what’s up w the grain?

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

Blumarine210 said:

Unknown_Guy100 said:
The animation is ok...I mean i still think the anime will be good....but the animation is just mid....it could have been soo much better....

We've only one episode dude let's wait to see the main fights of this season.

You should watch second episode on netflix japan, no it doesn’t get better. I would even say the composition got even worse not by a lot though.

Confused_100Jan 12, 3:02 AM

Jan 12, 3:06 AM

#9

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to Confused_100

Blumarine210 said:

Unknown_Guy100 said:
The animation is ok...I mean i still think the anime will be good....but the animation is just mid....it could have been soo much better....

We've only one episode dude let's wait to see the main fights of this season.

You should watch second episode on netflix japan, no it doesn’t get better. I would even say the composition got even worse not by a lot though.

@Confused_100 Nah I think the second episode is still pretty good but it's a shame that they skipped chapters 2 and 3.Also I've read the manga as well and I think that TMS is doing a good job for now not amazing or anything but still a good adaptation.I've seen you being very negative in all of the forums so far and you should really stop it.

Jan 12, 3:14 AM

#10

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

NickReyes said:
@Confused_100 Nah I think the second episode is still pretty good but it's a shame that they skipped chapters 2 and 3.Also I've read the manga as well and I think that TMS is doing a good job for now not amazing or anything but still a good adaptation.I've seen you being very negative in all of the forums so far and you should really stop it.

I haven’t just been negative. You are taking me out of context to dismiss what I say. Your opinion is that you see it as “pretty good”, cool more power to you. But guess what? Majority aren’t you, most people thought it just looked okay.

Second episode btw did have worse composition than first one, it’s a fact. Just look at when lu first punched in the episode. Or when sakamoto fought, worse composition compared to warehouse fight in first episode.

Again you can like it, like how I can dislike it and criticise it because I want it to be better. And if you play the game of “too negative” again with me, you won’t like my responses because anyone who tries to silence people who want a better product for one of their favourite mangas isn’t a fan to begin with and shouldn’t even be here.

Jan 12, 3:19 AM

#11

SideCharacterKal

Offline

Apr 2018

5485

Reply to NickReyes

@Confused_100 Nah I think the second episode is still pretty good but it's a shame that they skipped chapters 2 and 3.Also I've read the manga as well and I think that TMS is doing a good job for now not amazing or anything but still a good adaptation.I've seen you being very negative in all of the forums so far and you should really stop it.

@NickReyes You've read the manga with your eyes closed if you genuinely say that this is a good adaptation.

“You yourself have to change first, or nothing will change for you!”

'

Jan 12, 3:24 AM

#12

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to Confused_100

NickReyes said:
@Confused_100 Nah I think the second episode is still pretty good but it's a shame that they skipped chapters 2 and 3.Also I've read the manga as well and I think that TMS is doing a good job for now not amazing or anything but still a good adaptation.I've seen you being very negative in all of the forums so far and you should really stop it.

I haven’t just been negative. You are taking me out of context to dismiss what I say. Your opinion is that you see it as “pretty good”, cool more power to you. But guess what? Majority aren’t you, most people thought it just looked okay.

Second episode btw did have worse composition than first one, it’s a fact. Just look at when lu first punched in the episode. Or when sakamoto fought, worse composition compared to warehouse fight in first episode.

Again you can like it, like how I can dislike it and criticise it because I want it to be better. And if you play the game of “too negative” again with me, you won’t like my responses because anyone who tries to silence people who want a better product for one of their favourite mangas isn’t a fan to begin with and shouldn’t even be here.

@Confused_100 Quite strange that you said majority aren't like me even though people from reddit themselves which is probably where all the doompost comes from appreciated what TMS is doing though.Also,I still think that the composition in the second episode is not that bad though.Lastly, you can't really call someone who enjoyed the anime as not a fan of the manga lol, a lot of people still enjoyed the anime while being a big fan.Then again if you still hated the anime it's also fine cause everyone wanted the best for their manga.

Jan 12, 3:26 AM

#13

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to SideCharacterKal

@NickReyes You've read the manga with your eyes closed if you genuinely say that this is a good adaptation.

@SideCharacterKal Funnily enough I do think that it's a good adaptation because TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga and I really appreciated it lol.Other than that, as long as they did not make the animation worst than it is I think it's fine.

Jan 12, 3:27 AM

#14

SenpaiTM

Level 6 esper

Offline

May 2021

1093

Anime is amazing, it still looks better than 80 percent of Media.

