14R

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

(I only read chapter 1 before dropping it)

Story:

Well you can get the feel of what's happening in the story is felt throughout the story, it was was all about the place. The plot wasn't very clear to what was happening somehow the characters to feel very distance and what they say always isn't very relevant or inspirational. The romance aspect of the manga I think is very distant.

Art:
This type of art is actually one of my favourites, I like works by this artist very much. Is not too cluttered but its not particularly 'beautiful' in any sense but its not horrid and over-girly. It ... feels lukewarm.

Characters:
There were only 3 real characters introduced. I felt the romance between two of the characters was very unexpressed. They didn't really have any tight bond that you would recognise as love.

Enjoyment:
I spent the entire one-shot confused. I didn't really understand what was going on at most parts but managed to piece it all together at the end. Though I still don't get the ending, at al.

Overall:
Its an okay manga, what can I say its nothing special.

overall i really liked this manga, my favorite one was the second story it was really good ;> i tried to find it as a separate manga but i forgot they were one-shots... anyways the art was decent and i just want to say that i actually thought that chapter 2 was gonna be teacherXstudent but guess not....
i think that at some point in one of the chapters in this manga there was one really confusing chapter but i forgot which one.. haha

oh well overall this manga is alright and its worth reading (at least read chapter 2)
i dont really know what else to ... say because im not writing this right after i finished the manga.

I've read all the chapters, and I could really say that I could actually give this an '8' or possibly a '9' if only the first story weren't in it...

Honestly, I agree with the other reviewer who dropped this manga because of the first story. It was really... horrible. The characters weren't explained very well, and at the end it's like "WTF? That's just it?" Heck, it didn't even bother to tell the readers why the guy liked the girl or if he really liked her. I'll give this a '3'

As for the second story, I think it has the best story out of all ... the others, although there's not much romance in it. The story's great but the characters were... just good (I thought there was a deep story behind the character but there's not...) I'll give this one a '9'.

The third story felt like it lacked something, like it needed a continuation. I could say that this story had the best main characters (or character, I didn't really like the other girl). And this has no romance in it either, although if there was a continuation of this there might be...(As one girl was named "Yuri"... What else could it mean?). I'll give it a '9' too.

The fourth story was... cute but expected. It's nothing like a masterpiece, but no where near bad. Just your normal shoujo one-shot. I'll give it an '8'.

The last story's really sweet. I thought it would be as cliche as the synopsis said, but it wasn't... Although it's nothing special. I'll give it an '8'.

Long story short, don't read the first story -unless you're okay with a 14 year old doing it, iykwim.