot and roundhouse kick scene.

Well, this manga certainly is an experience. It's not bad, but it's not stellar either. It's about a magical boy and his fear of women, and it was a small read. Give it a shot if you like fanservice

Story: 4
The main point of this was clearly the fanservice, however, the plot was pretty cool. The author didn't make the story bad with all the fanservice, and it was just fun. It seems like it wasn't meant to be taken seriously. I would love for somebody to write a serious version of it, as its premise is interesting.

Art: 7
The art was erotic and attractive. The breasts ... and buttocks felt natural for the girls, they weren't oversized. Plus, the drawing was smooth, the character designs were nice to look at, and it wasn't over-detailed, but it definitely had attention to details. It would be a 6, but the breasts looked like breasts instead of airbags, so it's a 7.

Characters: 3
They didn't feel too much like characters, as to be expected by an 11 chapter manga. There wasn't enough time to really get attached, especially when their boobs and ass are being shoved in our faces.

Enjoyment: 5
It certainly was a read. It wasn't garbage or painful, but it wasn't entertaining either. It was just "meh".

Overall: 6
It's a good series if you like staring at boobs and ass. If ecchi isn't your style, then this probably isn't for you.

Before writing this review, I sat in my chair for 5 minutes chanting "Oh I have to review this shit pile". That's how much I hate this thing. It wasn't worth reading what there is and I want that time back, it's so awful. It's legit just someone's murder fetish. Note that this review contains spoilers for chapters 20 - 26 and that they're not censored or anything. I'm extremely sorry.

Story: 1
Revenge stories are something I enjoy when you understand why the protagonist wants revenge. I would say spend at least a volume on setting up the awful happenings that lead to revenge. Basically, the ... more extreme the revenge, the more time should be spent on why they want such terrible things. This manga gives a single chapter and expects us to go along with it. It makes the protagonist look immoral with how little we get to see. I became more invested in a shopkeeper's story and that was only there for what, a page?

Art: 2
It's extremely mediocre, nothing special. For something like this, it makes everything feel slightly off considering how distraught the characters are. Plus, there's too much fanservice. I've read Keijo, and it was really fun. But not this. There are just so many nude and lewd girls that it feels more like cheap hentai than a mind-bending manga that's supposed to make you question everything. I did not need to see a gigantic black spiky dildo.

Characters: 1
The main character is a Gary stu who is perfectly justified in the mass genocide and horrible atrocities he commits against innocent towns. In case he seems like a total villain, don't worry, this manga has the solution of instead of using the protagonist's horrid deeds to compare him to the bad guys and show how he's becoming what he hates and give a relatively interesting comparison, let's just make the bad guys even worse! See the sword hero? She's a rapist now. That makes her horrible cannibalism and rape justified. Fantastic. Plus, his harem is just a sex club.
Don't get me started on the bad guys, they seem bad for the sake of being bad rather than interesting immoral characters. Plus, everyone who doesn't have some positive relationship with the protagonist, his harem, or his village is pure evil unless they're not fully human.

Enjoyment: 1
This was literal torture to read. The disgusting fetishism, the horrid characters, and no elements I was promised. This sucked so much.

Overall: 1
Please do not read this unless you like mindless murder porn. I got so angry I want to create a fantasy world base. And I probably will.

Ange Vierge, the show that's based off a card game I've never heard of. It's got it all, bathhouse scenes where half the screen is censored by beams of light, bland fight sequences, plotholes, and plenty of yuri action. The A-drivers gain barely anything from supporting the Progress, why not just leave? Also, Saya was pretty much an ass in the first couple of episodes. I should actually review this, but it was so mediocre, and that's my least favourite kind of anime.

Story: 1
The story existed. It was as generic as can be. Basic "Oh weird black bad guy with no explained motive wants to ... destroy worlds because yes." It's been used a lot of times, I know. However, what makes this one so bad is its execution. The way each character and scenario is brought out really gives no emotion to the viewer, as it's a character-driven story and we were only just introduced to these characters. There isn't enough time to get attached, and the characters weren't interesting enough to get into. Plus, all exposition is either done before a bland fight scene, or a scene where everyone is naked. That's what makes the story bad.