“Do what feels right in your heart. You will be criticized either way.” (Eleanor Roosevelt)

Jan 12, 3:35 AM

#15

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

NickReyes said:
@Confused_100 Quite strange that you said majority aren't like me even though people from reddit themselves which is probably where all the doompost comes from appreciated what TMS is doing though.Also,I still think that the composition in the second episode is not that bad though.Lastly, you can't really call someone who enjoyed the anime as not a fan of the manga lol, a lot of people still enjoyed the anime while being a big fan.Then again if you still hated the anime it's also fine cause everyone wanted the best for their manga.

Again taking me out of context on purpose… I never said since you liked it, you aren’t a fan. Actually read what I said…

I literally said if you want to silence any kind of criticism from a person wanting better, you aren’t a fan. That was clear in what I said nothing to do with you enjoying it or not.

Now ironically enough, reddit is pretty mixed and that’s where toxic positivity lies in any website LMAO. Surprise are you new to reddit? Proof of what majority felt? You see the reaction when solo leveling released after? Sakadays talk went “…”. Why? Because the people who were saying it’s pretty good like yourself now understand what pretty good is. Then second episode fights were watched and it actually didn’t look any better. Dude even dr stone from studio looks better than this. That’s to me is disrespect. The schedule system for Sakadays isn’t looking any better.

I did say I was wrong because I expected worse but got mid instead. It’s acceptable but there comes a time, it’s not. Imagine the great fights to come with this kind of animation. Something that should be better than any JJK fight has this. I am not asking it to have JJK animation or Demon Slayer. I want it to be treated with respect and love like Dandadan. And so far I am not seeing that. Btw I am not saying the same style of Dandadan since you are so great with taking people out of context…

Jan 12, 3:37 AM

#16

1List2RuleThemAl

Offline

Jan 2019

163

Like with most 3D in anime, this show just feels bad when watching.

It feels like every few seconds there's a stutter happening. Some genius thought that was a good idea when making an animated 3D show.

Just to be clear, I'm fine with the visual style, but the issue is the way it's animated. The animations are playing like a game is stuttering, and it just looks awful. It's like, either the anime directors go shitty laggy 20 FPS animation using CGI or they go fill 60FPS with weird stuttering look.

If you're going to do high FPS visuals, don't animate them like this. I'll watch some more of the show to decide what I think of the story, I've only seen the first episode and the animation kept bothering me.

Jan 12, 3:37 AM

#17

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

NickReyes said:
@SideCharacterKal Funnily enough I do think that it's a good adaptation because TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga and I really appreciated it lol.Other than that, as long as they did not make the animation worst than it is I think it's fine.

This could be the most oxymoron comment in this thread because you literally contradicted yourself when you disliked that they ignored and removed content from 2 whole chapters…

And yes I know the chapters aren’t that important but it’s still worse than “adding scenes”

Jan 12, 3:53 AM

#18

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to Confused_100

NickReyes said:
@Confused_100 Quite strange that you said majority aren't like me even though people from reddit themselves which is probably where all the doompost comes from appreciated what TMS is doing though.Also,I still think that the composition in the second episode is not that bad though.Lastly, you can't really call someone who enjoyed the anime as not a fan of the manga lol, a lot of people still enjoyed the anime while being a big fan.Then again if you still hated the anime it's also fine cause everyone wanted the best for their manga.

Again taking me out of context on purpose… I never said since you liked it, you aren’t a fan. Actually read what I said…

I literally said if you want to silence any kind of criticism from a person wanting better, you aren’t a fan. That was clear in what I said nothing to do with you enjoying it or not.

Now ironically enough, reddit is pretty mixed and that’s where toxic positivity lies in any website LMAO. Surprise are you new to reddit? Proof of what majority felt? You see the reaction when solo leveling released after? Sakadays talk went “…”. Why? Because the people who were saying it’s pretty good like yourself now understand what pretty good is. Then second episode fights were watched and it actually didn’t look any better. Dude even dr stone from studio looks better than this. That’s to me is disrespect. The schedule system for Sakadays isn’t looking any better.

