Back to Andoux3's Profile Andoux3's Profile

Let me start this by saying this is really one of the worst mangas I have read. Usually I don't mind the cliche and the cheesiness in Shoujo mangas but this one is really horrible. The plot is your typical good girl falling for bad boy story and I don't mind that again I have read a lot of shoujo mangas and Iv seen this type of story quite a bit but this manga sadly was so very horrible beyond horrible from plot to characters and well everything except for art. The girl Emi is by far the dumbest and most stupid girl character I ... seen in my whole experience of reading manga. she is very desperate for that one guy who is the biggest ass hole who really has nothing good about him only his looks. Emi fell in love with Takeshita based on ONLY his looks which proves she is not only dumb but shallow also what sane girl would confess her love to a guy who she just saw making out with a girl and on top of that agrees to go to a threesome date with him? and giving up her virginity for a guy who she doesn't know well on the first date who then LEFT HER right after to go to another girl yet she STILL loves him? this is too stupid and I am very disappointed with this because the same mangaka Watanabe Ayu did one of my personal favorites which is L-DK. and finally in the end I don't think Takeshita even fixed his ways and loved her only. I have a strong feeling that guy just kept on doing what he does. I wanted to give this an overall rating of 2 but I just couldn't giving it a 1 is too much too. Im usually not harsh on mangas but this was too much.

First of all I must say this is not a bad manga, It's just your typical Shoujo manga it can be easily predicatble. When I read the summary I remembered Aa! Itoshi no Banchou-sama and because I loved Aa! Itoshi no Banchou-sama I wanted a manga similar to it so I thought I should give this a try. Now one of the things I noticed personally is that I thought things were a bit rushed and some moments where like out of place and as I read the manga more I felt like it lost its main plot. they characters weren't that special also, the ... newest chapters didn't make sense for me because from what I know if a boy leaves a girl for a not so good reason she would cry her heart out but Sawa on the other hand cried a bit then everything was alright after her boyfriend who she dated for over a half year left her for again a not so good reason. she didn't even feel awaked around him or anything she acted as if they never dated. Also Ran never had a real love rival and I never considered his friend Kido as one because he never really tried to get Sawa only at one point he tried but it wasn't much and Sugishita doesn't have feelings for Sawa from what I seen so it was a bit lame.
It was not a good manga nor it was a dead horrible manga it was OK for me. something id read if I'm really bored and have nothing else to read.