[Oshi No Ko]
| People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic. So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced. |
RobertBobertNov 12, 2024 10:12 AM
 |
Reply to Jurn56
RobertBobert said:
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
I personally think it's a great ending tbh. People just don't understand the story and that's the truth. And if people keep spreading misinformation like that (also the incest thing) it will have a negative impact on the anime yes.
| @Jurn56 Leaving the incest thing aside, I honestly find this ending completely contrary to the content and ideas of this manga so far. Even just the chapters that came out a couple of weeks ago. But we are not discussing the ending of the manga itself here, but whether it will negatively affect the anime. |
|
Reply to Jurn56
RobertBobert said:
@Jurn56 Leaving the incest thing aside, I honestly find this ending completely contrary to the content and ideas of this manga so far. Even just the chapters that came out a couple of weeks ago. But we are not discussing the ending of the manga itself here, but whether it will negatively affect the anime.
@Jurn56 Leaving the incest thing aside, I honestly find this ending completely contrary to the content and ideas of this manga so far. Even just the chapters that came out a couple of weeks ago. But we are not discussing the ending of the manga itself here, but whether it will negatively affect the anime.
Youre right it's about the impact on the anime. and honestly I think it will definitily influence the anime. (just like people stopped watching after the incest thing, people will stop watching if everyone says it's a bad ending)
| @Jurn56 Most of the anime fans either read the manga or know most of the spoilers about it, so I don't think they will need to listen to anyone for this. Therefore, it increasingly seems to me that Aka deliberately took a month off during the anime's finale, since he seemed to be well aware that it would be received negatively or at best controversial. |
|
Reply to kkolite
Jurn56 said:
I personally think it's a great ending tbh. People just don't understand the story and that's the truth. And if people keep spreading misinformation like that (also the incest thing) it will have a negative impact on the anime yes.
RobertBobert said:
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
I personally think it's a great ending tbh. People just don't understand the story and that's the truth. And if people keep spreading misinformation like that (also the incest thing) it will have a negative impact on the anime yes.
Rushed and poor ending. Main idea has some problems, but is another talking. imo right now author must write at least 5-7 chapters to complete story. But next chapter will be the last :) so stupid for this story
| @kkolite From what I can see, a lot of anime fans now want him to rewrite or expand on the potential ending of the anime. I think it's unlikely to happen, but if it does, it would be interesting to see it within the rumors that he ruined the manga to spite the editor. |
|
Reply to CheliosX
I think the ending was great, idk what mfs be crying about. They think the ending is ass because Aqua died, ffs, they should grow some more brain cells. Anyways, as for the future of the anime, I don't think that'll happen.
| @CheliosX I could say that the reasons have already been discussed many times, but what's the point of arguing about something if you're just insulting people who have a different opinion about the ending? |
|
Reply to CheliosX
RobertBobert said:
@CheliosX I could say that the reasons have already been discussed many times, but what's the point of arguing about something if you're just insulting people who have a different opinion about the ending?
@CheliosX I could say that the reasons have already been discussed many times, but what's the point of arguing about something if you're just insulting people who have a different opinion about the ending?
To. those that didn't like the ending, sure, I respect that. But I have come across multiple individuals that were celebrating and promoting negativity of the manga. Even if a manga ending is bad or bad in general, I'll still congratulate and thank the mangaka but no, these ones didn't do that. They're the ones I was insulting.
| @CheliosX So you insulted people because the bad ending to their favorite manga made them feel bad? |
|
Reply to CheliosX
RobertBobert said:
@CheliosX So you insulted people because the bad ending to their favorite manga made them feel bad?
@CheliosX So you insulted people because the bad ending to their favorite manga made them feel bad?
Favorite manga? Bad ending? Again, the ending being bad was their own opinion and I never said anything about ONK being their favorite manga. What they gave to me, I have back to them. It's called karma. ๐๐๐พ
| @CheliosX You're just looking for a reason to insult people with different opinions, that's all I see, sorry. |
|
Reply to CheliosX
RobertBobert said:
@CheliosX You're just looking for a reason to insult people with different opinions, that's all I see, sorry.
@CheliosX You're just looking for a reason to insult people with different opinions, that's all I see, sorry.
If that's all you see, sure. No one's gonna charge at you for that.
I call out whoever promotes negativity of any manga and does not give any word of thanks to the mangaka. It's wrong.
| @CheliosX People have the right to be negative towards the author if he at least subjectively ruined their favorite story. Especially if this destruction itself was very negative. None of them harass or threaten the author, thank God. |
|
Reply to godzilla9637
all we can do is pray for an anime original ending
| @godzilla9637 I just realized a couple of hours ago that we will also have live action later this month. So, Aka potentially created problems for those who were involved in the production of JDrama based on his work as well. |
|
Reply to NegativeRei
you should really post these kind of threads in the manga section
| @NegativeRei This thread is about the third season of the anime, not the manga. |
|
Reply to NegativeRei
It's possible for people to give spoilers about the ending. Also, you're asking for others opinion about the "manga" ending.
| @NegativeRei What are you talking about? I explicitly disclaimed spoilers in the description and wrote that this is not a thread to discuss the ending itself. |
|
Reply to NegativeRei
RobertBobert said:
@NegativeRei What are you talking about? I explicitly disclaimed spoilers in the description and wrote that this is not a thread to discuss the ending itself.