I did say I was wrong because I expected worse but got mid instead. It’s acceptable but there comes a time, it’s not. Imagine the great fights to come with this kind of animation. Something that should be better than any JJK fight has this. I am not asking it to have JJK animation or Demon Slayer. I want it to be treated with respect and love like Dandadan. And so far I am not seeing that. Btw I am not saying the same style of Dandadan since you are so great with taking people out of context…

@Confused_100 No one complained as much as you right now lol.You must have lead a very sad life right now.Other people that watched the second episode also did not complained as much as you right now.Again I'm sure that TMS will cook later on probably the amusement arc or when Sakamoto vs boiled.Just calm down and enjoy it for what it is for now.This is also the same studio that made megalo box which has an okay animation and megalo box nomad that have an amazing animation.So I'm sure they'll cook.If they don't then you are right I'm retarded haha.

Jan 12, 3:53 AM

#19

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

ryzxgum said:
@Confused_100 i didn't say you, learn to read. again, the pictures proved nothing, and neither did actually watching the show. like i said, if there are such examples then actually show something because mushoku definitely ain't it. stop going in circles without proving anything, i'm still waiting.

How did the pictures prove nothing? Lu looked worse with that filter on… While in MT, I don’t remember her name tbh looks good with it. It’s clear as day, which one looked better.

Like how? You need to explain what kind of examples you want then other than we waste eachother times here.

Jan 12, 3:57 AM

#20

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

NickReyes said:
@Confused_100 No one complained as much as you right now lol.You must have lead a very sad life right now.Other people that watched the second episode also did not complained as much as you right now.Again I'm sure that TMS will cook later on probably the amusement arc or when Sakamoto vs boiled.Just calm down and enjoy it for what it is for now.This is also the same studio that made megalo box which has an okay animation and megalo box nomad that have an amazing animation.So I'm sure they'll cook.If they don't then you are right I'm retarded haha.

Bruh there are people who criticised more than me… But sure say “complained” if that will make you feel better.

And thanks man, I really needed that life check on how sad it is. What’s that got to do with anything? LMAO

Atleast the rest is more acceptable, your point is that you are sure it will look way better when it arrives to it, okay. I hope you are right and I am wrong then, why? Because that would make me happy lol. But as of right now with what we are seeing? You can’t fault anyone for wanting better, and that’s the main point.

Jan 12, 4:01 AM

#21

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

ryzxgum said:
@Confused_100 coughing baby vs coughing baby. you have been wasting time since the start by giving one lame example, this is just a pathetic attempt. clear as day that you can't even prove anything by now, just move along.

And no response to what I asked. I actually asked what kind of example you want and you respond talking about me (nothing to do with what I said).

Ironic how you resorted to being a schizo though lol. Have a good day, bro. Try to understand people before talking, an advice in life.

Jan 12, 4:30 AM

#22

SideCharacterKal

Offline

Apr 2018

5485

Reply to NickReyes

@SideCharacterKal Funnily enough I do think that it's a good adaptation because TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga and I really appreciated it lol.Other than that, as long as they did not make the animation worst than it is I think it's fine.

@NickReyes Adding original scenes doesn't make it a good adaptation lmao. They've cut off chapter 2 and 3 and completely changed the gun disassembling scene. Also the animation you're talking about is just full of added effects to make the stiff frames look alive. All those speed lines, windy effects, explosions are just to cover up the shitty direction/storyboarding of the episode (anime).

I just don't understand how you can't see a pattern in this. Every scene looks so soulles with the same shit over and over. Slow-mo, blur, every type of effect (VFX) one can imagine.

Also all people that defend this are always the same herd saying the same bullshit. No one needs JJK2 or DS "level of animation". There are legit other adaptations that are insanely well done. Espically all the WSJ titles that got good adaptations.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SakamotoDays/comments/1hmrgn1/comment/m3x48zs/?share_id=26DJPLTQgnDPqc7x7MvHm
Read what the top comment of this post summarised.

“You yourself have to change first, or nothing will change for you!”

'

Jan 12, 6:15 AM

#23

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

@yg Yeah I understand your main point, he isn’t getting for some reason though. His hate for MT is that high lol.

Thanks for the other examples though especially from episode 2.

Jan 12, 3:59 PM

#24

RobertBobert

Offline

Apr 2012

21911

It's funny how this show left me with the impression of Househusband with action. Because animation gives exactly the same “animated manga” vibes. Although in much better shape.

Jan 12, 4:22 PM

#25

ReXiRa

Offline

Nov 2022

257

Unknown_Guy100 said:
The animation is ok...I mean i still think the anime will be good....but the animation is just mid....it could have been soo much better....

This is such a funny observation when they added more shin scenes in the warehouse and also that scene where sakamoto deflects shin's bullet with the candy is just amplified when it was just 2 pages in the manga

Like we get it, you want more dragon ball super unreadable choreography, big deal

Jan 12, 5:33 PM

#26

Oongbuh

Offline

Apr 2021

1518

Reply to 1List2RuleThemAl

Like with most 3D in anime, this show just feels bad when watching.

