Sep 20, 2023
Dream Fossil is easily the most inconsistent manga collection I've read: in terms of quality, of tone, of subject matters, etc... And I think that's what makes this collection so good. You're witnessing first-hand an artist trying to discover his style, going from genre to genre, messing up a bit at the beginning, getting better and finally truly finding his voice. Even though some of the stories' quality vary wildly, it's captivating to read the origins of such an iconic artist.
The first few stories are, let's be honest, pretty bad. They're either cliche, underdevelopped or just all-around dull, with the two baseball stories being my
...
least favorite. However, I'd still suggest still reading the bad stories as they show Kon's rapid evolution. The rest of the collection is however mostly great. "Toriko" is a fun little dystopian story that, without spoiling anything, smartly explores one of Kon's most recurring themes. "Kidnappers" and "Beyond the Sun" are hilarious short stories that rely on increasingly far-fetched coincidences, not too dissimilar to Kon's Tokyo Godfathers. Talking of that movie, Joyful Bell was a clear inspiration for Tokyo Godfathers, being a heartwarming christmas story. But my personal highlight has got to be Waira, a gorgeously atmospheric tale about warring samurai clans getting picked off one by one by a mysterious force. If Millennium Actress somehow didn't convince you Satoshi Kon was a Kurosawa fan, this one will!
As for the art, aside from "Guests" and the aforementioned drop-dead gorgeous "Waira", the art is mostly nothing special: it's nice to look at and expressive, not bad at all, but it doesn't really do anything special to distinguish itself from its contemporaries. The stories can also be somewhat hard to follow, with character designs that are too similar or panels that feel somewhat disconnected (a problem I've had with Kon's other manga)
Despite these flaws and some of the bad stories, this is a captivating must-read for anybody interested in Satoshi Kon's works.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all