@NegativeRei What are you talking about? I explicitly disclaimed spoilers in the description and wrote that this is not a thread to discuss the ending itself.
most of the comments here are people's thoughts about the ending
| @NegativeRei Can I manage these people? |
|
Reply to NegativeRei
Don't get offended, brother. I just thought you should've posted this thread in the manga section because most of the manga readers are caught up to the anime.
| @NegativeRei Perhaps, but this is not a manga thread. |
|
| What's the deal with popular manga getting awful endings recently? First AOT, then MHA and JJK and now Oshi no Ko. |
 |
Reply to Piromysl
What's the deal with popular manga getting awful endings recently?
First AOT, then MHA and JJK and now Oshi no Ko.
First AOT, then MHA and JJK and now Oshi no Ko.
| @Pieromysl This has long been a classic, but the fact that we got 3 of these endings in one year is simply amazing. Not to mention, this is literally the basis of serious part of the current hype anime right now. |
|
Reply to keikei99
RobertBobert said:
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
People have been talking about the ending chapter leaks for a week or two now and how it potentially makes the manga's ending even worse than the overly vague and murky endings of MHA and JJK (no spoilers or speculation on leaks from me, just watch how people react to all this on reddit and YouTube), but what about the anime? Do you think this will be a blow to people's expectations for season three? At least for you? Personally, it seems to me that even if Aka (potentially) waited a month so that the ending of the manga did not hit the finale of the second season, the third will not start airing until next year and we will already have a lot of fans who will either be hostile and biased against the title, or will lose any motivation to follow the story and become apathetic.
So, don't you think that in addition to the extremely controversial conclusion of the incredibly popular manga, Aka also potentially torpedoed its anime potential, whose new season was only recently announced.
I think the 3rd season will again be really popular, given that I think people might want to check out a series that had been very criticized. The animes potential also still lasts because the 2nd season ends at the perfect spot to turn some stuff around and make an original ending. However, whether Akasaka will approve this approach or not can't really be guessed.
| @keikei99 I thought a lot of people would still be watching the adaptation to see if it would get a new ending or at least change it in some way, given that it was widely criticized even in Japan and it would be expected that under some conditions Aka might want to change it . But more often than not, I meet people who simply express a loss of motivation for interest in anime, knowing what this will ultimately lead to. In particular, many people wrote that they mistakenly supported this manga because they expected it to be a motivational and inspiring story about how to overcome your difficulties instead of ending up suffering from them in the end anyway. @Flaming_Dezi Then they will have to come up with a lot of original material, including closing a lot of subplots instead of Aka. Which one way or another will still result in a change in the ending. I doubt it will go the way of Shaman King, when the studio completely rewrote the ending (and when the remake brought it back anyway), but it could be similar to the case with Bleach, where Kubo was forced to essentially rewrite the ending again for the sake of a clearer conclusion to the manga. |
|
| idk but Aka's decisions about the manga might directly hurt him if you know what I mean๐๐๐ |
 |
| I personally won't watch it. Pretty much all the plot points, mysteries and character development that will happen in s3 are just bait and will be thrown in the trash so not going to waste my time. |
Reply to Flaming_Dezi
@RobertBobert Thanks, I have been I fan for a while and started to catch up and read the manga, I just hope something’s changes because I hate to see one of my favorite series get ruined like that
| @Flaming_Dezi Aka is already being attacked by large Chinese influencers with tens or even hundreds of thousands of followers, so if this doesn't get at least some damage control, then things could go very far indeed. Especially considering that his new manga does not look like a guaranteed hit. |
|
Reply to GRG3
The ending will probably not affect the anime that heavily. Honestly, i believe they're prob adapt it to the same amount.
| @GRG3 In this case, I am afraid that Aka will fail not only as the author of a popular manga, but also as the author of the original of a popular anime. Moreover, even judging by the post above, you at least partially understand why. Once upon a time he basked in the glory and people adored him, but now people greet the announcement of his new work with ridicule, and he himself is apparently afraid even to go on Twitter. |
|
| Shit ending killed my interest in reading manga further than what anime covered (I dropped it before anime in the middle of stage play arc). |
 |
More topics from this board
» anime og ending?hananotou - Mar 24 |
16 |
by Amairs
»»
Mar 30, 3:40 PM |
|
» Has the knowledge of fan reception to the manga ending hurt your hype for season 3 (and beyond?) NO SPOILERSFrierenSimpKing - Dec 7, 2024 |
38 |
by boyswhatup
»»
Mar 18, 11:10 PM |
|
» New KV, will start from 2026ARK-13 - Feb 2 |
14 |
by Ricdumb
»»
Feb 2, 12:36 PM |
|
» Predictions for opening and ending theme songs?dazedcowcow62 - Oct 7, 2024 |
17 |
by DUFFAL0
»»
Jan 26, 12:11 AM |
|
» Release Date Speculation?Hamon- - Dec 3, 2024 |
7 |
by Dan_ALves
»»
Dec 4, 2024 3:43 PM |