It feels like every few seconds there's a stutter happening. Some genius thought that was a good idea when making an animated 3D show.

Just to be clear, I'm fine with the visual style, but the issue is the way it's animated. The animations are playing like a game is stuttering, and it just looks awful. It's like, either the anime directors go shitty laggy 20 FPS animation using CGI or they go fill 60FPS with weird stuttering look.

If you're going to do high FPS visuals, don't animate them like this. I'll watch some more of the show to decide what I think of the story, I've only seen the first episode and the animation kept bothering me.

@1List2RuleThemAl You're making a whole rant about 3D in anime when there's almost no visible 3D in this series.

Jan 12, 5:39 PM

#27

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

@yg Really ignore him, bro. Like I said he isn’t here to be constructive, he just a crybaby cursing anyone who doesn’t share his opinion. I doubt he has an opinion of his own atp.

Ignore him, and he will disappear lol. Not even kidding. You tried and gave a full link with extra pictures and composition and he still on you like you were with his mother or sth.

Jan 12, 8:34 PM

#28

Treyv0n

Offline

Apr 2021

1836

Jesus FUCK yall are complaining about ANYTHTING about this animation when nothing is bad about it it’s actually funny how you ppl are grasping at anything just to say the animation is bad😭

Jan 12, 9:08 PM

#29

Unknown_Guy100

Offline

Nov 2024

28

Blumarine210 said:

Unknown_Guy100 said:
The animation is ok...I mean i still think the anime will be good....but the animation is just mid....it could have been soo much better....

We've only one episode dude let's wait to see the main fights of this season.

yup....I will see the whole season...i hope it does justice with the action scenes...🤞

Jan 13, 4:03 AM

#30

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

Treyv0n said:
Jesus FUCK yall are complaining about ANYTHTING about this animation when nothing is bad about it it’s actually funny how you ppl are grasping at anything just to say the animation is bad😭

You have to be blind to say this animation looks good as well you know that right?

Jan 13, 10:28 AM

#31

Offline

Dec 2020

87

Reply to NickReyes

@SideCharacterKal Funnily enough I do think that it's a good adaptation because TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga and I really appreciated it lol.Other than that, as long as they did not make the animation worst than it is I think it's fine.

NickReyes said:
TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga

Let me ask this
Were those scene even on par with the manga let alone how they removed pages from chapter 2 and completely removed chapter 3 and went to ch 4

Jan 13, 10:29 AM

#32

Offline

Dec 2020

87

Reply to NickReyes

@Confused_100 No one complained as much as you right now lol.You must have lead a very sad life right now.Other people that watched the second episode also did not complained as much as you right now.Again I'm sure that TMS will cook later on probably the amusement arc or when Sakamoto vs boiled.Just calm down and enjoy it for what it is for now.This is also the same studio that made megalo box which has an okay animation and megalo box nomad that have an amazing animation.So I'm sure they'll cook.If they don't then you are right I'm retarded haha.

NickReyes said:
same studio that made megalo box

"Same studio"
Not the same staff

Jan 13, 10:33 AM

#33

Offline

Dec 2020

87

Reply to SideCharacterKal

@NickReyes Adding original scenes doesn't make it a good adaptation lmao. They've cut off chapter 2 and 3 and completely changed the gun disassembling scene. Also the animation you're talking about is just full of added effects to make the stiff frames look alive. All those speed lines, windy effects, explosions are just to cover up the shitty direction/storyboarding of the episode (anime).

I just don't understand how you can't see a pattern in this. Every scene looks so soulles with the same shit over and over. Slow-mo, blur, every type of effect (VFX) one can imagine.

Also all people that defend this are always the same herd saying the same bullshit. No one needs JJK2 or DS "level of animation". There are legit other adaptations that are insanely well done. Espically all the WSJ titles that got good adaptations.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SakamotoDays/comments/1hmrgn1/comment/m3x48zs/?share_id=26DJPLTQgnDPqc7x7MvHm
Read what the top comment of this post summarised.