Art: 4
The art is at least pleasant on the eye, it's not anything special, but it does have some pretty cool character designs. However, in some distant shots, it's obvious the characters are drawn lazily. It's expected though. The worst part of it is that in a few closer shots, it looks like the character had not been drawn completely. This is apparent in the bathhouse sequences. Also, there are too many shots where we get a zoom-in of a character's lips.

Sound: 5
The voices are high pitched, but it's an all-girls cast. The opening theme, Love is MY RAIL, is relatively good. The ending theme is alright, nothing too special. However, Elel's crying is extremely annoying. It's ear-piercing. The rest of the sound wasn't special, mediocre at best.

Character: 2
The characters are bland, generic protagonist who is selfish but grows, big boobed fanservice girl, innocent child, lazy one, and emotionless one. Then there's their A-driver, who's a bland "tries to be friends but is lonely" archetype. None of the side characters are that interesting either, and their only saving point is their designs. They're at least cool to look at, but if that's the only good thing one can say, it's bad.

Enjoyment: 2
The only arc where I felt sad and connected with a character was when Elel had to stop complimenting Rafiel or whoever because she was getting jealous. If only one arc can bring any emotion out of me, and I get emotional pretty easily, you're doing something wrong.

Overall: 4
It's eye-catching, but not worth staying for. The story is character driven, and when the characters are bad, the story becomes bad.

Tenshi No Drop is an anime about lolis doing things, and eating sweets. That may sound cute and innocent, but this anime makes you want to scratch your eyeballs out with how creepy it is. I don't like this, but if you like cute girls doing erotic things and don't mind weird subcontexts, this might be for you.

Story: 1
Some girl who I forgot the name of joins a school with angels. An angel named 'Un' falls from the ceiling, and Botan stares straight at her privates. Rude. Then they eat her halo and give birth. While the jelly-looking angel eggs are cute, the way it's ... animated and sounds is just disturbing.

Art: 4
The art is pretty pleasant to look at if you saw a screenshot of one of the not-weird scenes. It's very moe-style and the character designs are pretty bland, but sometimes stick with you. Their dresses are very poofy and I want to wear one.

Sound: 2
The sounds just give a very creepy vibe and generally make the listener feel uncomfortable. The constant "poreporepore" gets pretty weird and the loli just sound like lolis.

Characters: 2
Their designs are bland but sometimes memorable, and their dresses are nice. Overall, they're pretty nice eye candy. Why are they ranked so low? Because their characters are extremely bland and forgettable. I understand that for something like this, characterisation isn't the most important, but their motives are generic. Un doesn't even feel like she has a personality.

Enjoyment: 1
It was an uncomfortable experience that makes me question why I ever put myself through this. It was 5 minutes, and I want them back.

Overall: 3
I didn't enjoy it, but maybe somebody did. Who knows.
Cinna, signing off~

It's a perfect one. For every mangaka, take notes on this manga, as it's what not to do when writing!
It's based off Disney's "High School Musical" and while I haven't seen the film, I believe we can both agree that this is the worst adaptation of the story you can get, and it doesn't follow the original premise!

This manga is about 10 pages long. You can knock it out in about a minute. But should you? I believe you shouldn't, and here's why.

Story: 1
There is no story, there are just characters talking and then it ends. The synopsis gives an interesting premise, but it's never ... explored. The 'story' may have been present, but smashing it all into a handful of pages makes it get lost with no real evolving plotline. Don't try and shove your plot into a few pages.

Art: 1
It's an extremely generic art style that has nothing that makes it stand out. Character designs are generic, the shading is mediocre, and it's overall just something you look at. The art of manga should have something that makes it stand out, like Sailor Moon with its classic character designs or Berserk and it's highly detailed backgrounds. Even mangas with art that makes you cringe are better, as at least it gives you an emotion. But not this.

Characters: 1
The only ideas you get of them is a page that explains the characters and their relationships. It feels a lot like something you would read in a doujin, not an official manga. Even then, it's vague and doesn't really help, as you still have no clue who these people are.

Enjoyment: 1
It was minute-long fodder, and not very good at all. It was a waste of my time. It just suddenly ended and I was caught off-guard, as I was hoping that the theories that it was only a dozen or so pages long were false, but alas.

Overall: 1
It's generic and has nothing interesting for anyone. It's best you don't even consider it, as I can never get back that minute of my life I wasted on this. If you're really that bored, give it a read, it'll entertain you for a minute or so.
Cinnayanny, signing off~