Bungo

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

BUNGO, like many other promising manga, starts with a bang and then slowly fizzles out. This review will be spoiler-free.

The first eight volumes worth of chapters were tightly paced, with story beats that matched its real-world style of storytelling. The characters were engaging, and the interactions between the main cast felt rewarding to read. It held my interest in baseball despite not being a fan of the sport. What was most enjoyable though, was the dynamic between the four members of our main cast: Bungo, Noda, Makoto, and Hakamada.

**However** from around ch.85 onward, the story took a gradual but significant downward turn. Needlessly ... drawn out drama about team positions that lead to pacing issues. Additions to the main cast the worsened the bond and interactions between the main four. Bland and two-dimensional side-characters who don't do anything to drum up emotion. While it is easy to see where the author was going, every single one of these things was **executed poorly.** What makes this worse, is that all of these negatives crowd out the positives that made the first part of the manga so enjoyable. Multiple story arcs could have been cut in half and still had the same exact effect on the story. The author meandered for far too long, and lost the reader's interest.

BUNGO is a manga that will leave a sour taste in your mouth because it will always be a "what if." It does not fail quite as spectacularly as something like Food Wars did, but it fails all the same.

**After reading over 300 chapters, I feel like my time investment was wasted, and I cannot recommend BUNGO.**

This is my first review because this manga really doesn't get the love it deserves, Bungo while had an iffy start imo in the first 20 chapters or so where some events without any prior setup were used as backstories however as we go in deep to the baseball aspect it's absolutely fantastic. For now this has been the best baseball manga I've read. I would also not bother with comment section of illegal manga websites, this has a seinen tag and it means it, the most common complaint is at the time skip at chapter 88-90ish. While the timeskip was quite a shock and ... it did feel a bit jarring, at the same time it was also a very plausible situation which ended hyping Bungo development even better. This review is only for 122 chapters that have been translated and yes only 2 proper games have occured but keep in mind those 2 games have enough material to cover both Diaya no Ace's Act I and II (upto chapter 180ish) so in a way it has very efficient writing instead of kids using the term "it's draggin" on a match over and over again.

I feel I should prefix this by saying that I’m not a fan of baseball. I think it’s dull to spectate and, despite its prevalence in the medium, I don’t think it’s a great fit for the conventional sports manga formula. Due to the nature of the game, the only players who really receive focus in a match are the catcher, the pitcher, and any particularly notable batsmen. This can have the effect of making the world of the series feel a little small and insular, and it doesn’t feel like it explores the sport as best it could.

The reason I bring this up is ... because I think Bungo is a very pure example of how to make full use of a sport's strengths to tell an enjoyable story. While I did say that baseball is a poor fit for a conventional sports manga (where the focus is always on the team, the tournament and overcoming all odds together), it functions pretty well as a lens through which to tell a small-scale story about a few key characters and their relationships, and that’s exactly what Bungo does.

So far, Bungo is a relatively small-scale story. Its characters have big aspirations, but the driving force behind the story is definitely the interpersonal relationships of the core cast. I care far more about Bungo’s relationship with Noda than I do about his long-term goals as a player. This might be a turn-off to those who feel that "plot" should take priority above all else, but I actually think that not prioritising plot lends it a level of unpredictability that sports series sometimes lack. Because the relationships are front and centre, the sequence of events doesn't really have to conform to our expectations of a sports series. It can skip large portions of matches (important when portraying a sport like baseball), or even entire matches if it wants, because the matches aren’t as important to the story as the characters are. We’re only really shown what is necessary for the characters, and that results in a story with very little fat, which I think will serve the series well in the long run, as sports series are quite susceptible to bloating, especially as they start to get longer.

Despite being 118 chapters in, I still feel like Bungo is in its very early stages as a story, and that it could be taken in any number of ways from where it is now, so I am incredibly excited for whatever comes next.