@SideCharacterKal exactly this!!
Like the only defence that the anime Sakadays defenders uses are
"Atleast it's not Blue Lock level"
Or
"Oh you are just spoilt cuz of JJk & DS"

Like how could you just use the extream ends as an example whole neglecting some actual criticism about the anime

Jan 13, 10:43 AM

#34

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

M-T_S said:
@SideCharacterKal exactly this!!
Like the only defence that the anime Sakadays defenders uses are
"Atleast it's not Blue Lock level"
Or
"Oh you are just spoilt cuz of JJk & DS"

Like how could you just use the extream ends as an example whole neglecting some actual criticism about the anime

Because they aren’t genuine. They try to dismiss any kind of criticism and became fake fans in the process, quite ironic.

Jan 13, 3:43 PM

#35

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to M-T_S

NickReyes said:
TMS did add a lot of scenes that is not even from the manga

Let me ask this
Were those scene even on par with the manga let alone how they removed pages from chapter 2 and completely removed chapter 3 and went to ch 4

@M-T_S Yes those scenes are much better in the anime.For comparisons, Sakamoto gearing up to save shin is better in the anime, shin vs Sakamoto is better in the anime and they even added more scene about shin that explains more about him in the anime rather than a single panel in the manga.Even if they skip chapter 2 and 3 I don't really mind actually since those chapters are not even important.Heck, I don't think Suzuki even remembers nakase lol just like how irrelevant a certain character are in the future.

Jan 13, 3:56 PM

#36

Merve2Love

Offline

Apr 2020

3098

Yeah, looks nice.

Jan 13, 9:11 PM

#37

Offline

Dec 2020

87

Reply to NickReyes

@M-T_S Yes those scenes are much better in the anime.For comparisons, Sakamoto gearing up to save shin is better in the anime, shin vs Sakamoto is better in the anime and they even added more scene about shin that explains more about him in the anime rather than a single panel in the manga.Even if they skip chapter 2 and 3 I don't really mind actually since those chapters are not even important.Heck, I don't think Suzuki even remembers nakase lol just like how irrelevant a certain character are in the future.

NickReyes said:
if they skip chapter 2 and 3 I don't really mind actually since those chapters are not even important

so sakamoto saving his wife isn't important while showing her belif in sakamoto that he isn't gonna kill anyone anymore?

Jan 14, 12:31 AM

#38

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to M-T_S

NickReyes said:
if they skip chapter 2 and 3 I don't really mind actually since those chapters are not even important

so sakamoto saving his wife isn't important while showing her belif in sakamoto that he isn't gonna kill anyone anymore?

@M-T_S Dude that's in episode 2 what the heck are you talking about.They only skip the part where Sakamoto saves his wife which again it's still alright if they skip but if they skip their anniversary then yeah a lot of the wholesome moments are not going to be in it.

Jan 14, 12:42 AM

#39

MrShadowDUH

Czech Pirate

Offline

Aug 2015

18

Bro this thread is hilarious lmao

Anybody who complains about "wish fufilment" on this website should be pelted with rocks.

Jan 14, 5:07 AM

#40

Offline

Feb 2023

1045

NickReyes said:
@M-T_S Dude that's in episode 2 what the heck are you talking about.They only skip the part where Sakamoto saves his wife which again it's still alright if they skip but if they skip their anniversary then yeah a lot of the wholesome moments are not going to be in it.

Your reply makes zero sense because they did remove a lot of content and all you said were fight scenes which ironically are better drawn in the manga… Plus they literally skipped parts of the fights because it will be “hard” to animate. I call cap that you read the manga and just went to reddit to see what the difference is.

Jan 14, 5:45 AM

#41

Offline

Jul 2021

65

Reply to Confused_100

NickReyes said:
@M-T_S Dude that's in episode 2 what the heck are you talking about.They only skip the part where Sakamoto saves his wife which again it's still alright if they skip but if they skip their anniversary then yeah a lot of the wholesome moments are not going to be in it.

Your reply makes zero sense because they did remove a lot of content and all you said were fight scenes which ironically are better drawn in the manga… Plus they literally skipped parts of the fights because it will be “hard” to animate. I call cap that you read the manga and just went to reddit to see what the difference is.

@Confused_100 How did my reply makes zero sense here lol.Please enlighten me about why chapter 2 and 3 are that important other than Sakamoto backstory about why he doesn't kill people anymore which again they did adapt that part in the second episode lol.As far as I know I'm the only one that actually talks about chapter 2 and 3 here though so again quite weird how you tried to say that I didn't read the manga here.Again, you really think that nakase will actually be important in the future?Suzuki might be a great writer now but in the beginning he's not that good.Before calling me a liar here please tell me why chapter 2 and 3 is that important to you mate.

Jan 14, 6:12 AM

#42